Now like a phoenix Dundalk FC has returned to the ashes

An emotional Dundalk captain John Mountney reacts after his side are relegated. Photo by Ben McShane/Sportsfileplaceholder image
An emotional Dundalk captain John Mountney reacts after his side are relegated. Photo by Ben McShane/Sportsfile

The Commentary Box | The Gerry Malone Column

Dundalk's relegation last Friday night was no ordinary relegation. It is the end of an era. Dundalk's glory days were already being condemned to the bowels of history. It's been events off the pitch over the past number of years that have conspired to undo all the good work on it.

The 2-0 defeat by Derry City on Friday night sent Dundalk back to the First Division for the first time since 2008. It's the third time in the club's history to be relegated. But Friday night's drop is the most stunning of them all. It is an amazing fall from grace.

Yet I could see it coming for over a year at least. The news that the then manager Stephen O'Donnell had told the club's all-time leading goal scorer Pat Hoban that he could leave the club just three days before the end of last season was enough to signal that all was not right.

The failure to sign Nathan Shepperd back as keeper was also a major factor. But Dundalk's policy of signing players on loan and losing the best of them in mid-season was also another indication that all was not right.

This club has won five Premier League titles, three FAI Cups, and three League Cups in the past ten years. It is without doubt a stunning fall from grace. The club's success in Europe is also another huge success story in its own right.

But when Stephen Kenny left the club just six days after doing his third double in November 2018, there was a feeling that the good times were coming to an end. Vinny Perth did so well to guide Dundalk to a League and League Cup double a year later.

They just failed to do a treble when they lost by the butt of the post on penalties, against Shamrock Rovers in the FAI Cup in 2019. Dundalk went on to win the cup the following year.

Over the glory years, they also qualified for the Group Stages of the Europa League twice. Only Shamrock Rovers have achieved the same thing. Dundalk have had four different groups of owners over a 12-year period.

This has added to the instability at the club. Now John Temple is the third owner in four years. His dramatic stepping in to take over the club prevented it from going into liquidation only five weeks ago. It was a very brave move. He made no promises when he came in.

But he will now be reviewing to see if the club is viable to continue trading. Whether Dundalk go through SCARP is a burning question or whether the club will still be liquidated is another.

Dundalk owes Revenue at least 230 thousand euros. That figure may well be higher. Dundalk must pay that bill off fairly quickly. Revenue do not normally show any mercy when it comes to monies owed. The other debts the club owes could be paid off on a graduated basis.

The owner has been very brave to take on such a project to rescue Dundalk FC. I have no doubt he has plans to get Dundalk out of the mess. Whether they can work remains to be seen.

What's really important is that the new Dundalk FC Trust company and the 1903 Supporters Club work together in unity and not apart in their fundraising activities in their bids to help the club. 

It's important that unity prevails through whatever groups there are. Division is the last thing the club needs now. John Temple has undertaken a massive task that few if any would touch. He needs the support of a unified Trust and 1903 supporters club if he has to call upon them.

The owner was due to outline his preliminary plans to the Dundalk Democrat and the Argus newspapers in the past 24 hours or tomorrow on how he sees the way forward.

Meanwhile, the Dundalk FC Trust are holding a public meeting in the Town hall this coming Friday at seven-thirty to outline their plans as to how supporters can help the club going forward.

Dundalk played well in fits and starts on Friday night. But Derry, who were going for only their second win in 11 games. They hit the front on 16 minutes.

Michael Duffy swung a corner in from the right. Danny Mullin's header was going in. It took a deflection off Colm Whelan's back and ended in the net. Dundalk had done well in the opening 15 minutes.

But it was a defensive lapse that gifted Derry the goal. Dundalk have had huge problems with their defence over the past two seasons. On Friday night it was the same all over again.

Derry sealed the game on 74 minutes when they conceded a penalty after Mayowa took Michael Duffy down in the box. It was a needless penalty to give away. But former Dundalk player Will Patching had no problem slotting the ball past Ross Munro for the winner.

Jon Daly says it was hugely disappointing to lose the game. He will leave the club at the end of the season. ''I am obviously gutted for the players and the fans. I think the players have never had games where they have downed tools.

I told them if the league was won on hard work and effort, they would be near the top. But it's not. It's been the same old story since I came here. We created a number of chances but failed to take them. We have been relegated.

The club must work on getting itself back to the Premier Division. It's so disappointing. Look at the reaction of the supporters. They were extremely grateful for what they had seen on the pitch.

But the club must have a plan to come back stronger than ever to get promotion back to the Premier Division. But I think they need to put structures in place to make that happen.'

Asked about his future John says it's a fair question. ''I have been away from my family for four years. There was talk before of them coming over here from Scotland.

But what has been going on in the background in the past few months, it would be very unfair of me to expect them to uproot and come to a foreign country. I have to put my family first. That's what my plan will be.

If I had had a brutally honest picture about what was going on at the club before I decided to join the club I would have come back with my eyes open. I would have understood what I was coming into. I was obviously told certain things that did not come to fruition.

It made my job a little bit more difficult. But I am not going to make that as an excuse for us getting relegated. But the players have had certain games where they have had a lot on their minds. There probably have been games where they may not have been paid.

They had a lot on their minds at times. They had to worry about things such as paying bills and being unable to pay mortgages. That is something that is extremely difficult to deal with.

It's never something I have dealt with as a player. I can not put myself in their shoes. But relegation is a horrible feeling/ You have to harness that feeling and make sure it does not happen again.''

The Dundalk boss will be returning to Scotland. He is not coming back to Oriel next season. My plan was not to come in and rip a squad apart mid-season and start again. If I had known about that things may have been different.

I thought when I came in, I would be adding two or three players to the squad. But instead, we lost the bones of nine players at the break in June which is huge.

It made things extremely difficult. I am sure the club will be back. But the structures must be put in place to get them back as quickly as possible.''

Asked if he will be here for the last two games of the season, given cuts the owner is expected to make, John said he does expect to finish off the season as manager as far as he was aware.

One of the best players to grace Oriel Park during the past 12 years has been Daryl Horgan. ''We just have not been good enough this season. The table never lies. For us, we always had the belief that we could get out of the relegation situation.

We knew that we had to win the last three games and hope that Drogheda slipped up along the way. Yes, they did slip up against Rovers tonight. But we slipped up against Derry. We could not afford any more slip-ups, so we are down. We are relegated.

We conceded our first goal from a set piece. A team just can not afford to do that. But look as I say the relegation has not come down to tonight. It's been down to our performances over the season.

I did not know anything about the financial difficulties at the club until it came out in the media a few weeks ago''.But that has had nothing to do with us getting relegated. We just have not been good enough this year.

''I am staying with Dundalk for next season. That of course is unless something drastic happens. I would hope to be a driving force to help Dundalk return to the Premier Division. Everybody in there who is staying will have to put their shoulders to the wheel.

We as players have allowed this to happen. The supporters' response to our relegation has been magnificent. I have seen teams who were relegated and the crowds would be waiting outside with pitchforks. Our supporters have been fantastic this season.

They do not deserve what has happened in any way shape or form. We have to take this on the head and whoever is here next year we must bounce back straight away.

''The response we got was immense. We are a real community club. Now when things are  bleak, there must be a lot of give and take between players.

''There is a great connection between Derry and Dundalk. You could see the Derry players that played with Dundalk were gutted at the end of the game. Dundalk are a club who should not be in Division One.

But we all need to be aware that there is no such thing as a club being too big for the First Division. The league table never lies. We should never have been relegated. But we have been. We all have to go away. We have to look at ourselves and what happened.

And our aim has got to be to win the first Division title. I will take one week off when the season finishes. Then I will get back to running, swimming and biking and prepare for pre-season.

It does not matter about all our glory of the past 12 years. Football is unforgiving. You do not get any leeway. You get what you are given and you get what you deserve''.

Daryl is a very determined player and would make a perfect player-manager. His reading of the game is perfect. His attitude to preparing for the new season shows how good and positive an attitude he has to the game. And most importantly he is getting his coaching badges.

Dundalk FC coach Liam Burns says it's very important that Dundalk come back stronger next season, Liam managed the club on his own this season on one occasion and together with Brian Gartland twice.

''We need to come back stronger and a better club next season. It's been a challenging year for everyone. It's not just over the last couple of games. It's been a difficult season. The table does not lie. If you are bottom at the end of the season, then that is where you deserve to be.

Since the Shelbourne game, you can't question the players' attitude. Their commitment has been unbelievable. Once the team crosses the white line they are in the firing line. Players are only humans. You must look after their mental health as well.

To a man, their attitude to training and all other facets as players has been very good. That can not be questioned. Relegation can happen to anyone. Look at Cork. They were our stiffest opponents in the successful years.

They have been relegated twice. And yet they have come straight back up. I see no reason why Dundalk can not do the same. Waterford, Shelbourne and Shamrock Rovers have all been relegated. But they have bounced back.

''But it's how you come back and how you come back the stronger club.'' When asked, Liam says nobody knows just what will happen. The troubles off the pitch are well documented. Whoever will be here. They just have to look around at the club and see how big it is.

Can we improve on things? We can 100 percent. The fanbase here is absolutely fantastic. Whoever comes in there is a good foundation. But the big factor is to try and get a team on the pitch. When we are six feet under there will still be Dundalk FC.

The club nearly folded four weeks ago. That would be 121 years of history wiped out. It should never have come to this. Lessons must be learned there.

If we learn from our lessons both on and off the pitch, I firmly believe Dundalk will become a force in League of Ireland football in years to come.'' It's vital that Dundalk hold on to Liam Burns.

He is a fantastic coach. I never realised just how good he was, until I saw him taking charge of team affairs when Dundalk looked for a new manager.

Robbie Benson says he was bitterly disappointed to see Dundalk getting relegated.''It was a nightmare season from start to finish. We have ended up, probably where we deserve, from all aspects of the club behind the scenes.

We had five different people in charge as we changed managers. We had to see fans pay for pre-match meals and buses. It was really unacceptable from the club, but mostly mainly down really down to us as players from start to finish. That's the disappointing thing.

Only a handful of players come away with a bit of credit from all of this and get a pass. Liam Burns from a staff point of view the fans do not deserve to go down. But we do not deserve to get the reception we got from them, for what we served up to them during the entire season.''

Robbie says he was so disappointed for the people in the shed and in the entire ground as the fact hit home that Dundalk were relegated. We were ahead of Drogheda even though we had no wins in the first 11 games of the season. Then we were on the up.

But we have failed to win our last eleven games. There you go. We only managed to win one game since the break. Every team in the league managed to put a run together during the season. We did not. We have been the poorest side in the league.

The 11 games we lost in many we have just been beaten by the odd goal. I can not understand how we did not come out on the right side of some. It's hard to see now. But with the support they have, I have no doubt that the club will return to the Premier division before too long.''

Robbie says it's now down to the club to get their act together behind the scenes ''I just do not know how it has been allowed to get to this stage. It's really unbelievable that the club was allowed to be let go from where it was to this bad now. I do not really know what else to say.

Drogheda to their credit pulled away from us. They had two lads up front who found goals for them every week since the break. It was a position where we were lacking as well.

The farthest thing from my mind right now is if I have a future here. At the moment it's just about dealing with the fact that we have been relegated tonight.''

Robbie has played a huge part in the success story of Dundalk over the past 11 years. He is also doing his coaching badges. He too would be a great guy to appoint as player-manager next season.

He is an excellent player, His reading of the game is top-class. And the way he spoke about how the demise of the club in this interview was so straightforward and honest.

Andy Boyle's reaction was somewhat similar to Robbie Benson's. He spoke very highly of the supporters. He also does not know whether he will be staying at Oriel next season. He says it is something he will look at after the last game of this season is played.

Dundalk centre half, Mayowa says he is devastated to see his hometown club go down.''I am heartbroken. But I have to look at the positives. At least we still have a club that we nearly lost it last month. That is the most important thing.

The club is so important to the community. The supporters were phenomenal tonight. We have the best supporters in the country. They give us the same support whether we win or lose.

The way the fans clapped us off the pitch at the end shows how incredible each and every one of our supporters are. They are a credit to themselves, their families and everybody that knows them.

Asked about his contractual situation at the club, Mayowa said that he had no answer to that. He also said that he could not honestly comment as to whether he would be staying at Oriel next season.

Mayowa said it was just so hard to put it into words, how he felt at that point just after seeing Dundalk getting relegated. All of the players he said have the same feeling.

Derry City boss Ruaidhri Higgins had said to me at the launch of the league in February that there was no way Dundalk would be relegated this season. I asked him that because I could see the mess Dundalk were in.

In mid-season, I asked him the same question at the Brandywell. Ruaidhri said there was no way it would happen. At that time Dundalk were bottom. The Derry manager told me both times that his former team were too good to go down.

I reminded him of what he had said before and during the season after Friday's game. ''Sadly you were right. Dundalk FC will always mean something very special to me. They played a big part in my life.''

Ruaidhri was part of the first team to win the league under Stephen Kenny. That was 10 years ago last Thursday when Dundalk went on to beat Cork City in the final league game of the season.

''I am totally heartbroken for people like Jimmy Fisher, Maxi, Maxi's family, John Murphy and Ailish in the office. I am especially heartbroken for the club's great supporters. Only five years ago they lost a treble on penalties. I was the assistant manager at the time. I am devastated for so many.''

''My heart goes out to Daryl Horgan, Robbie Benson, Andy Boyle and John Mountney who all played with and for me at Dundalk in the Kenny and Perth era.''

''The skipper John Mountney's heart was broken at full-time. The amount and sweat and blood that he has given this club over the years has been phenomenal. I am heartbroken for the club.

There was never any chance that I was going to stand in front of you and say Dundak were going to be relegated. They are a big club. I think and I hope that they bounce back at the first time of asking '''.It was a glowing tribute to the club from the Derry boss.

Where does the club go from here? There is no doubt that Dundalk's decline started with the departure of Stephen Kenny and Vinny Perth. Stephen left in 2018. Vinny departed in 2021.

Dundalk's decline and finally their fall from the top flight of Irish football was not as a result of what happened on the field. It was related to the difficult issues that the club had to deal with off the field. The constant change in ownership of the club was never going to help.

Four different owners in four years is unheard of in the history of the club. Dundalk is like a phoenix. They rose from the ashes of the First Division to the Premier Division in 2008.

That rise accelerated under Stephen Kenny and Vinny Perth. It really took off when both joined the club as manager and assistant boss in 2012. Now like a phoenix, the club has returned to the ashes.

The big question is if the club will survive to dominate Irish soccer at some time in the future. Everybody who loves Dundalk FC, owners, supporters groups, supporters and the local media should get behind the club and play their own distinct part in its rebuilding.

Do not forget the meeting of the new Trust next Friday at the Town hall at seven thirty pm. Have a good week. Please look after each other and be very careful out there.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice