New Dundalk manager needs to make big changes

Newly appointed Dundalk manager Jon Daly. Photo by Michael P Ryan/Sportsfileplaceholder image
Newly appointed Dundalk manager Jon Daly. Photo by Michael P Ryan/Sportsfile

The Commentary Box | The Gerry Malone Column

New Dundalk boss Jon Daly knows now how huge a task he has of trying to get his side off the bottom of the table, after they produced yet another horror away show, this time at Eamonn Deacy Park in Galway last Friday.

Dundalk has only collected two points away from home this season and has failed to notch up a win on the road since last November.

The new boss found himself in the hot seat in charge of the team, even though it had originally been stated he would be acting as an observer from the stand for the first game.

First team coach Liam Burns was in the stands as he was sitting out a one match suspension. Liam had prepared the team for Friday's game. But even he could never have imagined how poor this team would be.

Liam Burns went with the same team that had beaten Shamrock Rovers the week before in Oriel, bar Cameron Elliott being dropped to the bench and Sam Durrant replacing him up front.

Durrant normally plays on the wing when he comes on as a sub. The idea of placing him up front with Jamie Gullan just never worked at all. Dundalk started with three at the back.

Andy Boyle, Mayowa and Zak Johnson made up this sector. John Mountney and Archie Davies were the right- and left-wing backs.

Sam Durrant and Daryl Horgan were on the wings with Paul Doyle and Zak Bradshaw slotting in at the centre of midfield. Jamie Gullan was the lone striker. But the way the team lined out backfired totally on Dundalk as Galway ran the show for most of the first half.

Dundalk were so poor that they failed to muster a shot on target for the entire game. Galway were on target four times and off target 13 times. Dundalk had only four shots at goal for the entire night.

All were off target. Galway had four corner kicks and scored twice from two. Dundalk had only one corner kick. Galway keeper Brendan Clarke had no saves to make for the entire game while Ross Munro had two saves to make.

He also conceded two goals, one of which was an own goal from him. The stats do not lie. It also raised the question why Dundalk can play reasonably well in Oriel, yet at times look like a team away from home that any Leinster Senior League team could beat and for that matter a team from Division One.

To make matters much worse the team looks to have a mounting injury crisis. Robie Benson missed the game through injury from the start.

Scott High has gone back to Huddersfield with a bad hamstring injury and will not be returning. John Mountney was forced off through injury on 34 minutes. He was replaced by Hayden Muller.

One can only hope that he is okay. He was able to walk to the tunnel which was a good sign after a bad tackle on him. Mayowa was injured with six minutes remaining to half time.

That looks concerning as he appeared to be carrying the injury for spells in the first half. Jamie got a knock in the first twenty minutes of the game. He was playing very well up to then.

Gullan threatened the Galway defence at times and was causing them problems. Sadly, his influence on the game all but disappeared as it was clear that he was carrying an injury after the knock. Suddenly the Dundalk midfield seemed to weaken. And with Gullan not challenging up front, Galway's challenge grew.

Galway should have led on 21 minutes when a bad mistake by Zak Bradshaw allowed Aodh Dervin in. Bradshaw had back headed the ball straight into the path of Dervin.

His 20-yard effort came crashing back off the Dundalk crossbar. The men from the west were in front three minutes later. David Hurley pumped in an in-swinging header into the box.

There was panic in the Dundalk defence. Ross Munro turned the ball into his own net for an own goal. Munro had a poor game. He has been disappointing at times since his arrival at Oriel.

He can leave the Dundalk defence very shaky, as he is just not giving it the confidence it needs. He gave away an awful soft goal in Waterford two weeks ago. He did the same on Friday. He is with Dundalk on a two-year contract.

Dundalk were being overrun in attack, midfield and defence. They had no shape to themselves whatsoever in the first half. Mayowa was brought off at halftime with Cameron Elliott coming on.

The manager went with a 4-4-2 formation. It worked well for Jon Daly for the first 25 minutes of the second half as Dundalk had Galway pinned back into their own half.

Dundalk had a good move one 54 minutes when Muller slipped Gullan in with a chance. The Dundalk striker failed miserably as he saw his effort blocked by a Galway defender.

Ryan O'Kane was finally given his chance when he replaced Sam Durrant with 18 minutes remaining. Gullan was in again with a chance seeing his effort go inches wide. This third quarter of the game was the best part of the game where they showed a lot of confidence.

But disaster was lurking around the corner when Galway forced a corner. Bellurgan man Conor McCormack put in a great corner from the left.

Maurice Nugent got the second goal when he headed the corner to the net. He was totally unmarked. They deserved a third minutes later when Wassim Aouachria found Munro off his line.

His header left the Dundalk keeper in no man's land. The header came crashing back off the Dundalk crossbar. Dundalk were very lucky it was not 3-0.

As it was, it was an emphatic and fully deserved win for Galway United. Dundalk froze on the night just as they did in Waterford two weeks ago.

They just had little to offer and looked like a team that now believes they will finish in the automatic relegation spot. If Jon Daly did not know before what awaits him, he does now.

The new manager needs to make big changes to this side if they are to avoid the drop. If and how he can do that remains to be seen. Dundalk have problems at the back with Ross Munro in goals.

They also have problems with George Shelvey in the same position. He is on a long term suspension. Both keepers were given 2 year contracts.

It was a surprising commitment by the club to give them contracts like this when they could not secure the signing of Nathan Shepperd. He is a terrific keeper. He is available.

He would instill confidence in a Dundalk team that are crying out for some. Jamie Gullan has disappointed up front. He is a good player who needs another one up front with him.

I certainly would not see Cameron Elliott being the ideal player to use as a help for Gullan. Elliott has scored just one goal for Dundalk over a year and a half as a striker.

This is most certainly not satisfactory to try and form a lethal partnership. Dara Keane has been hit with injury since pre-season. He was signed from UCD.

But he had a poor injury record and has played in only a handful of games also as a midfielder. Why was he signed when he had such a record?

It's not the young player's fault, I'm sure in the longer term things can come good for him. But Dundalk just do not have that time to wait as they see themselves on the verge of relegation.

Jon Daly must be looking at the side he has at his disposal and wondering if he can get Dundalk out of the mess they are in. He told me afterwards that he would not have taken the Dundalk job had he not believed that he could move Dundalk to safety from relegation.

However he really has an awesome task if he is to achieve this. Dundalk were not at the races in the Galway game for the last 20 minutes of the first half.

From Jamie Gullan's injury in the 20th minute of the first half the structure fell out of the team. Galway had complete domination. However when Jon Daly got his side in at the break, he reorganised the defence back to the usual 4-4-2 system.

It worked for a considerable period of the second half. Dundalk were the better team for periods in the initial stages of the second half.

Zak Bradshaw was immense when he was moved back to his full back position. Ryan O'Kane was brought into the game on 67 minutes for Sam Durrant.

O'Kane has not been given a chance this season by the managers who have been at the helm this season. He is a terrific player with great potential.

If Jon Daly were to give him his chance I believe he would deliver. He has the potential also to help drag Dundalk out of the mess they are in.

Paul Doyle had a totally ineffective game. He had a tendency to lose the ball in key positions during the game in the centre of midfield.

One example was when Karl O'Sullivan dispossessed him in the middle of the park with 19 minutes remaining. He cut inside the Dundalk defence and shot wide.

It could have finished Dundalk's challenge. Maurice Nugent settled the issue a minute later when Conor McCormack's corner was headed home by the Galway midfielder as he rose with ease in the box to settle the game and give Dundalk the knockout punch. I was amazed it took Galway so long to kill off the Dundalk challenge. But when it came it was inevitable.

The fact that Dundalk failed to have even a single shot on target just about sums up their season. At this moment in time, they are simply not good enough to stave off relegation.

The new manager just does not have the players to prevent this from happening. As John Murphy said to me in an interview a few weeks ago, if the players are not there then not even Pep Guardiola could keep Dundalk up.

This team is much weaker than any of the two other teams that were relegated before. Martin Murray's 2002 team should never have gone down.

They won the Cup that year. It was also a season in which three teams went down. Dundalk finished third from bottom but well clear on points from the team that finished second from bottom. In any other season they would have been fine.

The recruitment has not been good at Oriel this season. I have been through this all before. But amazingly it's my understanding that when Dundalk began to recruit in early December it was felt that they were by no means too late looking for players on the Irish market.

The feeling at that time was that only a small number of clubs had made their moves for players on the domestic market at that stage. Well as we know, in the end Dundalk had to go in search of new players in the lower leagues of the UK.

At least 4 players were brought in on loan. This is a disaster as Dundalk look set to lose defenders Zak Johnson and Zak Bradshaw at the end of June.

They are due to return to their respective clubs at the end of June. Jon Daly will need to use all his skills of communication and perseverance to keep the players at Oriel until the end of the season. Hopefully he can.

New boss Jon Daly said after the game that conceding the first goal gave Dundalk a little hill to climb. He said the second goal made the task insurmountable.

"Both goals that Galway got were from set plays, which is a little bit disappointing. I just flew in today and met the boys pre-match in the hotel. It was good for me to see at first hand to see things.

"Liam Burns was suspended, so it was straight into action for me. Yes we have a lot to do, as do most teams in the league. I have been given the opportunity to work with a good group and a fantastic club.

"I have a firm belief that we can turn things around. We just have to get the results that will turn things around. I did think we lacked a bit of energy in the first half.

"I thought we lacked a real cutting edge in the first half. In the second half we did look better with two strikers. I was pleased with the way we played in the second half up until the second goal arrived. I thought we looked like the team that were in the ascendancy and that were going to get the next goal.

