The Commentary Box: Dundalk need a win against Bohemians


The Commentary Box | The Gerry Malone Column
Dundalk go into Friday night's crucial league game against second-place Bohemians, knowing that they need a win.
With just four games left, Dundalk will go into the game just seven points ahead of the two teams in the play-off zone, Drogheda United and Waterford. Dundalk have not won at Oriel in the league since May.
Their overall form has deteriorated considerably since the window opened. Dundalk were once being tipped for a European spot. They have since seen those hopes dwindle to ash.
They conceded 13 goals in their last four games. It's a shocking defensive record. They have the second-worst record in the league at conceding goals. That's 53. It's the defence where an awful lot has gone wrong.
Drogheda and Waterford's form is much better than Dundalk's as far as picking up points recently. Waterford pushed Shamrock Rovers all the way at the Tallaght stadium just 10 days ago.
They were leading twice only for Rovers to strike with two late goals to win. Drogheda led against Bohemians and in the end went down to a narrow defeat.
Meanwhile, Dundalk were throwing a lead away twice against Shelbourne to go down to a three-two defeat.JR Wilson and Trevor Clarke are out for the rest of the season through injury.
They had to be replaced during the Shelbourne game. Trevor Clarke has done very well for Dundalk since coming in. But he has been plagued with injury. Now he is gone for the rest of the season. Injury has also hit JR Wilson during the season.
In fact, I was surprised to see him returning so early in the past two games. Now he is gone for the season if the reports can be believed.
Dundalk's position to stay up is stronger than Waterford or Drogheda. But Dundalk's form over the past three months has been much worse than Waterford or Sligo.
Tyreke Wilson is still recovering from injury. He has been one of the finds of the season. He may have got over the injury, but he is hardly fit. I can understand if Dundalk are tempted to play him on Friday. But they should not do it.
An injury on Friday would leave him out for the rest of the season. And it's the right thing to do for the player as well. I remember when Dundalk were doing poorly in the late 90s. I remember one player was recovering from a bad injury.
The manager played him against UCD in Belfield. Sadly, he only lasted 20 minutes. And he never played soccer again. The well-being of the player must always be put before the team's. If he is not fit, he must not be played.
Dundalk badly need reinforcements. But they just do not have them. The squad is very thin. This is one of the reasons why Dundalk are playing like a team that could be relegated.
I personally do not think they will get caught up in the play-off spot. But nor do I think they will pick up a single point in their last four games.
Bohemians should win comfortably on Friday night, going on their recent performances and Dundalk's gifting of goals to the opposition.
It's frightening how this Dundalk team can not hold a lead. How many times have they been leading this season, but then blown it? They have dropped approx 28 points from winning positions this season. This is shocking.
Dundalk must play Sligo Rovers away in the Showgrounds in Sligo. Pats beat them up there by a single goal in the game. Sligo may already be relegated.
However, they have already beaten Dundalk this season. They will push Dundalk all the way. I can not see the Oriel Park men getting even a point, judging on their shocking demise in form since the window.
Supporters say the slump has been caused by the loss of Gbemi Arubi and Eoin Kenny. Yes, it's played its part. But the rot had already set in before that. Dundalk have had an unprecedented injury list this season.
Conor O'Keeffe is badly missed in defence. He picked up a serious head injury last season and has just never recovered. He has played some games since, but the injury hit him again. I don't even know if he will ever play again.
The injury to Danny Mullen was a massive blow. The former Derry City striker did have injury problems last season. But Ciaran Kilduff was confident he would do well.
His goal against Derry at the Brandywell seemed to give Kilduff hope. But he suffered a number of injuries that has seen him barely play for Dundalk.
Those that say that Mullen was the correct replacement for Gbemi Arubi when he left at the end of June were incorrect. Sadly, Danny was never really in a position to confirm that hope.
Players brought in during the window have not really worked out. Trevor Clarke has shown some good touches. But like many other players, his stay at Oriel has been plagued with injury.
Cian Dillon, brought in as a striker, has been a huge disappointment. He is signed for next season as well. That, to me, was a big mistake. Egor Vassenein, the 18 year old centre half from Shamrock Rovers, has shown a lot of promise in some games.
He has a good future ahead of him. Although I am sure that will be with Shamrock Rovers. Tom Grivosti was another signing made in the window. Tom has impressed at times. But at times he certainly has not.
During their earlier Oriel Park games, Dundalk managed to win six, draw two and lose two. But since their last home win on 29th May, Dundalk have played six games, lost five and drawn just one. This was all in Oriel.
In the 10 early games, Dundalk scored 18 goals at Oriel and conceded seven. Now Dundalk have lost five of their last six games at Oriel and drawn just once. In their six-game winless run at Oriel, they have scored 7 goals but conceded a shocking 15.
I have said it all season that goalkeeper Enda Minogue would not be my choice between the goals. He has played some good games. He excelled in the home game against Shamrock Rovers earlier in the season.
But he has not been up to standard in the season overall. In my mind, Ciaran Kilduff has made a serious mistake persisting with Minogue. He must take responsibility for that decision.
He has rejected criticism of Minogue from me. Ciaran says Enda Minogue is a good keeper. He also says he will be sticking with him for the last four games.
Drogheda have a very tough run in. Dundalk will be hoping that they drop enough points that ensures the Oriel Park side escape the play-off. On Thursday night Drogheda will be away to Shamrock Rovers. They always cause Rovers problems.
That's whether the game is played in Drogheda or at the Tallaght stadium. Drogheda were very unlucky not to get at least a point at Dalymount against Bohemians. They lost to a very late goal. That was 12 days ago.
I think Drogheda are well capable of getting something from that game. The following week, Drogheda play Derry at home. City are playing well at the moment. They want to hold onto fourth place, even though they are still in the cup.
Fourth place will give them a place in the Conference League if Bohemians win the cup. But should Derry win the cup, they will get a place in the Europa League. It would be a tough game for Drogheda.
But with home advantage and home support, I think they will win that. Drogheda must travel to Waterford on 23rd October for their second-to-last game. That game is too close to call. I will go for a draw.
Drogheda's last home game is against Galway. Again, it's a tough game. But again, with home advantage, I think Drogheda will get the points. If my prediction for Drogheda is correct, they will finish with an extra 8 points. It would leave them with 42 points.
That would be one more point than Dundalk have at the moment. If I am right, and I hope I'm not, I just can not see Dundalk getting anything from their last four games, given their recent shocking form.
Waterford play Galway at home at the RSC. The Blues should win that. They also play Bohemians away. They could well get a point from that.
I can see their game against Drogheda ending in a draw at the RSC. They play Shelbourne away from home in the last game of the season. Shelbourne could still be chasing the fourth spot.
If so, this could end in a draw. If Shels have nothing to play for, Waterford could get all three points. If results go as I predict, then Waterford will escape the drop zone by a point from Dundalk.
But the results from these games, of course, could go any way. Dundalk still have their destiny in their own hands. But their collapse in form in the league since May has been shocking.
So shocking that they could be relegated if they end up in the play-off spot and lose that as well. The weekend before last, Ciaran Kilduff told the media that he is not talking about relegation.
He said he backed his team to find their way through the storm that they are in right now. The manager said he understands the concerns there are.
But he feels his team have enough points right now that will be good enough from keeping Dundalk away from the play-offs.
Last Wednesday night a crowd of 550 attended the game. Between the Dundalk Women's under-23 team and Wexford FC. Wexford won with a late goal. The game was played in Oriel Park. There were heroes in both teams.
Eden Laughton Tyler was magnificent in goal for Dundalk. She deservedly won the player of the match award. Her saves were magnificent. Time after time, Wexford breached the Dundalk defence.
But Eden was just outstanding. I could not believe the saves she made. It was the best display from a Dundalk goalkeeper that I have seen in years. That is no exaggeration.
This was the first women's game I have seen in Oriel. The message was very positive from the match. And that is, a very entertaining and skilful game was seen by everybody.
Dundalk had their chances and could have won the game. But Wexford always looked to have that bit of extra class on the ball. Media people present agreed with that.
Dundalk looked dangerous at times. But Wexford were that bit more dangerous. They had a number of their senior League of Ireland players in the team. Wexford won the game with just two minutes remaining.
They went on a run at the Dundalk defence for the umpteenth time. Miah Whelan latched onto the ball from the edge of the box. Dundalk Keeper Eden Tyler went to save it.
She did get her hands to the ball. Sadly, Miah was very quick to see her chance. She blasted the loose ball to the centre of the net.
Dundalk can be very proud of their display. They have had a very impressive run to the final. This game will just highlight even further the deficit there is at Dundalk FC for not having a senior women's team. But it will happen.
The women's game is well established in Oriel now. It's up to the powers that be as to when the club will have a senior women's team in the League of Ireland.
The week was dominated by the Israel -Ireland fixture in the Nations Cup. Right up to the final 12 hours, there was no certainty that it would. Geographically, Israel is part of Asia and has no business being a member of UEFA.
It only became a member of UEFA in 1994.UEFA stands for the Union of European Football Associations. When it was set up in 1948, Israel became a member of the Asian Football Confederation.
This was in 1954. During the 1950s, 60s, and 70s, multiple Arab and Muslim states refused to play against Israel. This was due to the Arab League boycott.
In 1974, Israel was expelled by the Asian Football Confederation. This followed a motion by Kuwait to do so. It led to Israel being expelled from the AFC during the Asian Games in Tehran.
For nearly two decades, Israel was not affiliated with any continental federation. They played only occasional matches or by competing temporarily within the Oceania Football Confederation.
In 1991, UEFA allowed the Israeli national team to begin playing European qualifying matches. Israeli clubs also joined European competitions under special exemptions in 1992.
In 1994, Israel became a full member of UEFA. This allowed the country to play in the European Championship qualifiers, along with the World Cup qualifiers. Israeli clubs were also allowed to play in all the European club competitions.
Israel is a nation based in the Levant, based in the Mediterranean, connecting Africa to Asia. Just like the neighbouring nations of Lebanon, Syria, and parts of Egypt, it is geographically in the Middle East. The Israel Football Federation emerged from the Football Association of Palestine.
The state of Israel has its origins in 1917, when the British government who had control of the area, decided that Jews would have a homeland where Palestine already existed.
Britain ran the area under a mandate from the League of Nations. In 1947, the UN proposed dividing the territory into separate Jewish and Arab states.
This did not happen. It ended with Palestinians being dislodged from their homeland and Israel being able to create its own state. The British withdrew after a war between Arabs and Jews.
And since then, the persecution of Palestinians has continued to the present day. Israeli citizens have also been subject to terrible atrocities by Arabs as well.
The worst was on October 7th 2023. At least 828 civilians died. 88 were children. 71 were foreign nationals. 367 members of the Israeli security forces also died in the attack by the Palestinian group Hamas.
251 Israeli civilians and non-Israeli civilians were kidnapped. Israel had killed many innocent Palestinians before October 7th. Thousands have died in clashes since 1947.
There was still hope of a two-state solution where Palestinians would control Gaza and the West Bank up to 2023. Since the October atrocities, Israel has butchered innocent men, women, and children in the Gaza war.
Many people have been forced from their homes in Gaza and the West Bank. No matter what Israel says, they have committed genocide in Palestine. There is no way they should be allowed to play in any sporting competitions anywhere.
They should be thrown out of UEFA. They should not be allowed to play in European club or national competitions anymore. Their army killed over 85,000 people in Gaza alone. Many were children.
The Irish government made a mess of the situation. They should have advised or told the FAI that they were not to play Israel. The FAI should have withdrawn from these games when the draw was made against Israel, whatever the consequences from UEFA.
Instead, the players were put under unprecedented pressure with the games going ahead. They were the subject of some vile abuse on social media.
Protests were held by a group calling itself Stop The Game outside the team hotel in Dublin. I have no doubt that this would have put the players under enormous pressure.
24 hours before the game, there was still a doubt as to whether the game would go ahead. Votes were taken by players as to whether they should play. After a long day of to and fro, came the word the game would go ahead.
Votes were taken by the players. But there was nothing official as to how many voted for or against. Goalkeeper Gavin Bazunu decided he had enough. He issued a statement on his Instagram stating he would not be playing.
Jimmy Dunne was named as the third sub keeper. Jimmy is of course a former Rock Celtic player. He now plays for Queens Park Rangers as a midfielder. Thus, a midfielder had to be named as the third keeper.
I do not criticise the players who took part in Sunday's game. What choice did they. I condemn UEFA, the government and the FAI for placing our players and country in such a position.
Why should Ireland suffer in a competition because a country they have been drawn against has committed mass murder? Why do the mass murderers win and Ireland lose?
The opposition the players were subject to by people at home was also a disgrace. These were young men who should never have been put in this position. That they were is nothing short of disgraceful.
These players should get as much help as is possible when they return. Their mental health is bound to have suffered greatly. Gavin Bazunu was right to pull out. The other players who chose to stay were right too.
In truth, the FAI should have called its squad home on the Sunday morning when it was clear how much strain its players were under. The FAI are now under huge pressure.
Only one member of the executive was there to deal with the players in the hotel on the Saturday before the game. The manager has been criticised.
Yes, he should have told Gavin Bazunu about a meeting and a vote to decide what action was being taken. The goalkeeping coach was supposed to tell him.
Bazunu knew nothing about a meeting and a vote on what action to take. In the end, the only FAI executive present announced that the players had decided to play the game on Sunday.
But it was clear that the vote was very close. Not the one disclosed by the FAI.Anyway, on Sunday the game went ahead. Ireland upset all the odds. They won by three goals to nil. The goals were scored in the opening 25 minutes of the game.
Israel never looked like breaching the Irish defence. It was the Republic's best scoreline for three years. The Boys in Green were heroes to a man. When the game was over, a small group of Israeli supporters chanted IDF at the Irish players. They took no notice.
The Irish boys wore black armbands in memory of the Palestinian people who died in the Gaza war. That amounts to over 85,000 people butchered by Israel. The Irish team never shook any of the Israeli players' hands.
They did not accept the Israeli pennant before the game. And it's hard to believe a small group of Irish supporters managed to get into the ground.
Ireland play Austria on Thursday at the Aviva. They lead the group by three points. Next Sunday, Ireland must play Israel yet again in the Nations League in Serbia. This is Ireland's supposed home game.
My wish is that the players, manager, and his team are left alone by the Trolls on social media. Fair play to them for facing Israel.And fair play to Gavin Bazunu for not playing.
To the FAI, you must now lobby the government much harder to have Israel thrown out of UEFA. For God's sake, the Israeli prime minister Netanyahu has been issued with a warrant for his arrest by the International Criminal Court.
If he ever lands in Ireland, he must be arrested on the spot. The coalition government must be a lot more proactive to get Israel thrown out. Let them go back and join the Asian confederation.
I was disappointed that the Irish media did not cover the actual game. It was ridiculous. If I am sent out to cover an event in Gaza, Germany, Russia, or Ukraine, I cover it. The journalists say they were boycotting the game in support of the Palestinians.
But surely they should have reported on the game to let us know what was happening. This was a highly political game. Anything could have happened.
Yet there was no Irish media on live to say what could be happening. In fairness, the reporters had the full support of their editors. I just can not get my head around this.