John Murphy set for Dundalk FM return as Lilywhites gear up for busy schedule


The Commentary Box | The Gerry Malone Column
When I first get a glance of a team sheet before the start of a game, I always look to see if there are any team changes from the previous week or if anybody has returned from injury. Next Friday as Dundalk make the journey up the road to take on league leaders Shelbourne, there is one return I am delighted to see.
John Murphy from Dundalk FM has not featured in the match commentaries this season. His absence has left a huge gap among the many thousands of listeners who tune in to listen to the station's excellent coverage of Dundalk games home and away.
John has been missing as a result of an illness that completely floored him for about six weeks. But now the good news is that the former Dundalk League Championship winner of 1963 is returning to the airways.
I've been keeping an eye on John's progress since he was struck down with the illness. But from the start his counterpart Gussie Hearty was one hundred per cent assured John would return.
The good news came on Friday that the much loved former Dundalk player has passed all fitness tests and will return next Friday for the Shelbourne game at Tolka Park. In many ways I wish John was returning to play for Dundalk as I'm told that in his day he was a formidable player who had an excellent football brain.
Stephen O'Donnell could be doing with somebody like John in his first eleven. But as we all know time waits for nobody and the former club defender is now 85. Hopefully will be with us for many years to come.
John started his broadcasting job with Dundalk FM in January 2006. He soon became a household name all over the country with straight, honest and forthright broadcasting. John reads the game as he sees it and he also calls it the same way.
The move to broadcasting has become just another part of the legendary status the man has with the club. His footballing days have stood to him and perhaps explain his fitness and his ability to fight off ill health.
Two years ago John became one of the many victims of Covid 19. But add to that the legend was also hit with heart trouble. John spent some time in the Mater Hospital in Dublin and thankfully emerged fully fit again to take up his microphone once more.
His recovery amazed us all. But it did not amaze me as over the years I have grown to see how much his broadcasting job at Dundalk FM means to him and also how much he loves bringing live coverage of his club to the supporters.
John is a fountain of knowledge about Dundalk and football in general. Nothing he says to me causes a surprise. He played against Alex Ferguson in the old Inter City Fairs cup in 1968 for Dundalk against Glasgow Rangers at Ibrox.
He played against the husband of the Manchester United physiotherapist who had an affair with then club manager Tommy Doherty. He brought United back up to the old first Division now the Premiership just one year after United were relegated.
But when Doherty won the cup with United it emerged he had been having an affair with the United club physio. The scandal cost Doherty his job. John Murphy's claim to fame in this saga is that at one stage he played against her husband some years earlier.
Last Friday I called to see John and spoke to him at length about his return to Dundalk FM on Friday night, the bad start Dundalk have had in the league and most importantly how his health was.
Inevitably we spent most of our time speaking about how awful it was to see Dundalk rock bottom of the league."With the help of God I feel great” were John's first words. “I will be back for the Shelbourne game on Friday night with the help of God and with my Sports Academy Program on Saturday" said the great man.
"I will be talking about football the whole time” John told me. "Next weekend will be a very busy time for me as the Shelbourne game will be followed by the must win game against Drogheda on the following Monday with a kick off time at one pm''.
“There will be plenty to talk about with next weekend's football. And I will be well capable of doing that''. John revealed that he was hit by a very bad bout of flu that forced him onto a heavy dose of antibiotics and steroids. "The medication worked and helped me to stay out of hospital".
"I found my illness very frustrating as it kept me out of Oriel Park''. I missed the games as a supporter but also as a former captain.
“I love to see Dundalk winning as whatever I got out of football it was from Dundalk I got it from. I will never forget Dundalk until I pass on as they are a club deep in my heart.”
''It was great to have a press conference with the new owner at the beginning of December as the local media never had one with the two owners of Stats Sports or Andy Connolly who were the previous owners of the club.”
The fans make the club, no matter what is thought of budgets or other club business."I was very disappointed with the last owners as they would not take the fans into their confidence.”
