Temple discusses the future of Dundalk FC


John Temple speaks on the Lilywhites financial situation, legacy issues, and the road ahead
Dundalk FC's new owner, John Temple, sat down with local media to discuss the club’s financial situation, legacy issues, and the road ahead. Temple wasted no time addressing the club's financial difficulties which are largely inherited from previous regimes.
He said: “It could still be very much hours within existence. The Revenue Commissioners may decide that they want to go to the High Court and take a certain application.
“We are trying to engage with Revenue, but make no mistake, the Revenue bill does not arise from my time or Brian Ainscough’s time. If I’m correct when PEAK6 left, they left €1.7 million in the bank account and that was in November 2021.
“The 2023 accounts are filing for a €1.5 million loss. You have to remember that there was also European money that came into the accounts during that time as well.
“In due diligence, and for my own protection personally and for that of everyone involved, I have to send the accounts over to the Office of the Director of Corporate Enforcement, because questions have to be asked.
“There’s money that I’m not sure has been accounted for or not accounted for. I’m not an accountant, I can’t read accounts, but you have the accountants telling you that the business is going to file for a €1.5 million loss.
“Then in the next breath, they’re telling you that it’s probably best to just shut everything down – for a club that has enjoyed so much success from Stephen Kenny’s time and everything else.”
Temple laid bare the financial pressures on the club and revealed debts owed to various entities including €200,000 to Revenue and close to €50,000 to the Gardaí for matchday policing.
He said: “Revenue are looking for about €200,000 and that’s what they’re owed. An Garda Siochana are owed just shy of €50,000 for policing at games. There’s a local bus company that are owed more or less the same. I’ve had a huge amount of effort trying to go to other creditors.
“I don’t know how many insurance policies we have, we have insurance policies to cover insurance policies. I had to pay, just there a few weeks ago, €9,000 towards insurance just to cover the pitches and the grounds for public liability.
“I had to pay for the fleet insurance because although the cars are sponsored, the fleet isn’t and that insurance had to be initiated and then the electricity came banging, they were looking for about €7,000.
“All those bills had to be paid. I paid just over €6,000 for Dan Pike. He suffered an injury at the Bohs game – so anybody who’s coming out and saying John Temple isn’t paying wages because of the academy and stuff, that’s not the truth.”
One of Temple’s aims is to broaden the board’s representation and see involvement from local stakeholders like DkIT and Louth County Council. He also opened the door for fans to have a say although he remains skeptical about the practicality of a fan ownership model.
Temple said: “I’m looking at stakeholders. For example, it’d hopefully be someone like the DkIT for them to have a representative on the board for the simple reason that the DkIT has got sports, hospitality and they’ve got business courses.
“These are young people who are willing to train up into that area. This club could offer them some sort of experience in return for them coming down to the club. I would like for them to sit on the board and advise us about that.
“I’ve also put out the feelers and I’ve got it back to a lot of public reps as well as in I think it’d be important to get someone from Louth County Council on board to actually sit and be a stakeholder to advise us.
“To put a fans model into it, I’ve met with The 1903, but what way would they nominate internally to have a person on the board? If it’s my money going in and someone else’s private money going in and then the fans come in and dictate how the money’s to be spent, where’s the commercial sensitivity stop?
“What I’ve offered to The 1903 is that they can come into the board at any time and they can make a presentation and we can sit there and meet with them.
“I’m an 80% shareholder at the moment, so the other 20% who are sitting there, they’re very good and their knowledge is unreal, they were the four shareholders between Brian Ainscough and themselves.
“A fan base model of ownership, I mean it only really works in clubs where you’ve got two and 300,000 fans and they can buy in and vote.
“A lot of these groups, from what I can see, are falling out with each other before they even get off the ground. That’s the problem. Egos and some things get in the middle of it. If it’s more structured, more constituted and more uniformed, then you could sit down and have that discussion.
“If there’s too many voices in the room, you’ll never get a single thing done, but I do believe the board that makes decisions should at least keep the fans up to date about what we do and the decisions we make and why we make them. Engagement, I’ve no problem with, but supporters getting the seats on the board? I just don’t know how it’s going to work.”
Temple admitted that he is not a millionaire and acknowledged that Friday’s fan anger and abuse towards his family made him question his future involvement.
“I’m not a millionaire, but I don’t think millionaires would want to get involved with this stuff. I’m a local man. I do have the resources. My time is coming between the club and my work at court. Whether I’ll stay on that, I don’t know.
“After what happened on Friday night, especially the anger and the hatred that was directed at my family who were at the game, well-known individuals around Dundalk contacted me on Saturday morning and said to me, just walk away.
“It’s not worth it. Why would you want to put that much hassle onto your family? For the thuggish act that was committed on Friday night, one would have to ask why would you continue?
“I do love football. Yes, I was involved in politics for long enough, but I did a lot of community work as well and I’ve always enjoyed the community. I enjoy people’s engagement.
“When you see that the club was about to close down four or five weeks ago and then on Friday night to look at the fans up there and to see what they’ve done.
“We were relegated on Friday night and yet you’d think we won the league the way the fans carried out, they were a credit to what it is and what Dundalk has.
“I was looking at the clock and I saw 90 minutes plus one and when you actually see the crowd is still there, that’s fascinating to see. That’s outstanding to see.
“That’s what I want to keep up. Yes, I’m hoping that there will be investment. I want to get my 80% share down to about 20%. I’d like to see that we could safely bring in other investors who are like-minded, but sane individuals because there’s an awful lot of head-bangers out there.”
There have been whispers about potential backers behind Temple, but he was quick to dismiss those rumours. He confirmed: “There’s no one behind me. There’s rumours as to who it is, but the rumours are just what they are.
“They’re rumours, there’s nobody behind me at this time. I do have a lot of interest from a lot of people, I’ve met with most of them. We’ve had a lot of offers and then we’ve had people with contacts from America because the Americans are mad now because of Brexit, but the reality is that I don’t think the people in Dundalk want another American takeover.
“I think they’ve had their fill of foreign investment. As a local man myself, I thought it was time to stand up. I’ve heard some of the rumours myself, they’re quite sinister. People have to remember I am a criminal barrister of law. That is primarily what I do.
“I act in the criminal sphere. I have acted for a lot of high-profile individuals, but that’s in that sphere and I suppose it’s their money coming to pay me, what they owed me for the work I’ve done, but there’s no investment consortium behind me right now.”
Looking ahead, Temple admitted the club would need to make painful cuts to survive. He said: “I’m going to have to rearrange some things. You can’t make an omelette without breaking a few eggs.
“The club is not sustainable. The club that once was cannot go forward. Even just speaking with the financial controller that’s in Shelbourne and other clubs, they’ve told me that I’m operating at about a 40% higher cost than what they are.
“There’s the average, but I’m operating between 13 and 40% higher and yet look where Dundalk are in the table. The model that’s there is not working and it has to adapt to change and nobody who comes into the club could sustain it at the level that it’s at.
“That’s just the reality of it and people are going to be unhappy, but for the club to survive, the model has got to change. If they can’t adapt to doing it in a different way, be it instead of taking a wage, take an expense or working extra time for free or something, whatever way it can be.
“I’ve done a head count. Some of the work is counterproductive and is just non-existent and it has to change. The model can’t stay the same.
“Invariably there will be lay-offs because if people turn and say, I’m not doing that and that’s not my job, I have to move you on because the club in the First Division is not going to be as busy as it once was.
“The one thing we’re going to suffer on will be the away fans tickets coming in because they do provide a good source of income for the club each home game we have.
“That’s not going to happen now in the First Division, so when the money’s not going to be coming in, you have to scale back. It’s a recession for the club.
“Going forward, we have to cut back anyway because if we’re going into SCARP and that does come about and it’s a full five-week process – this comes back to the licencing issue with the FAI.”
Temple also addressed the possibility of entering SCARP, a restructuring process to deal with the club’s financial challenges. He said: “From the minute I’ve come in, we’ve been prepared for SCARP.
“You have to seek that protection of going for SCARP. I have to sit down later this week and have a look. Auditors and accountants have told me that if I want to stay in the business at all or I want to keep this afloat, I’ll have to put it into SCARP.
“The difficulty with going into SCARP is that we are going to drop points instantly. The way the FAI look at that is they don’t want to be short-changed and will say, if you’re going to be smart with us and you’re only going to go into SCARP at the end of the season, you’re going to start next season on minus points. That’s not ideal for us.
“However, it takes several weeks to prepare to go into SCARP. The licencing is up for Dundalk Football Club and we were marred already going into the licencing process.
“One of the big things with the licencing at the moment is that there are several claims against Dundalk FC. When Dundalk were in Europe, there were promises made to Stephen O’Donnell to be given certain bonus money and that never materialised.
“There was a player called Zahibo who played for Dundalk a long time ago. He was promised money and he’s got a claim for outstanding amounts. Louie Annesley was never paid (for historical international matches) and that claim is now overhanging.”