The Commentary Box: It was not to be Dundalk's night in Sligo


The Commentary Box | The Gerry Malone Column
Dundalk went down to their second defeat of the season, when they were beaten 2-0 by Sligo Rovers on Saturday night. Sligo recorded their third win in a row and are unbeaten in four.
Right from the start, I got the feeling it was not going to be their night. They had some very good spells in both halves. But they also conceded goals, they would not normally give away so easily.
Dundalk went into the game with just one change from the side that beat Galway 2-0 at Oriel eight days earlier. JR Wilson was missing through injury. Other than that, it was the same side that had done so well in their previous game.
Harvey Warren nearly turned the ball into his own net early on, as he attempted to clear a Will Fitzgerald ball after just three minutes. Kavanagh and McElroy both had chances from the ensuing corner. Gbemi Arubi was playing with an injured foot.
He came close when a mistake by Jeannot Esua allowed him to shoot from the halfway line. The Sligo keeper was way off his line. Arubi's effort was not far away. Sligo struck for the opening goal on 12 minutes.
Enda Minogue made a complete mess coming for the ball as he attempted to clear. He collided with Sligo's Kavanagh as he attempted to punch the ball clear. The ball came to Will Fitzgerald, who shot to the empty net.
This was the Sligo captain's third goal in as many games. Sligo should have been two up on 23 minutes, when Meekison shot over in front of an empty goal. He missed from six yards.
Dundalk pressed hard for an equaliser as the half wore on. Ronan Teahan came close from the edge of the box after a good run.
But Sligo should have made it two when Meekison missed a second great chance minutes from the break. With Minogue nowhere, the Sligo man amazingly shot wide yet again in front of an empty goal.
But Dundalk were very unlucky not to level two minutes into injury time when Mayowa saw his header in the box from a Horgan corner come crashing off the Sligo crossbar. It was a real let-off for the home team.
There was no way back for Dundalk when Sligo struck for their second goal three minutes after the break. Meekison played Kavanagh in between Mayowa and Harvey Warren. Kavanagh made no mistake from close range. It was game over.
Harry Groome and Shane Tracey came in for Dundalk. Groome in particular had a very good game. Eoin Kenny got a cross into the Sligo box before the substitutions.
Arubi's header was pushed onto the Sligo crossbar by their keeper. Eoin Kenny was moved into centre forward when Gbemi came off.
Harry Groome was able to open up the Sligo defence easily in his midfield role. He put Eoin Kenny away with a great ball. His effort was not far away. Groome then had a 25-yard effort saved superbly by Sligo keeper Sam Sargeant.
The one real positive note of the night was when Leo Gaxha came on as a substitute with 10 minutes remaining. He has been out injured since last June. He has been missed. He replaced Ronan Teahan on the night.
Gaxha was very unlucky right at the death. He had a great shot cleared off the Sligo line. It was not to be Dundalk's night. They had a terrible start with the side conceding an early goal.
The defence was totally out of sorts. Minogue's mistake for the first goal was not good. He did not have a good game. It looks like the manager will have no choice but to bring in Peter Cherrie. He is still a top-class keeper. He may be 43.
That does not matter for a keeper. Dundalk just can not afford to be giving away easy goals, like the one Enda Minogue did. This is a cruel league. If a team makes a mistake, they will be swallowed. That's what happened on Saturday night.
The Dundalk defence was not good on Saturday. Midfield was not much better, and playing Arubi and later Kenny on their own up front made it next to nigh impossible for Dundalk to get back into the game.
Dundalk started both the first and second halves quite poorly. They were good in between times. But that is not good enough. I was not impressed with Sligo either. I thought they were poor as well.
It was a very scrappy affair. Dundalk must put this game behind them and quickly. They play Shelbourne at Oriel on Friday. Then they must go to the RSC ground on Bank holiday Monday to play bottom team, Waterford.
Manager Ciaran Kilduff was 100 per cent right after the Galway game to dampen down the massive expectations that supporters and the local media have of his team.
After seeing Dundalk playing on Saturday, I quite agree with him. Staying in the Premier Division is the most important aim Dundalk must have. They have only been promoted. They are taking the league by storm.
But they must be realistic. Manager Ciaran Kilduff says it's vital Dundalk know how to deal with things when they hit a bad spell. The defeat in Sligo is not the start of a bad spell.
Dundalk have been excellent. But when they do hit a bad spell, they must deal with it.
The Dundalk manager was bitterly disappointed with the result.
''We had a poor first 23 minutes start in the first half and a poor 15 minutes start to the second half. That's when it was lost. We never really recovered after that. We did show positive things in the game.
But we were always chasing it. The first goal was sloppy. But we were sloppy before and after that. My half-time team talk was out the window when they scored so early in the second half, to go two up.
We did create chances. We hit the bar, had an effort cleared off the line, among others. But in the end, we were not good enough.
I never had the word draw come across my mind coming up here. We came here to win. Of course, at 2-0 down, I would have taken the point. But even that was not to be.
"JR Wilson was missing tonight as he has a bit of an issue with his shoulder. He injured it against Galway. He has had a scan. There is a bit of an issue with it. I do not know how long Gbemi lasted as long as he did tonight.
He had a scan yesterday. He is dealing with an issue in his foot. We did a little bit of a patched job on him for tonight's game. We could not have got any more out of Gbemi by the time we replaced him.
JR was badly missing tonight. Conor O'Keeffe is still out injured, and Vinnie Leonard is still missing. So defensively we were trying to plug a few holes.
"That group in there gave everything tonight. They are a very honest group. All of those lads give everything. It would be easy to be critical. I am not. The lads put themselves out there tonight. Sadly, we are coming away with nothing.
"We have been on a very positive run. It's a long time since the Pats beat us 4-0. Good runs can change very quickly. As I have said, this league is very unforgiving. Any team can beat the other in this league.
We play Shelbourne in Oriel on Friday. Shels are a very good side. Yes, we have beaten them in Tolka. And yes, they have yet to win a game at home this season.
Last night Drogheda made a terrific comeback to beat Shels 4-3. But make no mistake. They have terrific players, and we will have to be at their very best to beat them.
"Shelbourne are a very dangerous team. They are a team full of quality. Danny Mullen is another player who Dundalk have been missing for a long spell.
He had an injection at the start of last week. Dundalk have tried everything to get the pain relief into him.
He would never have made the team against Sligo after getting the pain injection. It really is a matter of wait and see for Danny. This sounds very worrying for the Dundalk striker.
He has had his pain management. He has had his rehab. Dundalk must wait to see how long he will be out. It looks like it will be some time.
Conor O'Keeffe will be out for at least another two weeks. He picked up a head injury in a game two weeks ago.
Given that he had a serious head injury last season, Dundalk will not be taking any chances on him. The Dundalk manager is not confident of getting anyone back anytime soon.
On Gbemi Arubi, it appears he has been carrying an injury. He has had a positive scan. But that does not lessen the pain. JR Wilson is to have another assessment on his injury to see if it is going to be long-term.
The manager is confident that Vinnie Leonard will return in three weeks' time. But of course it will only be for a short spell as he will be off to Norwich in mid June. But that does not matter.
Vinnie got a very serious virus in his leg. He will be fine. I know that that's all that Dundalk supporters want. They are concerned for his welfare. The fact Vinnie will be fine and fit to join Norwich in mid-June is what matters.
Dundalk lined out as follows: goals Enda Minogue. Two full-backs, Declan McDaid. Bobby Burns. Two centre Backs, Harvey Warren and Matowa.
Midfield: Ronan Teahan, Keith Buckley, Daryl Horgan, Harry Groome and Eoin Kenny. One striker. Gbemi Arubi.
Leo Gaxha replaced Ronan Teahan on 85 minutes, Shane Tracey replaced Keith Buckley 63 minutes, as was Declan McDaid by Aodh Dervin.
Harry Groome replaced Gbemi Arubi on also on 63 minutes. The defeat is not the end of the world. I have no idea why Sean Spaight was at least on the bench.
If he was not injured, he should have been playing. Rob Cornwall was on the bench. But did not feature. He has been out injured for two months.
The Shelbourne game on Friday night should draw a good crowd. There were 2,600 people at Friday night's game. Next Monday, Dundalk are away to Waterford.
The Blues are managed by former Dundalk boss Jon Daly. They are going through a very difficult time at the bottom of the table. Last Friday, they were heading for a defeat against Galway. They struck late in injury time for an equaliser.
The week before, they also drew. But Jon Daly has not had a good start to the season. It remains to be seen if Jon Daly is still there after the window.
It will depend on results. Dundalk's record at the RSC has not been good in recent years. I would be happy with a draw against Waterford and also a share of the spoils against Shelbourne.
I know Ciaran Kilduff and many of the players. I know that they will go all out to win these games. To the people of Dundalk, I say your club needs you. They need as many people as possible to attend their games.
A big crowd would be a huge boost for Dundalk in the game against Shelbourne. The growing injury crisis is serious. Let's hope that this can be resolved soon.
I was thinking back during the week who was one of the best players I ever saw line out for Dundalk. The name Tony Cavanagh immediately came to mind. Very few supporters will remember the late Tony.
To me, he was one of the best wingers to ever play for Dundalk. Tony came to Dundalk on 4th February 1973. The club had just gone through one of the worst periods in its history.
The club was virtually insolvent. They were in the bottom two in the league. The club were staring into the abyss by midway through season 1972-73. Jim Malone, a long-serving director since 1955, had left the board by September 1970.
He was aghast at the way the club was being run and heading. He felt he had no option but to leave the board, as he had no say in the running of the club.
This was left in the hands of a small number of directors who were watching the club drifting out of football.
It was no surprise that Drogheda FC asked Jim Malone to join the board of directors at the south Louth club. It was Jim, as a member of the FAI Executive, who played the key role in getting Drogheda into the League of Ireland.
He would often go and see Drogheda play in the Lourdes Stadium when Dundalk were playing away from home. He turned down the offer to become a Drogheda director.
In November 1971, he began a move to take power from the then majority shareholders of the club.
He approached local businessmen such as Oliver Quinn, Kevin McGuinness, Charlie McCann, Jim Kerr, Tommy McEvoy, Ted Kierans, and others to see if they were interested in mounting a challenge to take control of the club.
Enda McGuill was one of the four who held much of the control of the club. When he was persuaded to join the challenge for a change, it worked.
Enda became one of the most powerful and skillful soccer administrators in the decades ahead in the country. He played a superb role in the running of Dundalk FC. The challenge for the change came in December 1972.
It worked. The club was now in the hands of a group of local businessmen who, led by Enda McGuill and Jim Malone, knew how to get the club back on track.
Oliver Quinn proved to be a great chairman. He knew the world of business inside out. He ran the local Ballymascanlon Hotel. He was a very young man starting off in Oriel as chairman.
Oliver is still with us today, thankfully. The club was being managed by the great Fran Brennan. He was a member of the 1966/67 team that won the league under Alan Fox.
The squad in 1972/73 was nearly all local. Jim Malone's ousting of the outgoing board was like something out of the old American TV drama Dallas.
It had to be done; it was ruthless in one sense. But if it had not happened, the club would have gone out of football. It was the shareholders and the new Board of Directors who saved Dundalk. It was not Jim Malone. But he did play leading role.
In January 1973, with the new board in place, it made its first signings. Gerry Brammeld, Joe McEleavey and Tony Cavanagh.
They were signed from Glentoran. All three went straight into the side to play Shamrock Rovers in Milltown in the cup. Dundalk were given no chance.
But they played very well, with Tony Cavanagh excelling. He reminded me of the great Georgie Best. Tony was an old-fashioned winger.
He would weave in and out of players with the ball. He was simply majestic. Dundalk surprisingly held Rovers to a draw. Tony dramatically put Dundalk ahead.
The replay was held in Oriel the following Thursday. In those days, all shops closed at lunchtime on a Thursday in Dundalk. That tradition is long gone. Dundalk met Rovers head-on in the replay.
But sadly, Dundalk bowed out of the cup by the narrowest of margins. Oriel was packed to the rafters that night, for the first time in years. Despite the defeat, the buzz was back.
There was nothing the new board could do to salvage the league season. Dundalk finished second from bottom. Drogheda finished rock bottom.
In that time, there was no relegation. But the bottom two teams had to apply to the FAI to be re-elected back into the league. They were.
Tony loved to take on defenders. He was a magician with the ball. Tony was from Ardoyne in Belfast. He was an orthodox left winger. Off the field, he was very quiet in many ways. But he had the great ball-playing skills of Georgie Best, among others.
Tony was deceptively strong on the ball, retaining possession under the most physical of challenges. His crazy mazy runs made him one of the most entertaining wingers ever to play for Dundalk.
John Smyth arrived at Oriel in July 1973. John was to be a player-manager. He brought Richie Blackmore and Jimmy Dainty to the club, among others.
John had a successful season with Dundalk in many ways. He got them to the semi-final of the League Cup and finished fifth in the league.
But John made a massive error. He rarely played Tony. The young Belfast man made only nine appearances for Dundalk in the entire season of 1973-74. He made 10 appearances the previous season from February 1973 to May 1973.
John Smith departed as manager in October 1974. Peter Watson took over as temporary player-manager. Jim McLaughlin arrived in November.
As a side issue, when McLaughlin became manager, the old Dundalk Shopping Centre opened. The opening ceremony was performed by Gay Byrne.
McLaughlin quickly noticed he had a very skilful player on his hands. Tony made 27 appearances for Dundalk that season.
He managed to score nine goals. The following season, he made 27 first-team appearances for Dundalk. This was the same as the previous season.
The huge difference was that Tony played a key role in helping bring the League title to Dundalk in season 1975-78. He scored three goals that same season. Dundalk had two natural wingers in that team.
Tony Cavanagh as left winger with Jimmy Dainty on the right. They were simply unstoppable. Dundalk lost only one game that season.
In September 1976, Dundalk took on the mighty PSV Eindhoven in the European Cup. The Dutch champions drew a huge crowd to Oriel.
They did go 1-0 in front in the first half. Tony had a magnificent game. He caused the Eindhoven defence many problems on the flanks.
Dundalk deservingly equalised in the second half. The game finished 1-1. The second leg was played in Eindhoven. Dundalk keeper Richie Blackmore picked up a bad injury.
He was to miss the next four months through injury. Eindhoven ran out comfortable winners. Tony picked up the Dundalk FC Player of the Year award in 1974-75.
After helping Dundalk to win the league a year later, and Richie Blackmore picking up a serious injury in Eindhoven, season 1976-77 was a disappointing one. Tony made 34 appearances for Dundalk that season. He scored three goals.
Season 76-77 saw Dundalk win the FAI cup for the first time in 19 years. This team were fantastic. Tony played a major role in Dundalk winning the cup.
They played Limerick in the final. They won the game by two goals to nil. Tony's wizardry on the wing tormented Limerick.
Terry Flanagan got the two goals that brought the cup north instead of it going to the south west. Dundalk easily had the two best wingers in the country in Tony and Jimmy Dainty at the time.
Dundalk played Hajduk Split in the first round of the European Cup Winners' Cup. This was in September 1977.
Sadly, three players had disputes with club directors over expenses at Dublin airport shortly before the team flew out to Split for the UEFA Cup Winners' Cup second leg. The three were suspended. One was Tony. He never played for Dundalk again.
Tony was one of the best ball players the League of Ireland has ever seen. He loved to take on players. He mesmerised them with great creativity.
He was an old-fashioned winger, the type of which has been sadly consigned to the dustbin of history. I would love to see it coming back.
Tony won a league and a cup winners' medal with Dundalk. He was Dundalk Player of the Year in 1974-75. He made 84 appearances for Dundalk over five seasons. He scored 13 goals in that time. Tony sadly died in Belfast at way too young an age.
He brought much happiness to the people of Dundalk and supporters in the League of Ireland. It was a privilege to see him play. Tony and Jimmy Dainty were two of the best players I have ever seen on the wing for Dundalk.
Get out and enjoy the good weather. It's here for the week. Have a safe week. Look after yourselves and each other. And remember, please be careful out there. I will be in Oriel on Friday. Will you.