No-one would love to see Oriel come alive again more than John Murphy


Inside Track | Joe Carroll
“Oriel Park is alive again.” That’s heard often on Dundalk FM, veteran match commentator, John Murphy, really giving it wellie. But it’s only a recording, spun as a prelude to an upcoming game.
Yes, Oriel continues to be peopled by genuine followers, but there’s been precious little for them to get excited about – rarely is Murphy given occasion to raise his voice in commentary.
On nearly all occasions since the beginning of the current league, the man behind the mic, along with his assistant, Gussie Hearty, have only had tales of woe for their listeners, and if that’s not difficult enough for them, they have a further hour to fill on a Saturday afternoon, analysing what had been on offer the night before.
Dundalk’s start to the season is the worse there’s been in years. The bottom spot has been theirs from early on, and needless to say, it will continue to be like that if results don’t improve.
Stephen O’Donnell is no longer manager. As is widely known, the one-time favourite with supporters is his days wearing the white jersey was given the heave-ho a few weeks ago by new club owner, Brian Ainscough.
I’m looking at things from the outside, depending on what I read in the papers and hear on radio. My opinion is O’Donnell found himself a victim of poor planning and some harsh criticism.
What manager could be expected to assemble a team a few weeks before the season begins? That’s what O’Donnell had to do. By that stage, all League of Ireland players keen to change clubs would have been snapped up, and with no local well to dip into, the only other place to source was the lower reaches of cross-Channel football.
To come up with a winning team in those circumstances would test the mettle of the most successful of managers.
This wasn’t a problem which the most illustrious of O’Donnell’s predecessors, Stephen Kenny, had to face.
The former Republic of Ireland boss had the money behind him to cherry-pick, and those he brought to Oriel more than justified the confidence placed in them. He still had to show he had the ability to mould them into a winning team. And he did, several times over.
Pat Hoban proved himself to be one of Kenny’s best signings, a predator who in due course would break a scoring record set by one of the town’s best-ever, Joey Donnelly.
The Galway man came under O’Donnell’s care, but before this season began, he took himself off to Derry, a move similar to the one Louth GAA felt aggrieved about with the departure of Mickey Harte.
It has never been fully explained why Hoban took his leave, least of all by the player himself. He had a year of his contract to run; had he stayed you can only ponder on what a difference he would have made in this goal-scarce season.
It’s for sure O’Donnell would have done all he could to keep Hoban in place, but maybe he hadn’t the power. It wouldn’t, after all, have been him who had charge of the purse strings, if money had been a factor.
The question was asked here when Kenny was running the line with the International side: what would he have been thinking of as a losing performance drew to a close. Would it have been, what sort of a grilling am I going to get from the hacks afterwards?
Stephen O’Donnell might have felt the same. It’s bad enough having to endure a torrid 90 minutes on the line, in his case looking at a group of players, most of unproven quality, and then having to come in to answer questions, some of which may have been asked the time before, and, from my reading of them, others not taking into account the situation O’Donnell had found himself in at the start of the season.
I was never a fan of after-match interviews in my time sitting at this paper’s sports desk. But when ‘stringing’ for a couple of the dailies, I could understand being told to ‘talk to the manager/s”. In that way, reports could be quickly filled and got back to the office to meet deadlines.
But there was more time to fill the Demo page, and the way I looked at it, is it not what the paper has to say, rather than managers and players, they putting their own spin on things, especially in the wake of a defeat?
It was a policy that got me through over two decades – and in that time, the 3 Earl Street production’s GAA page didn’t lose any of the reputation my predecessor, the legendary Paddy King, had made for it.
All of that said, my hope is that Dundalk get back on the bike again, and Stephen O’Donnell finds a less challenging job. It might be asking too much of Stephen Kenny for him to have a second Oriel Park coming.
But you never know. For one thing, he has a young ‘un to be steered in the right direction, and nothing would please the former boss more than to see Master Eoin blossom.
Then there’s the Voice of Oriel. There are few more enthusiastic about than John Murphy, and you can be sure he’d only love to give current meaning to the words that opened this piece.