John says the owners never told the fans if they needed help or asked fans if they could help. "I was stunned by the news that the club had debts of around 750,000 euro. It makes so much sense that European Football can not be missed out on.”
John says that last season that Europe was missed out on. ''This has proved very costly for the club.
“The new owner has stepped in and is at least keeping things afloat. He has paid the bills and the players wages. The fact that the players are getting their wages at the end of each week is what really matters.
“It's surprising that if wages are not paid at the end of a week,how quickly things will go downhill for the players. The manager can talk all he wants, but if there are no wages being paid then it has a huge rippling effect on a player outside the club for them.
“They are totally dependent on the wage.They must put food on the table for the family. If there is no money then there is utter instability in the home.This is why it's vital a club continues to pay the wages despite the fact their debts may be mounting up''.
On the playing front John says Dundalk were very impressive against Shamrock Rovers in the first game of the season. ''But I did not get carried away by that result. Going back to my playing days, there is no motivation needed when you are sitting in the dressing room waiting to play Shamrock Rovers.
“Money does not come into things as a player when you are playing Shamrock Rovers. The important thing was for the players to get themselves up for the next game against Galway at Oriel which the players just simply failed to do.
“Shamrock Rovers take the best out of any player and all they want to do is beat them. Dundalk maybe got just too much praise after the result against Rovers.The weaknesses were not seen in the Dundalk team that are occurring now.
“Dundalk failed to score against Galway in the game following the Rovers clash. If you do not score goals you will not win games. And this Dundalk team simply can not seem to score goals,” the former Dundalk skipper said.
'You can have a good defence, but a simple mistake at the back can leave you one nil down. If you can not score which the current Dundalk team can not seem to do then you are beaten,” said John Murphy.
Dundalk should have been building their squad this season around Pat Hoban, Darragh Leahy, John Martin, Greg Sloggett and Nathan Shepherd are the foundation of your team.
They are players who should never have been allowed leave, even though only two of them had contracts for this season. The club should surely have been adding on to these players but they failed to do that.
The club has lost a man who scored 150 goals. What other club would sign a player like that only Dundalk. Whatever happened between Hoban and O'Donnell has never come out. It should never have happened.
There should have been an agreement with Pat Hoban that seeing he only had a tear left on his contract with Dundalk to let bygones be bygones. O'Donnell should have told Hoban that he wanted him to play for Dundalk and that he wanted him to score goals.
John said that if Dundalk had Hoban now that maybe the club would not be in the position it is in now. John asked me if I had ever seen a house built without a foundation. I said no. Pat Hoban was a key part of the foundation of the club John. He has been let go.
Instead it has taken in players where it has been found out already that some are just not up to the standard. If you are bringing in players from the UK then you would expect them to be of a higher standard than Hoban or Sloggett.
But that has simply just not been happening. It's not the players fault” said John. They have been given a contract. "The current problem with the Dundalk team started last year,” said John.
“That's the one thing I am very surprised at with Stephen O'Donnell. I like him as a manager. But you can not go on saying we are giving bad goals away. Surely to God it's Stephen O'Donnell's job to fix that.
“As an ex footballer, the Dundalk boss and with Brian Gartland as the second in command should be able to solve the problems of giving goals away. Where were the new intake of players seen. Did anyone from the club go over and see them” said John.
“I do not think so. Many of the players are signed on the evidence of videos. If I was trying to get a player signed with a club I would only send a good video. It would certainly not be a bad one” said Murphy.
On Ryan O'Kane being left out of a starting place on the team John had much to say. “Ryan O'Kane is a very promising player. I believe Ryan O'Kane is a player that needs guidance.
“He is only a young guy. He has been very good for Dundalk scoring vital goals. Dundalk thinks now that he is looked upon as if he is in the veteran stage. He is only a young guy learning his trade.
“I believe Ryan needs coaching. I believe he needs outlets such as how to know how to lose a full back and learning to have an understanding with your own full back. He needs to be coached to make runs and to learn how to take people out of the game.
“John says he did all of these things with certain players when he was a manager. My players he added knew what i expected of them. What the players could not do, I tried to put in their head what they could do.
“The manager picks his team from what happens in training. It's a great guide to selecting a team. If you can get each section of your team doing what they are capable of doing and up to their own ability, you eventually end up with a team that knows how to play with each other and maybe know how to come back from the dead and win a game that they should not have won.”
John says at the moment Dundalk seem to have a team that can win a game whatsoever. “It looks as if some of the new players that were signed in the close season seem to be on a mystery tour. They do not know each other and they can not seem to gel together. This can not get you results” said the former Dundalk assistant manager.
“The one thing Dundalk have got to do is to win their home games.They have not won one game at home this season.You can keep the fans happy once you win the home games. The team are letting themselves down in front of their own fans.
“Fans are like players. They will lose confidence in their own team too. Fans will drift if the results are not being got at home and if they drift you might not get them back” says the Dundalk FM commentator.
“We need the old turnstiles to click continuously. But sadly we can not expect crowds to attend games at Oriel Park when one looks at the huge growth in attendances at the Dublin venues.
“The facilities are a disgrace at Oriel. The new owner himself has said this. Unless we do something with the pitch and the facilities then Dundalk will always be the paupers in League of Ireland football.”
John then focussed on the situation right now. ''First of all, where are we now with the team?” If we keep changing the team from one year to the next how can you build anything? It makes the manager's job very hard then.
I'm sure Stephen O'Donnell would prefer to have all his players in before the pre-season games. Time also runs out for every manager especially if you are not winning games. And when you look up the league table you will see Shelbourne fourteen points clear of Dundalk.
There are no weak teams in the Premier Division this season where Dundalk could expect to say they would collect six or seven points from. Drogheda would be Dundalk's hope where they can pick up 16 points from.
But can we depend on Dundalk to clinch 12 points by beating Drogheda in the four games they will meet this season. Dundalk did it last season. Then after that their nearest rivals are St. Pat's, Bohemians, and Shamrock Rovers.
“All of Dundalk's opponents will pick up points. But can the same be said of Dundalk” says John. “It's getting desperate for Dundalk Football Club. And the more desperate things get for a club the more inclined they are to change their manager.
“I do not know if that's the solution with Stephen O'Donnell. Any new manager coming in would still have to deal with those players. I think if you took Pep Guardiola over to take charge of the players, would he be able to do anything with them.
“At the moment the players who signed for Dundalk are not doing the job they were brought in for. It seems clear that the best hope Dundalk can have is to aim for second from the bottom in the table and aim for the play offs.
“The longer we keep losing games the more they will keep getting away from us. If we can't put together one win, how are the club going to put together go on a run of more than five or six wins.
“It's going to be very hard to keep pace with any team unless Stephen O'Donnell has a magic wand and get all the players clicking and getting them all playing for each other.”
John says that in his interviews Stephen O'Donnell shows great faith and belief in his players and that they will get the club up the table and out of trouble. But at the moment the players are not doing the job that they are being paid for.
“It's going to be a relegation battle this season. If the team can not put a win of 5 or 6 games together then a fight for the play off spot is all Dundalk can seem to hope for.
“O'Donnell always shows great faith in his players and always seems to have the belief that they will get the club out of trouble. All we can do is hope that the manager is right. We do not see the training.
“But this is a very important part of a player's career. You can tell a player that has potential and one that has more in him to give you and fitness in training " said John.
''Stephen O'Donnell can see things in players that the supporters can not see in training. But if they are not showing it from a quarter to eight on a Friday night until twenty to ten then supporters can simply not believe what the manager is saying about his players.
“Results will tell you that at the moment no matter what Stephen O'Donnell says about the panelw we are finding it very hard to believe him because the league table does not lie.”
John says he would not be inclined to change managers at Oriel at the moment despite the fact they are rock bottom. John says that any manager that comes in will still have the same material to work with.
“John says that up to now the only thing he has been very surprised that he has not been able to cure the team's ailments at the back.''Stephen O'Donnel is going to have to learn very quickly that defending at the back four is all about defending.
“It's not about getting forward. It's nice for defenders to get forward when they have a chance to have a good run. I would rather be seeing my back four defending than attacking when the case arises.”
John acknowledged that Louie Annesley showed great leadership at the back during the recent Waterford game. And John acknowledged the terrific performance that Zac Johnson put in as centre half also.
But John says every player must show leadership on the pitch.''When I was captain at Dundalk there were players who were older than him who could tell him things he did not know.
Back then we were all leaders. And I am just hoping that the current team can gel very quickly and get us out of trouble. But the longer the current situation continues the worse Dundalk are.
If I read in the morning that Stephen O'Donnell was sacked i would not be surprised.The first thing you would say is just look at his results.Stephen O'Donnell would tell you the same''.
''Managers live on their results. It's as simple as that. If you do not get results especially at home then the manager is in
trouble. Because at home the supporters come in paying their hard cash they expect to see the team playing well." John said he feels the club has three or four matches to show they might be able to get out of trouble.
He says the next four which include Shelbourne, Drogheda and Derry and Bohemians are key. He says that Dundalk are going to need to get points from these games even though it will be very difficult. “I believe that the local players from Ireland know the league. You should be able to get more passion from them rather than those who do not yet understand the league.”
If Dundalk do not get points from the next four games then Dundalk will be looking up the table for the rest of the season like UCD were last year and who were relegated.
John finished by saying he believes that Stephen O'Donnell has got about four games to save his job.
These would be the next four. He also says that if O'Donnell has to go then Brian Gartland who recruited the players would also be in a situation of having to go as well.
John revealed that he did an interview with a soccer writer last week about Jimmy Hasty. The writer was amazed that Jim Malone bought Hasty with his own money and with the board not knowing what he was doing.
He told the author that Malone was told by the board they would not sanction the signing of the one armed player. Malone got his money back within 3 weeks when Hasty got a hatful of goals.
The writer was all the more stunned when he heard that Jimmy had only one arm. The book which covers a broad range of soccer stories is due out later in the year.
Dundalk's form on the field continued to disappoint earlier last week when they were knocked out of the quarter finals of the Leinster Senior Cup by two goals to nil by Leinster Senior League side St. Mochtas.
It could have been more. The team had up to seven players of first team experience. Dundalk should not be losing to Leinster Senior League teams. It just shows how much trouble the team is in.
On Friday the news was much better. Dundalk beat Larne who are Irish League Champions and current leaders at a venue close to Belfast. The game was played behind closed doors and was top secret.
The teams have not been released to the media even now. All I know is that Dundalk won one nil, which was a great achievement. Personally I respect these behind closed door games.
Yet I can not understand why some details of the game are not released afterwards. For the record the winning goal was scored by Daryl Horgan. Louie Annesley was on international duty with Gibraltar last week.
Sam Durrant was called up to the Sri Lankan national team in a surprise move last week. He qualifies to play for Sri Lanka through his mother. Sri Lanka played Papua New Guinea last Friday and Bhutan on yesterday Monday.
John Gill stepped down as first team manager of Warrenpoint FC. John replaced Barry Grey as boss last November when he moved to Newry City.
Irish clubs can have a player or two of their team away on trial with British teams during the international break. Best of luck to all. And if there was a Dundalk player away on trial I hope it went well for him.
Dundalk's clash with Shelbourne at Tolka Park next Friday. Dundalk must get at least a point from this game. On Easter Monday they will play Drogheda United in a must win game at Oriel. Kick-off time is 1pm.
Lose this one and then I'm afraid the team will see the automatic relegation trap door open up considerably further even though it's still so early in the season.
Have a safe week. Happy Easter. Please everybody look after each other.