We must get realistic about where the club is now


The Commentary Box | Gerry Malone
Dundalk were left in serious trouble following a 2-1 defeat by league leaders Shelbourne at Tolka Park last Friday night. In front of a sellout crowd, Shelbourne increased their lead at the top as they brushed aside a Dundalk team that even at this early stage of the season may be doomed for relegation.
In the first half Dundalk went toe-to-toe with Shelbourne. They were good in defence and midfield. But up front they offered nothing. The pressure is mounting on manager Stephen O'Donnell after this terrible start to the season, the worst since 1972 when Dundalk had a mostly all local team managed by Fran Brennan.
The manager has been criticised in the past by supporters, the local media including me and by other pundits. But although he does bear some responsibility for how bad things are this season, it should be remembered that he was asked to put together a new squad in the space of a month at the start of January.
For much of last season the boss spoke about how much he was looking forward to strengthening his squad but not facing the situation he faced in 2023 when he also had to put a new team out of nothing. The 2023 team just missed out on Europe and when I look at the situation now one can see how good an achievement that was.
But this season time seems to have run out for the manager in regards to building a squad that would see Dundalk challenge for Europe once again. O'Donnell along with Brian Gartland have signed a very young squad who just seem to be out of their depth and who cannot cope with the high standard of the League of Ireland.
I arrived in Tolka Park at half four well ahead of kick off time. I always like to give myself time as one never knows if one is going to be held up by unforeseen circumstances such as road accidents or traffic delays. At four fifty I saw the Dundalk boss walk across the hallowed turf of the home of Shelbourne.
He was alone and obviously wanted to get things clear in his mind ahead of the big game. He sat in the visitors' dugout for 15 to 20 minutes before he was on the move walking up and down the pitch again.
The manager did this walking on the pitch mostly alone for two hours minimum. To me I took this solitary thought process by the manager as a way of asking himself if there is anything he can do to get Dundalk out of the current rut. The goals all came in the second half. Liam Burt struck a stunning goal for the leaders on 51 minutes. He ran at and was passed by four Dundalk players to shoot home a great effort.
The Dublin side deserved their lead for how they began the second half. The way Burt cut the Dundalk midfield and defence just shows how shaky the team is. Mark Coyle fed Burt on the halfway line.
The young Scot skipped between two defenders and past a third before riffling a dream shot over Ross Munro for a terrific goal. Burt was instrumental in Shelbourne's second goal when his cross on 74 minutes from the left was turned into his own net by Hayden Muller. There was no way back after that as Shelbourne dominated the last 15 minutes.
Dundalk did get a goal back two minutes into injury time when John Mountney's cross was headed home by Robbie Benson. There was no chance of an equaliser as the referee blew the whistle for full time. After the game I posed a few questions to the Dundalk manager Stephen O'Donnell. I began by saying to the boss that Dundalk have now had their worst start in the league since 1972.
I said to him that the club was in big trouble. “Yes we know we have not begun the season well. There is no point in dwelling on it,” said the manager. “We have to get ready for the challenge ahead. I believe in the players that we have, and I honestly believe that they can help to get Dundalk out of trouble. Again we have to play with more incisiveness and with penetration. We need to think more aggressively in our play. There is no doubt about that.”
The manager said that he is not really concerned about his own future at Oriel. “It's not about me. I am not going to concern myself if I have long to go. My job is to prepare the team for games ahead.
That's my remit. “That's my job” the manager told me. When asked did he thought he had long left if things continued as they were, O'Donnell said how would he know. He said to me it was a silly question and not to ask him silly questions. I said it was not a silly question.
The manager told me that he is not disillusioned at the way things were. “I don't really get disillusioned as there is a job to do. It's a massive job now. In regards the games going forward.”
I asked Stephen if he ever thought of just walking away. “No, I'm not that type. I'm not going to walk away. Look I gave up a lot to come to this club. I gave up a hell of a lot. That's my feelings towards the club. This club came sixth in 2021 with a plethora of players before I came. There were league winners in the team of 2021”, the manager said.
“They came third the season before that in 2020 after 18 games” that was when covid 19 disrupted the whole league programme. The manager said that Dundalk were struggling long before he came.
Stephen said the fact the club were struggling long before he came is the bottom line. The manager said that he has done a hell of a job the last two years since he came in. Stephen said there were only two players signed when he came in at the end of 2021. They came third in his first season in 2022.
They were beaten to the runners up spot on goal difference by Derry City. People often forget that Brian Ainscough came in at the beginning of December. The manager says the domestic players were gone. He said the club lost players to Derry City because the club could not act.
The bottom line was where the market was. The club had once again got to try to attract players from the UK. Many were coming in at the start of their careers just ten days before the window closed before the start of the season. O'Donnell says that was where Dundalk were at. That's where Dundalk are at. So people need to realise this.
The manager says the club was not going great before he came in. He again said he had given up a hell of a lot to come to Dundalk. That was as far as he was concerned the bottom line. He said he was sick of people questioning things. People he said needed to realise where the club are at and that is with a group consisting of many young players. People he said, need to realise where the club has been at for the past three years. Stephen said that that was it and again said everybody needs to realise that.
Stephen O'Donnell gave a very passionate interview which was one where he gave a top class defence of why the club is at where it is at. And very few would disagree with him on that. In his first season he guided Dundalk into Europe finishing third. This was in 2022. The season before that the club was in a very vulnerable state. Bill Hulsizer of Peak 6 was in charge and made some very questionable decisions.
The club had four different managers that season. Filippo Giovagnoli, was appointed permanent manager in December 2020. He had guided Dundalk to the FAI Cup the same year. He also guided the club to the group stages of the Europa League which was a great achievement.
In 2021 the club was shaken by the loss of many of its top stars. Filippo was replaced as manager before the start of season 2021. Shane Keegan was the new boss. Filippo was still the real boss. Shane Keegan was appointed manager as he had the full coaching badge needed to manage in Europe.
But Filippo was not happy with the decision and left the club in the early part of season 2021. Shane Keegan was now the full-time manager in more than name. Things did not go Dundalk's way in the first couple of months on the pitch, Shane quickly departed. Sporting Director Jim Magilton now took charge.
The Belfast man had no intention of getting involved in the football side of things on the pitch. He was thrust into the job. Things went well at the start but then Magilton struggled. Eventually Bill Hulsizer brought Vinny Perth back to become manager for the second time in his career. Dundalk were in relegation trouble near the bottom. Vinny guided Dundalk to mid-table. It was a great achievement given where the club was at when he came back.
In November 2021 Peak 6 departed. Andy Connolly returned as a new owner for the second time. StatSports under Alan Clarke and Sean O'Connor were the new owners. Dundalk supporters were happy the club was back in local hands. In December Stephen O'Donnell was appointed manager.
Stephen assembled a decent squad, some from the UK and others from Europe. There were of course league of Ireland players there as well. Dundalk finished third and were in Europe again. But things began to change at the end of season 2022. Dundalk were forced to recruit from the UK and other countries. They failed to attract League of Ireland players.
They finished fifth but just missed out on Europe in season 2023. But there was a mass clear out of players. Manager Stephen O'Donnell allowed top scorer Pat Hoban to depart to Derry in January of this year. New owner Brian Ainscough took on the brave decision to run the club.
Andy Connolly and StatSports pulled out. Brian took over a club that was in somewhat of a mess. Darragh Leahy, another player under contract, left. Nathan Shepperd, Alfie Lewis, Greg Sloggett and John Martin also left. These were all terrific players. Why did they decide to leave Dundalk? Keith Ward also left.
Thus, for this season the manager was forced to raid the UK for players, 12 of whom arrived with only two weeks to the start of the new season. Many of the players as Stephen O'Donnell says are very young and are just starting their careers. This Is where Dundalk are at. But I have to say I feel Dundalk should have been able to keep some of their players from last season.
It was surprising to see Hoban and Leahy go. John Martin should also have been persuaded to stay. Connor Malley was also a surprise departure. I just do not understand why he was not kept either. Had Nathan Shepperd stayed any goalkeeping difficulties would have been erased at Dundalk.
The club did have a chance to keep Nathan under the previous owners. Why did all these players depart? Hoban and Leahy should have been kept. They were two players who were in contract for this season. Darragh Leahy went to Waterford while Pat Hoban of course went to Derry after being told to find another club by Stephen O'Donnell.
There is no reason why the two could not have stayed. Yet they moved on and Dundalk lost two very experienced players. The manager was right when he told me on Friday night that the club had not been going great before he came in. There is no doubt that Stephen O'Donnell did give up a hell of a lot to come to Dundalk.
He had just won the FAI Cup with St. Pats. He was on top of the world of Irish soccer. Stephen had turned St. Pats into a real force in Irish soccer. The manager was right to emphasise that he had given up much to come to Oriel at the end of 2021. I can understand when he said he was sick of people questioning it.
And as far as I am concerned maybe supporters and the local media must get realistic about where the club is now and where it has been at for the last three years. The manager was right to say that is the bottom line. I have no problems with anything Stephen said to me on Friday night.
But I have to say the club has not just been struggling for the three years prior to Stephen O'Donnell's arrival back to Dundalk. It's been struggling for the past six years. Stephen O'Donnell has done a great job by keeping Dundalk in the top half of the table for the past two seasons. To get Dundalk into Europe was his greatest achievement in 2022.
Last season Dundalk came within a hare's breath of qualifying for Europe yet again. But overall, it was a massive disappointment as the team easily had the guile and talent to get to Europe. For the past three seasons Dundalk have had to look to the UK market to get many of their players. This has been a struggle. This season Dundalk were only able to sign one League of Ireland player.
He came in from UCD. But he has been injured and has yet to play a competitive game. Where Dundalk are at is signing players from the lower leagues in the UK on a permanent or a loan basis. This season the club could lose four players at the end of June as they are on loan from the UK. It has the potential to cause a lot of instability in the squad if Dundalk cannot replace or keep the four.
Off the field one hopes that new owner Brian Ainscough can continue to act as a figure for stability within the club. Next season I would be confident that Dundalk will be able to have a squad fully signed up by early December. There will not have to be any more on loan signings if everything goes right and the club will be able to sign some good League of Ireland players.
When Stephen O'Donnell came into Oriel in December 2022 there may have only been two players who were on the books. But a good group of players decided at the end of the 2021 season to wait who the new manager was going to be named before they committed to other clubs. As a result, Pat Hoban signed a 3-year contract for his new boss when it was confirmed Stephen was the new manager.
Daniel Kelly was another player who signed on the dotted line on a two-year deal. And there were more. Pat Hoban was hopeful that the 3-year deal would ensure he would finish his career at Oriel. He did not of course as he went to Derry at the end of last season with just one more year left on his existing contract.
And so what of the future of Stephen O'Donnell at Oriel. Not counting yesterday's Louth Derby against Drogheda, at the time of writing this piece Dundalk have taken just two points out of a possible 18 after 6 games. They are rock bottom of the table having scored only two goals and conceded 11 goals. They have yet to win a game, drawn two and lost four. The club is in big trouble.
I was prepared after the Derry game next Friday to offer my own opinion on the future of Stephen O'Donnell at Dundalk. But having seen them lose to Shelbourne last Friday I have been coming to the conclusion that maybe it is time for a change at Oriel. But I've thought again and asked what it will achieve. The manager can only deal with the players he has been given.
And getting players in on loan and signing more from the lower leagues of the UK at the last minute has been the usual format for at least the last two seasons. A change of manager will not do much.
But I had to ask Stephen about his future at the club last Friday as the pressure has been growing with such a bad start to the season. He gave his answers clearly and succinctly as to why he was intending to stay. I fully respect what he had to say. It's not easy for a manager to answer such questions. Stephen has never shied away from the difficult questions. I'm sure they do cause pressure for him. It's not nice for a reporter to ask them as well.
But there are times when the hard questions have to be asked and I will never shy away from that. Reporters would be failing in their jobs if they are not prepared to ask such questions when the need arises.
Have a safe week. Please be careful out there and look after each other.