Inside Track: Mulroy’s failure to win All-Star nomination difficult to fathom


Inside Track with Joe Carroll
Until Louth’s All-Ireland semi-final with Mayo, Sam Mulroy was clearly in the frame for an All-Star nomination. A good chance, too, that he would win a second consecutive award.
Then there is Dara McDonnell. Even after the defeat by Mayo, a game in which Louth were left standing soon after the second half began, the Naomh Mairtin clubman was being widely tipped not only for an All-Star, but also the Young Player of the Year award.
McDonnell remains odds-on to join Paddy Keenan, Craig Lennon and Mulroy on Louth’s list of All-Stars, and could also win the ‘Young’ gong.
Others from this county, Lennon and Ciarán Downey, will also be togged out in their best bib and touckers at Dublin’s RDS Centre on the last Friday in October. It’s a first nomination for Downey, and no-one can say it is not thoroughly deserved.
Mulroy, however, won’t be there, and that’s a surprise. What’s more than a surprise is his failure to even get a nomination.
It would all suggest the selectors defined his season on just one game, the All-Ireland semi-final. That day Mulroy took a heavy knock in the first half and clearly wasn’t able to do himself justice after that. Missed most of all were his leadership qualities, as Louth tried to contain what became a galloping Mayo horse.
To get to that stage, Louth had to win four games. One came in the Leinster championship first round – the other three in the bear pit that is the All-Ireland qualifiers.
And here there was revenge for the Leinster semi-final defeat by Dublin. This was a win that saw the county to at last get rid of baggage that had been hanging around for almost 70 years.
If it was good that day at Croke Park, it was ten times better in the Inniskeen match with Armagh, the All-Ireland champions of two years ago.
It will live long in many memories that game’s final chapter, Louth grabbing a last-minute goal to win by a point. If anyone needs reminding, it was Mulroy who was the scorer. Another feature was Louth clearing a five-point first half deficit to go in leading at the break.
Then came Monaghan in the quarter-finals. Everyone who was in a red jersey that day had to give more than 100% after Seán O’Callaghan had been sent off inside the first quarter. And they did with Mulroy again leading from the front.
If all that the Naomh Mairtín clubman did in the championship wasn’t enough, take into consideration his league form, and what Louth achieved in the spring.
Wins over Derry and Tyrone were the headline acts – next best was the rout of Cavan at Breffni Park. All that Ulster counties had to offer in league and championship this year was taken care of, and in none of the games was the team captain not front and centre.
Let’s turn the clock back to the early 1980s. The All-Star selection was slightly different at the time. Provincial ‘paper hacks were in on the game at the time, your writer included.
We were asked to name players from our counties who we thought were worthy of consideration. Top of my list was Gerry Farrell.
The Cooley Kickhams goalie was in imperious form in 1983, and for years before and after. When it came to narrowing the field down for each of the fifteen positions, he was among the three nominated.
Offaly’s Martin Furlong and Dublin’s John O’Leary were the others. Exalted company, but ‘Flogger’ wasn’t out of place.
Furlong got the nod, just as had done the two previous years when he also won All-Irelands. He had an advantage in that he was playing in games that most of the All-Stars selectors, many of them working GAA journalists, would have been present at.
While he was shot-stopping at his best, Farrell – who was named on the Louth Team of the Millennium – was operating in the lower reaches of the National League, his Louth outings only covered by scribes who had no say in the selection of the All-Stars.
That wasn’t the case with Sam Mulroy this year, however. Three of his big performances were in Croker – in the league match with Meath and the championship wins over Dublin and Monaghan. I can vouch for it, we, the country yokels, didn’t hold a Press majority.
In a year in which many Louth players shipped injuries, some of them long-term, Dara McDonnell stayed sound.
He was asked to take over the centre-half berth on the county team after Peter Lynch fell victim of a heavy tackle in the league match with Meath, and in this, his first season with the seniors, he has not only filled the post more than adequately, but also blossomed, winning huge praise for his performances against Armagh and Monaghan.
However, before he makes his way to Dublin next month, McDonnell has an important task on hand. Mairtíns are in danger of losing their senior championship status.
They face a crucial play-off with either Hunterstown Rovers of Roche Emmets (the extra-time issue has still to be resolved at the time of writing.)
Craig Lennon would love to have club games to face. His St Mochta’s side are through to the senior championship semi-final, and are not without a major chance of qualifying for a second final in six years.
But having sustained a bad injury early in Louth’s match with Mayo, the 2024 All-Star will have to be satisfied with a place along the sideline. His performances prior to the All-Ireland final were, as always, of a high quality.
Ciarán Downey hasn’t been a stranger to the treatment table, either, his latest spell coming in recent weeks. But he was well enough recovered to come on in the second half of Newtown Blues’ quarter-final with St Patrick’s and play a vital role in the 2025 runners-up winning by six points.
Downey has had a great season with the county team, creating and taking scores. One of the best had him side-footing to the net in the league defeat of Cavan. It’s no surprise that he has caught the eye of the All-Stars selector.
He’s in there fighting for an award, which, if he gets it, would bring great honour to his club, which, over the years, has given the county some of its best footballers.