Commentary Box: Dundalk were working the oracle in the first half of the season


The Commentary Box | The Gerry Malone Column
Dundalk went down to yet another defeat at Oriel Park last Friday, when they were beaten on a 2-1 scoreline. It was the Oriel Park side's 12th league defeat of the season.
They have now played 33 league games. In their last 11 league games, Dundalk have won only one game. They lost 7 and drawn just three. It's a shocking statistic.
And with three games left, Dundalk can still very much be caught on the line and thrown to the wolves of the play off spot. Manager Ciaran Kilduff seems to believe that this will not happen.
He believes it would take some out of the ordinary sequence of results involving Drogheda and Waterford for Dundalk to end up in the play off position. Yes, Dundalk are seven points clear of these teams. They have four games left and Dundalk have three.
Dundalk must play Sligo Rovers in the Showgrounds on Saturday week. They are then away to Derry and have a home game against joint leaders Shamrock Rovers in their last game.
I can not see Dundalk getting anything from these last games. That is because their defence is so poor. After Friday's game, Dundalk now have the worst defensive record in the league.
They have conceded 50 goals. It's another shocking statistic that nobody can stand over. Bohemians' second goal that sealed the game was a terrible goal to concede.
Yes, the defending was poor. But once again goalkeeper Enda Minogue failed to come for the cross from the corner. It allowed Bohemians to kill the game in the second half at such a crucial stage of the game.
Given the circumstances in which he has had to operate in, Ciaran Kilduff will not be asked to leave at the end of the season. And that is only right.
He has had no hard finance to invest in players that could now be helping his side earn a place in next season's Europa Conference League.
He brought Dundalk back into the Premier Division last season on a shoestring budget. Dundalk were working the oracle in the first half of the season. Their season has imploded since then. The loss of Gbemi Arubi and Eoin Kenny has played its part. But only a part.
He has 10 of his team out injured. That's been a major factor. Kilduff has not been able to pick the same team for two games in a row this season, because his side have been ravaged by injuries on a weekly basis.
But without sounding like a broken record his failure to sign a replacement keeper for Conor Kearns has resulted in instability in the Dundalk defence. His refusal to change Enda Minogue the second choice keeper, with another signing has cost Dundalk dearly.
The slump is not solely down to the Dundalk goalkeeper. The defence has been shocking as well. But Ciaran Kilduff's refusal to change has an outside chance of causing Dundalk's season to end in tears.
3,300 supporters attended the game. Some Bohemians supporters did end up in the home end. Their ability to do so was quickly shut down by Dundalk.
A Bohemians director told me that some did get through the breach as he recognised a number of Bohemians Supporters in the home end.
Bohemians players and the management refused to talk to the media after the game. This was after the Dublin club issued a statement during the game, which stated that their managers or players would not be taking part in any post-match interviews.
This was a protest move by the club because Shamrock Rovers were allowed to bring their game against Drogheda forward 24 hours to next Thursday. This was to facilitate TV coverage.
But in truth, it seems Bohemians were annoyed that Rovers will get 24 hours advantage without a game. This is because the 2 teams clash early the following week in the league. Bohemians play their FAI Cup semi-final next weekend.
Ciaran Kilduff told me after the game that he received an apology from the fourth official at Friday's game.
This official refereed the Dundalk-Derry cup semi-final at the Brandywell weeks before. Kilduff says the official accepted he got the penalty call wrong. He told Kilduff it was no penalty.
The Dundalk boss also said that Dundalk had a stonewall penalty waived away against Bohemians in the first half. He said the penalty they did get in the second half was no penalty. He said that this was one incident that Dundalk got away with.
Trevor Clarke's season looked to be over when he was injured against Shelbourne two weeks ago. He played very well on Friday. But JR Wilson was also injured in that game. He did not play on Friday.
Dundalk lined out with Enda Minogue in goals. The back four were Harvey Warren, Mayowa, Tom Grivosty and Bobby Burns.
Keith Buckley and Aodh Dervin played in front of the back four. Trevor Clarke, Ronan Tehan and Daryl Horgan were in front of Buckley and Dervin. Leo Gaxha was played as a lone striker up front.
Igor Vassenein replaced Warren on 54 minutes. Keith Bickley was replaced by Declan McDaid on 71 minutes.
Ronan Teahan was replaced by Harry Groome on 85 minutes. Leo Gaxha was replaced by Cian Dillon on 72 minutes. Aodh Dervin was replaced by Norman Garbett on 72 minutes.
My ratings for the Dundalk players were as follows. Minogue, 4. Warren, 5. Mayowa 6. Grivosti 6. Clarke 7. Buckley 6. Dervin 6. Burns 7. Teahan 6. Horgan 7. Gaxha 5. Subs ratings. Vassenein 5. McDaid 6. Garbett 5. Groome 5. Dillon 4.
Danny Mullen has been given a contract for next season. The former Derry striker has been plagued with injuries this season. He has only played a limited number of games. It's a big risk for Ciaran Kilduff taking him back.
Leo Gaxha is also reported to have been signed again for next season. Sadly, I would have misgivings about him as well. To me, he is just not a Premier Division player. Daryl Horgan is being kept on for another two seasons.
He has had a fantastic influence on the team this season. I wonder if the manager is thinking about signing Conor Kearns as his first-choice keeper. Conor was badly injured earlier in the season.
He suffered a recurrence of an old injury which kept him out of football two seasons ago. Dundalk brought him here on loan. I just do not think it would be a good move to sign him.
If he is very prone to injury, it will cause trouble for Dundalk down the line. In the small number of games I have seen him, he would not fill me with a whole lot of confidence.
Kilduff needs a lot of outside investment to make Dundalk a force again. If that is not forthcoming, the club will be in a lot of trouble. They need the money now, as the planning for next season is well underway.
The manager must bring in a lot of new players. And it would be best for Dundalk if they can sign Irish players. He will have to go and sign two new keepers. I look forward to that.
More than 3,300 people turned out for the game in Oriel. Bohs victory at Oriel was their fifth straight win. Dundalk went 2-0 down. They got a goal back when Daryl Horgan smashed home a late penalty.
Ciaran Kilduff has accepted that it was not a penalty. But the claims for one in the second half should have been given.
Bohs were down to ten men when Cian Byrne hacked Cian Dillon down on the edge of the box. Bobby Burns' free came crashing back off the crossbar.
In the early exchanges, Enda Minogue did take off a great save. Parsons put Whelan through. The Dundalk defence stalled. Whelan fired a fierce shot at the Dundalk goal. Minogue was equal to it and pushed the ball away.
But Bohs finally got their goal when Aodh Dervin tripped Conor Parsons in the box. Colin Whelan placed the penalty and fired to the roof of the net. It was the Bohs player's 13th goal of the season.
Bohs should have been down to 10 men when Conor Parsons went off his feet and caught Harvey Warren. Referee Damian McGrath only gave a yellow. Parsons should have been sent off.
Dundalk were denied a definite penalty minutes later when Hickey, in attempting to clear the ball, kicked it onto his arms. After the game, Ciaran Kilduff told me this was a penalty.
Former Dundalk player Senan Mulen, who is on loan from Torino, caused the Dundalk problems. Trevor Clarke split the Bohemians defence open in the second half with a pass to Hogan.
Darragh Power got back to put the ball out for a corner. It was Dundalk again minutes later, when Trevor Clarke knocked the ball into the box. Dervin lost control of the ball.
Dundalk struggled to maintain their momentum. Midway through the second half, Bohs struck for the goal that put the game beyond doubt. A corner from Jordan Flores was headed back across the goal.
Enda Minogue seemed to freeze. Hickey headed the corner across the goal. Ross Tierney finished the ball to the net with ease. Dundalk did pull a goal back late in the game when Niall Monahan pulled Norman Garbett back in the box.
Daryl Horgan shot home the penalty. There was a great finish to the game. Bobby Burns had a shot from a free that came crashing back off the Dundalk crossbar.
The referee just played three minutes injury time. There should have been at least six minutes. There were so many hold-ups in the second half.
Ciaran Kilduff was very disappointed with the result. He said that it was a very frustrating night, even though there were some green shoots in the Dundalk team.
"I truly do not think that we will be dragged into the play-off zone as a result of tonight's defeat. The objective at the start of the season was to accumulate as many points as we can. The fact that we have not added to our points tally is on us.
There has been a huge turnover of personnel since we last played Bohemians. We had no Jr Wilson, Danny Mullen, Eoin Kenny or Gbemi Arubi tonight. In the last game against Bohs, we had those layers.
We have a brand new, fresh crop of players since that game. I am trying to get the most out of them. So far it has not been working. I did not agree with you. I did not think we were that far off. But we have been."
"I love this club. I love the fans, and everything there has been about Dundalk FC. A lot of people thought that this season would be so easy, that it would be a walk in the park. I have always said that our first season back in the Premier Division would not be easy.
We did have a good start to the league and indeed to the first half of the season. But things have changed now. We have to steady the ship. I was happy with our points tally up to a couple of weeks ago.
But now I know there is a job to be done. I know what is wrong with the team. There is a lot to be done. I was looking at last year's fixtures.
This time a year ago we were playing Athlone in Athlone. Now we are playing in big games, as we were tonight. We can not seem to get the results in these games now."
"You never know what is going to happen in a game. Two weeks ago we were 2-1 up against Shelbourne with ten minutes remaining. We conceded two terrible goals to lose. I got an apology from the fourth official this evening.
He was the referee in the FAI Cup game in Derry a couple of weeks ago. He accepted that he got it wrong. But that's ok. But look at all the decisions that have gone against us all season. We have the most red cards of any other team in the division.
There are penalties every week. Tonight we were awarded a penalty that was never a penalty. Then we were denied a certain penalty that was not given. What do you do? There is so much inconsistency among officials in this league."
"I agree with you that for us to compete in this league, we will need a lot more investment. We have a brilliant owner. We have a new pitch. We have our new lights. And as I say, the owner has been great.
The new signings we have brought in are only going to transition into good players when they get time. They have not had the time so far.
Look at how long it took for us to get Gbemi playing, the way we knew he could. We are a new entity. Our new players too are going to take time to settle. It's so difficult to do that in half a season."
Dundalk captain Darlyl Horgan says there were good and bad parts to the Bohemians game: "Like most games this season, there was very little in it. We just have to get on the right side of games a lot more. I am not going to talk about the decisions of referees.
That's the way football goes. There were a lot of good things that could be taken from the game. But we got no points. The big thing for me from the game is the never-say-die atmosphere that exists among the team.
We just kept going at them, even when we were two down. Look, we got one back. We hit the crossbar. They got a man sent off. It became chaos. Sometimes, you can fall into that in football.
"Mathematically, we could still get caught up in the playoffs. But it would need an extraordinary set of results for that to happen. All we can do is to focus on our next game away against Sligo on Saturday week.
There has been very little difference regarding our early season form and now. It's all about getting results over the line. Our endeavour, work rate and push to get results is still there. Getting into both boxes has kind of killed us.
The fact that after tonight, we have the worst defensive record in the league is something we are going to have to work on. It depends on what way you want to look at it.
We do score a lot of goals. We do try to go out and play. We go hell for leather, as a team, chasing for the goals. So we sometimes leave ourselves open."
"It's a very pessimistic way of looking at things, Gerry, by saying we might not win any of our last three games. We are going to go out against Sligo and play in that game.
There is also the chance that maybe we can go out an
d win our last three games against Sligo, Derry and Shamrock Rovers. We will never have the attitude that we may never win again.
We will go out and try to win all three. No, you are saying we might not win any of the last three games. We will be determined that that does not happen."
"We have nearly two weeks until our next league game against Sligo Rovers. We will train and prepare for that game. We will be ready for that game. That is all we can do. We can learn from what happened in that game tonight and move on.
The attendance was very good tonight. They have been very good all year. I will be here next season as well. I have signed another two-year deal."
I can understand Daryl's reaction to me when I said that Dundalk may well lose their last three games. But Dundalk's form has deteriorated since May at an alarming rate.
The statistics say it all. I would not have expected Daryl to do anything else but defend his players. But he has to know that things are not going well for his team, now for months.
I find it shocking that Paul McLaughlin, who refereed the Derry-Dundalk cup game at the Brandywell a number of weeks ago, has now accepted that he made a mistake giving Derry the crucial penalty and, from that, the goal which put them into the semi-final.
Paul is a highly respected referee, and it took some courage to tell Ciaran Kilduff on Friday that he had made the wrong decision. It would not have made much difference in my opinion.
Dundalk's defence was leaking goals that day. They would have won the game anyway. At the time I said it was wrong. Ronan Teehan had slipped in his own box.
As he got up, Ronan was judged to have handled the ball. At the very most, it hit him while he was getting up. At no stage did he handle the ball on purpose.
Now the referee admits he got it wrong. I believe the case grows greater than ever for VAR to be introduced in all Premier Division games next season and in the cup. I wait to see.
After the game, the Bohemians players and managers refused to talk to the media. In a ridiculous move. They say it's in protest because Shamrock Rovers have been allowed to play Drogheda next Thursday, not Friday.
They claim Rovers will be 24 hours fresher for their game the following week with Bohs. I never heard of such rubbish in my life. I asked Stephen O'Donnell if he would do a post-match interview on their win.
He said no, because of the media ban the club had just introduced. They will continue with the ban next week in the FAI Cup semi-final. Meanwhile, Rovers will meet Drogheda on Thursday night at the Tallaght stadium.
It was supposed to be on the Friday night. Bohs and Rovers meet in a crunch top-of-the-table game early the following week. Bohs, Pats and Rovers all have the same points at the top.
It is a crucial game for Bohs. But how is Stephen O'Donnell not being allowed to talk to me on Friday going to make a difference? I couldn't believe it.
Eoin Kenny was in Oriel Park on Friday night. He said that he loves to get to Oriel anytime he can. He was on a short break as he is involved in the North's under-21 European Championship qualifiers at the moment.
The previous night his team were held to a 1-1 draw against Georgia in Ballymena. He did so well that he got the man of the match award. Former Dundalk keeper and now with Waterford, Stephen McMullen was in goal.
Eoin Kenny will be in action again for the North tonight when they take on Greece. The game is being played at Mourneview Park in Lurgan. It has a 5 pm kick-off.
There is an important question-and-answer evening on Thursday evening with Ciaran Kilduff. It is exclusively for season ticket holders. It is in the Lillywhite Lounge. It starts at 7.30 pm.
Former Rock Celtic player and currently with QPR Jimmy Dunne lined out for the Ireland Israel game in Serbia on Sunday night. It's great to see Jimmy doing so well.
Have a great week. Please look after each other and yourselves. Be careful out there.