Dundalk face tough season opener against reigning champions Rovers

Dundalk players and staff pose for squad photograph during a Dundalk FC squad portraits session at Oriel Park in Dundalk. All Photos:Stephen McCarthy/Sportsfileplaceholder image
Dundalk players and staff pose for squad photograph during a Dundalk FC squad portraits session at Oriel Park in Dundalk. All Photos:Stephen McCarthy/Sportsfile

The Commentary Box: The Gerry Malone Column

The new season kicks off in three days time at the Tallaght stadium on Friday night when Dundalk must do battle with four in a row league champions Shamrock Rovers.

It's always very difficult to make any predictions in the League of Ireland. I think I can say safely enough that Rovers will win the league title for the fifth season in a row. It will take a massive challenge from the likes of Derry City and St Pats to prise that title away from them.

Last Friday night Rovers easily brushed aside the challenge of St Pats in the annual Presidents Cup game at Tallaght Stadium.

Rovers have recruited this season,but not on the scale of other clubs in the League. Their closest expected challengers Derry City have only brought in two players both of course from Dundalk, Pat Hoban and Daniel Kelly. The loss of these two players by Dundalk is incalculable. Hoban was of course still under contract while Kelly was a free agent.

The revelation that Stephen O'Donnell had told Hoban he could go just three days before the last home game of the season and that he could find another club, caused much consternation among supporters at the time. Hoban ended up breaking Joey Donnelly's all time goal scoring record in that last home game of the season. 

But Hoban left Dundalk at the end of January and went to Derry for a fee of around €35,000. New owner Brian Ainscough took the stance on arrival that he had no problem with Hoban staying if manager Stephen O'Donnell and the Dundalk striker could resolve their differences. Whether the two ever even held reconciliation talks remains unknown. But it all came to nothing and Pat Hoban was off to join his other former teammates at Derry City.

Stephen O'Donnell obviously had his own reasons for letting Hoban go. And as he is the manager, Brian Ainscough understandably backed the decision. No one player can ever become bigger than their club and you must trust your manager's judgement if you feel he is the right man to lead the club into the future.

The new owner was left with a mess on the playing front when he came in. The manager also let other key players go during the close season that certainly caused me some worry. Darragh Leahy was still under contract, but he departed. John Martin and Connor Malley were other surprise departures. Greg Sloggett did not look to renew his contract. Nathan Shepperd also departed. Dundalk offered him a contract.

Sadly talks broke down when Shepperd's representatives looked for him to have an opt out clause in June should he so wish. Keith Ward went to Shelbourne while Alfie Lewis departed for the UK. Both of these players as most mentioned above were out of contract.

The departure of Statsports and Andy Connolly as owners caught many on the hop, although it was not really that surprising. Dundalk were just very lucky that they had a new owner in Brian Ainscough who has brought the much needed stability back to the running of the club. The new owner will not get everything right overnight. But his availability to communicate has been like a breath of fresh air.

But the upheaval with the club changing owners meant that Dundalk were once again late in getting to the transfer market to replace those lost from last season. Brian Gartland and Stephen O'Donnell's could really do nothing about signing new players until the club was in new ownership.

Once again Brian Gartland has raided the foreign markets mainly Scottish to bring in his new players. Jamie Walker is a new left back who has featured in a couple of pre-season games. He comes from the Scottish Highland leagues. This is the same league Cameron Elliott came from last season.

Ross Munro is a new keeper who has played in two pre-season games. He was signed from Ross County. Robbie Mahon is from Dublin and played in at least one pre- season game. He was very impressive. He was signed from Motherwell and is a winger. Jamie Gullan is a new striker signed from Raith Rovers.

Koen Oostenbrink is a midfielder and has arrived from PSV Eindhoven. Zak Bradshaw is a defender and is on loan until June from Lincoln City. Ciaran McGuckin is a second striker and is again on loan, this time from Rotherham until June. He is from the north.

Scott High is a midfielder and is on loan until June from Huddersfield. He is Scottish. Dara Keane is the only League of Ireland player who Brian Gartland has signed. He comes in from UCD. Dundalk will also also have youngster Luke Mulligan who is aged 16.

He has signed professionally with the club. This is an exciting new move by the club to ensure it can hold onto its youngest talent. Hayden Muller, Andy Boyle,and Louie Annesley remain on from last season. Mayowa Animasahun is a centre back and returns to the squad having being on loan to Dungannon Swifts. Sean Bannon is an 18 year old centre back who is a very exciting prospect.

Archie Davies remains at right back. Ruaidhri Higgins wants him. He may only be at Oriel for another season. John Mountney returns to the side after being out injured for the past two seasons. He is also the new club captain. Paul Doyle is staying on at the club. Anthony Mayo aged 19 will be part of the squad along with Sean Keogh, Daryl Horgan and Robbie Benson. Sam Durrant and Ryan O'Kane also stayed from last season as did Cameron Elliott.

Eoin Kenny is an exciting young prospect. Aged 18 he has also signed professionally with Dundalk. He has also got on the score sheet in pre-season games.

It's going to take time for this Dundalk team to gel together. But time is not what they have. Having to go straight into the lion's den on Friday against the champions, Dundalk will go into the game as complete rank outsiders. Their pre-season form has not been anything to write home about.

Their only victory was a win over Malahide United in the Leinster Senior Cup. Drogheda beat them in Oriel by two goals to one in the same competition. The under 19's drew with Bohemians under 19's in the same competition. Dundalk lost to Longford in a friendly at Oriel. Last Friday, Derry had a comprehensive win over Dundalk in a behind closed doors game at Oriel in a three nil win. Michael Duffy got two of the goals. Pat Hoban failed to score.

With away games against Pat's, Derry and Bohs also coming up, it looks very difficult for Dundalk at the start. Their opening home game against Galway United will also be tough. I think Stephen O'Donnell must not set his sights too high this season. I would be very happy to see Dundalk finishing in a comfortable mid table position. With a totally new team Dundalk fans must be patient.

The manager can get it right. But fans must also give him and his players the time to get things right. A second goalkeeper is due to arrive at Oriel along with possibly two further players. The defence is the key for Dundalk. I was a bit alarmed to hear they had conceded three goals against Derry at Oriel last Friday.

But again it's only pre-season. It was great to hear that up to 18 of the squad will be living in Dundalk. That will help to strengthen the club's identity from within the community. Some of the players are very young. For one or two it's also their first time away from home. So fans must take that into account.

Stephen O'Donnell told the Democrat that it was hard to believe that the new season was starting in three days time. But it was professionally what all managers and players live for. O'Donnell says that where Dundalk finish up in the table remains to be seen. He says that the signing of players was a little bit behind other clubs with the change in ownership.

He says the new owner has been fantastic. He would not set a target as to where his side will finish in the league. But he emphasised how great it would be to finish in the European places.

The Dundalk manager said he is happy with the group that he has assembled. He did accept that there were other teams that were that bit more ready to go for the season as Dundalk were late to the table assembling their squad for the coming season.

He revealed that he could not talk to players about possible contracts until December.

There were players the club lost out on as a result. But there were others for last season's squad that the club were not interested in pursuing and now his squad has been freshened with new players in their place. O'Donnell says that Shamrock Rovers have settled a structure and are a team that could use pre-season for fitness reasons.

Dundalk have used the pre-season with the aim of assembling a team together. He says he wants to get Dundalk to where Rovers are so that pre-season would be for fitness of the team rather than structure. 

Dundalk are a club who have seen a change of ownership four times in the past 13 seasons. It needs long term continuous ownership. But it also needs investors. Brian Ainscough has said he is hopeful off bringing in new investors. The club needs them to become debt free and stable.

Last season Shelbourne got that stability when Hull City invested around €3m in the club. They pulled out of the club almost as quickly as they came in but they did not withdraw the money they had already invested. Shelbourne by qualifying for Europe are also guaranteed a minimum of €500,000. Dundalk's failure to qualify for Europe was possibly the catalyst that led to Statssports and Andy Connolly pulling out of the club. 

Stephen O'Donnell is looking forward to returning to Tallaght on Friday night. He acknowledges that Dundalk have not won there since 2019. He also accepts that he has never guided Dundalk to a win there since he took over as manager in 2022.The manager is going to Tallaght to win on Friday night. Who knows?

Shamrock Rovers player Lee Grace told me last week that he is raring to go for the new season. He can't wait to face Dundalk. The four in a row was massive. To win five in a row allows Rovers the chance to create their own history. He says the players never mentioned four in a row last season and will not be saying anything about five in a row either. He says the players as in any other club have enough pressure to deal with.

The players will just take care of things on the field and see where they are in November. It does not matter to Rovers who they start the season against. The main thing is that the first game is at home. The Dundalk game will be a big one, as it has been over the past four years. But they do not pay much attention as no matter who they play the sides will meet at least four times in the season. Lee says Rovers do not know too much about the new look Dundalk side.

The homework will be done on them. But they won't know what Dundalk are like until they meet them on the pitch. He says they will be stepping into the unknown. But he has this warning for the Oriel Park side. Rovers will be ready.

Lee says the champions have a very strong squad and that will be needed when it comes to the European games. Dundalk know this as well from the Kenny Perth era. The big squads are needed says Lee, as Rovers will be drawing on every one of the players.

Playing at Taillaght stadium is also massive for Rovers. The pitch surface is a massive asset. And with the new stand open it means even greater attendances. He says it's unreal the way Rovers have grown since they were promoted from the first Division in 2006. It all comes down to the people who work tirelessly for the club behind the scenes.

The people you do not hear about or see Lee says and are putting in the hard work are the real heroes. They have made the modern story of Shamrock Rovers grow to such a remarkable phenomenon.

Rovers, Pats and Derry are the three teams everybody are tipping to be in the chase for the title. But Lee is realistic. He says nobody really knows until a ball is kicked and the season starts. The three teams mentioned may have the strongest squads. But it means nothing if the teams fail to turn up on a Friday night.

Stephen O'Donnell has picked John Mountney as the new club captain. John has missed the past two seasons at Dundalk through injury. He is one of the most generous players in the current squad to give time to the media and speak to them. He realises the important role they play for the club and the league in general.

On Wednesday it was revealed he is the new club captain. The decision took me by surprise as John has missed so much game time in recent years through no fault of his own. In fact I was very surprised that Dundalk had even signed John given his injury history. But Stephen O'Donnell has great faith in his fellow Galway man.

O'Donnell knows what's needed to be a captain. Thus he sees in John a man who can lead his Dundalk players into battle each week. I just can not get my head round the move as John has missed so many games through no fault of his own with a series of terrible injuries. If he can remain injury free, then he is a good choice. Andy Boyle has been named as vice captain. Like John this man is a great leader.

John told me that he was just glad to be back training. He did not take part in the first two pre-season games. He says he was just managing a little niggle that does come with him now and again. John is confident that he can remain injury free this season and be available for most weeks. He says he normally played right back.

But now with Archie Davies having made the position his own he may have a different role. John says it's just about keeping the training up and him getting stronger and stronger. He says it's important he is available for as many games as possible. John says the past few seasons where he has been hit with injury has been very tough.

But he says it happens to many people in all sorts of sports. He says if you have a want and a need in you to come back then you can. John says he still has the same speeds he had before his injuries. Once he proved this even to himself he knew he would be fine to make his comeback. He says he is strong both mentally and physically.J ohn is feeling fit and strong and ready to lead his team into battle.

The Dundalk skipper says he is really looking forward to the Rovers game in Tallaght. He says it's a great way to start the season off. He says playing the champions will be a great test and he is looking forward to it. John is impressed with the new players that have come in so far. They have looked very good in training.

Asked if he was confidant Dundalk can fight for a European place, he said that all teams would be confident of achieving that goal. He says with the new owner taking over so late in December, Dundalk are a bit behind other teams. He says once Dundalk get a few games behind them then they will get a better picture off where they are going.

Manager Stephen O'Donnell says that John Mountney is a very positive influence to have in the dressing room. The manager said this at the height of the time John was going through his injury crisis. When I remember the respect that Stephen has for John, then it is no surprise that he has made him captain.

It's going to be a  long season. It's impossible to predict where Dundalk will finish in the league at this moment in time,given the huge influx of new players. It is a pity that once again at least two players have been brought in on loan. They could easily depart back to the parent club and interrupt the team's progress in June which is a critical time.

However there was nothing the club could do given the short time they had to put a team together. I would be very happy to see Dundalk to just consolidate their place in the Premier Division. I would like to see them strive for a comfortable mid-table position at the end of the season.

I have a fear that they might be fighting to stay away from the dreaded relegation zone. This is the most competitive Premier league there has been in years. In other years one could look at two teams in the Premier Division and say that they are the two clubs who will finish in the bottom two.

That can not be said this season. Dundalk must improve on their poor away record of winning games this season. They must also ensure that Oriel is a fortress for the third year in a row. 

With Shamrock Rovers as an opener, the game could not have been any more difficult.

To have to play it in Tallaght leaves me with just one conclusion. Shamrock Rovers to win. I wish I could say otherwise. I cannot. I would love to meet Brian Gartland next week and have him say that I got my prediction wrong. But I do not think that will be happening.

Have a great week and let us hope Dundalk can get a result against the champions.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice