Jail term increased for hammer attacker who blinded Louth grandmother in one eye


Sentence increased for hammer attacker who tied up “Good Samaritan” grandmother
A violent criminal who carried out a three-hour hammer attack on a “Good Samaritan” grandmother, leaving her blind in one eye after tying her up and threatening to kill her, has had his jail sentence increased by two years following a successful appeal by the State.
Gerard Stokes (44) and his co-accused Samantha Campbell (37) were convicted of inflicting what a judge described as a “punishment beating” on the woman over alleged missing drugs.
The Director of Public Prosecutions sought a review of the sentences on the grounds that they were unduly lenient, while Campbell had cross-appealed the severity of her own term of imprisonment.
The Court of Appeal on Tuesday found that Stoke’s 13-and-a-half-year jail term, with two years suspended, was unduly lenient. It instead resentenced him to 14-and-a-half-years, with one year suspended.
However, the court ruled that Campbell’s ten-year sentence was not too lenient. It also dismissed the mother of seven’s appeal against the severity of her sentence, finding that she was “an instigator and enthusiastic participant” in the attacks and was not "subjugated" by Stokes.
Stokes and Campbell, both with addresses in Muirhevnamór, Dundalk, were convicted by a jury at Dundalk Circuit Court following a three-week trial in February 2024 of seriously assaulting the woman at Stokes’ home and falsely imprisoning her. They were also convicted of assaulting her friend causing harm and carrying out an aggravated burglary at that friend’s home in Waterville Crescent on December 5, 2018.
Judge Dara Hayes jailed Stokes for 13-and-a-half-year with two years suspended, while Campbell received a 12-year term, with two years suspended.
The court heard the victim lost an eye in the attack and now uses a prosthesis.
Delivering judgment on Tuesday, Mr Justice Patrick McCarthy said that both defendants “participated willingly” in the attack and the jury accepted that this was joint enterprise. He said that while Stokes inflicted the most serious harm with the hammer, Campbell had “asked to go first”.
Mr Justice McCarthy described the victim today as a “good Samaritan” who had known both assailants for years, She said in her statement that she had been friends with Campbell all her life, used to give her mother food and had babysat for her.
He noted the victim was asked by Stokes to “mind a package for him”. He said she agreed to do so “in fear” and was afraid that the package contained drugs. He said the package did in fact contain cocaine.
After the victim returned the parcel some days later, it was alleged that some portion of the contents was missing.
The judge noted the first intimation of violence occurred when Campbell punched the victim in the face and pulled her hair.
Stokes then told the woman to turn off her phone, took it from her and instructed the victim to stand on black bin bags which had been laid out on the floor.
Mr Justice McCarthy said the pair then “violently assaulted” the woman, before Stokes told Campbell that punching and kicking was of no use, and it was time to “finish her off”.
Stokes picked up a hammer and struck the woman a number of times on her body, before telling her he was going to kill her and striking her in the head, including blows to her right eye. After she fell to the ground, she was forced into one of the black bin bags and Stokes pulled the drawcord closed.
The woman sustained significant injuries in the attack, including the rupturing of her right eye leading to its loss and fractures of several facial bones, for which she had plates inserted and significant bruising.
As she was becoming unconscious and, in an attempt to save her own life, the woman said that the package was at a friend’s house, though this was not the case.
Stokes and Campbell put the victim in a car and drove to this person’s house, having told another individual to burn the hammer, the victim’s phone and the plastic bin bags. Both defendants assaulted the second woman but fled the scene after gardai arrived.
Mr Justice McCarthy noted that the second woman’s ordeal lasted several minutes, while the attack on the first victim lasted approximately three hours.
The judge said Campbell had argued that her jail term was too severe and the sentencing judge had failed to sufficiently distinguish between the two defendant’s culpability and personal circumstances.
It had been asserted, Mr Justice McCarthy said, that Campbell was “emotionally and financially” dependent on Stokes for all her needs and that she was “subjugated by him”.
However, he said the court found that on the evidence, there was no basis for arguing that Stokes exercised a dominant influence over Campbell.
“Whatever about her relationship with Stokes in other areas of her personal life, the evidence showed that on the day of her offences she did not display any sign of acting under compulsion or pressure from Stokes,” he said.
“On the contrary, it showed that she was an instigator and enthusiastic participant.”
He said the DPP, in seeking a review of the terms imposed on both defendants, had argued that the level of injury suffered by the victim was very high, resulting in her losing an eye.
It was also submitted that there was a high degree of premeditation involved in the attack and the victim believed she was about to be killed, as she was assaulted whilst being held in a black plastic bag. The DPP also highlighted the fact that the offences occurred in more than one location.
Mr Justice McCarthy rejected the State's argument that there was no basis for imposing different headline sentences on the two defendants, saying the trial judge was in an “exceptionally strong position” to decide on the relative culpability of each.
“We are not persuaded that the distinction he made in nominating the headline sentences, and in particular the identification of the lower headline sentence of 12 years and 9 months in Campbell's case, constituted an error on the evidence. It was accordingly neither unduly lenient nor excessive,” he said, dismissing both appeals in Campbell’s case.
The judge said Stokes’ offending was aggravated by his relevant previous convictions, noting that these included those for the sale or supply of drugs, extortion and witness intimidation.
He said the court would quash Stoke’s conviction and set a new headline term of 17 and a half years. Mr Justice McCarthy said the trial judge fell into error when he took the view that Stoke’s previous convictions were not aggravating factors and failed to set a headline sentence in line with the fact that this case fell into the “most serious or exceptional class”.
After hearing submissions from Stoke’s barrister Roderick O’Hanlon, Mr Justice McCarthy re-sentenced the defendant to 14-and-a-half years, with one suspended. He noted that there was “some grounds for hope”, given Stokes' good behavioural record in prison and his efforts to address his difficulties with controlled drugs.
Passing sentence at Dundalk Circuit Court, Judge Hayes said that what occurred was effectively a “punishment beating’” over alleged missing drugs. He noted the woman was fearful of giving evidence and said he understood her reluctance to attend court.
The court heard Stokes and Campbell have two children together.
Stokes has 14 previous convictions, including for the possession of drugs for sale or supply, blackmail/extortion and witness intimidation.
Campbell has eight previous convictions, including for the possession of drugs for sale or supply and road traffic offences.
In her Victim Impact Statement, the grandmother of nine said the attack “took my whole life away from me…People pass me on the streets and don’t even know me. It kills me inside, so now I don’t leave the house.”