“Unfortunately we were done for the second goal from set play which we are aware of. Giving the goals away from the set play is a massive part of the game.

"We have to be more aggressive in both boxes, our own and the other team's. The second goal came at a time when we were on top. We were playing some good football and getting into some dangerous situations.

"That second goal gave Galway and their supporters a massive lift. I would not be here if I did not think I could keep Dundalk up. I did a reasonable job at Pats.

"I won the Cup last year and got them into Europe. I was not in any rush to get back into work. I have been away from my family for three and a half years. I have spent the last two and a half weeks with them.

"This job has come about. I have a very understanding family. I have been able to get straight back into work. I would never have taken the job if I felt that the players as a group were not good enough to get us out of trouble in the league.

"I got the call about the job late last week, early this week. Things were only finalised late Thursday. I just booked a flight for today and came straight across to meet the players for the first time today, only a few hours before the Galway game.

“The switch from 3-5-3 to a 4-4-2 at half time gave us a bit more attacking quality in the second half. It really helped us going forward. The previous week the first half formation helped us beat Shamrock Rovers.

"Thus in many ways different formations can suit different games. The switch in formation just gave us a bit more quality going forward. It allowed our key attacking players the chance to work on Galway.

"We will assess John Mountney's injury over the weekend. Hopefully it's not serious. He is a key player and somebody who I am looking forward to working with.

"I know the group and I know the players. I know the challenges ahead. But again, I am confident we will get out of the trouble we are in at the moment.”

Dundalk now have 57 points to play for starting with arch enemies Derry City. Despite all the great Dundalk players that have moved to Foyleside in recent years, Derry are surprisingly not having as good a season as many thought they would.

But they are still bang in the title race. Dundalk have not given away a goal at Oriel over the last six games. It will be a very tough game. But they might just spring a surprise on Ruaidhri Higgins

Dundalk's late former one-armed striker Jimmy Hasty was back in the news this week. A documentary made on Jimmy's life by the Noah Media Group for UEFA TV won the Sports Emmy award for short documentaries in New York on Wednesday night.

Jimmy was a one-armed player from Belfast signed by Dundalk from Newry Town who went on to help them to win a league title for the first time in 30 years.

Sadly, Jimmy was assassinated by the loyalist paramilitary group the UVF on 11th October 1974 just because he was catholic. It's strongly believed that Jimmy's murder was one of the many in the north that involved security force, loyalist collusion.

The documentary was produced by Richard Millway from the Noah Group. The documentary was entitled Extraordinary Stories: Jimmy Hasty One-Armed Wonder. Richard Millway was presented with the award.

He spoke to the audience immediately afterwards. “I would like to thank all the great people who worked on the documentary. I would also like to thank Dundalk Football Club.

"Jimmy's family and the Malone family who all helped us so much in the production of the documentary. Jimmy was brought to Dundalk by its late director Jim Malone.

!Jimmy's sons Paul and Martin were such a huge help. Jimmy's wife was excellent. It was the first time she has spoken in public about Jimmy's death.

"It's 50 years since Jimmy's death and Margaret has never uttered a word in public about it until now. She did so with such amazing bravery and courage. I would like to dedicate this award to her.”

Paul Hasty told me that the documentary was hard to watch. He is Jimmy's youngest son. He says it was great that Jimmy got the recognition he deserved.

Paul was only two and a half when Jimmy was gunned down and murdered. “My dad was a character and was a totally innocent man. He was murdered just because he was a member of the Catholic community.

"I find it shocking that nobody was ever brought to justice for my dad's murder. There is belief that my dad was set up. The murderers are believed to have had a getaway area.

"There was evidence missing from the scene, like a pair of gloves and a car around the corner. We were told in later years whether it's true or not, that the people who murdered my father were agents for the British Army and they helped the murderers to escape from the scene.

"My mother is 85 this year. I would like to see justice for Jimmy Hasty before she passes on. My dad will always be in my heart and head. My mother and myself and the rest of the family are so proud of this documentary.”

John Murphy of Dundalk FM was Jimmy's captain during the Hasty era at Oriel. “Jimmy was a brilliant character to be around. When you saw Jimmy play football it was just out of this world.

"Jimmy had excellent balance even with just one arm. He could score goals equally with both the right and left foot. He could hold the ball up so well. He had all the assets that you would want from a centre forward.”

John played a key role recalling Jimmy Hasty's time at Dundalk in the documentary. When he saw the documentary, John said it was a great tribute to his former striker. He says it brought all the memories flooding back including the shocking news of Jimmy's murder.

Let's hope Dundalk can beat Ruaidhri Higgins and Derry City next Friday. The new manager will do well at Oriel in the long term. But if he is to save Dundalk from relegation, he does not have that much time.

Have a safe week. Please look after yourself and those around you.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice