New rules are finding favour – Louth must do the same

As this photo from the 1957 All-Ireland shows, eight from each team, the six  forwards and two midfielders, used line up for the throw-in. Now it's just two, a midfielder from each side.placeholder image
As this photo from the 1957 All-Ireland shows, eight from each team, the six forwards and two midfielders, used line up for the throw-in. Now it's just two, a midfielder from each side.

Inside Track | Joe Carroll

Gaelic football has witnessed a few revolutions, if we can call them that, in recent times. The changes brought about in the latest, but not the others, are written into the book of instructions.

The work of Jim Gavin’s FRC committee is meeting with acclaim, though maybe not widespread. Still, the changes are likely to become permanent after some tweaking.

That slight alternations are needed is accepted by those most enthusiastic about the whole concept. First of the revolutions was most visible, you could say, when Tyrone played Kerry in the 2003 All-Ireland semi-final.

Kerry players weren’t given a chance to breathe when on the ball. Two, three and sometimes more Tyrone men were on them like a rash, and it invariably led to a turnover.

It paid dividends. Tyrone went on the win the game and the title, and when they regained it in 2005 and again two years later, it was Kerry they beat in the final each time.

Pat Spillane had a name for it; but no matter how many times he shouted ‘puke football’, one of the game’s most decorated couldn’t get under Tyrone skins. Take your beating, was the call from Dungannon and other such places in the Red Hand.  

There was another outcry, many thousands in the chorus for this one, when Jim McGuinness drove the bus to Croke Park in 2012 and parked it around the half-back line.

It, and another McGuinness invention, blanket defending, was effective if not attractive. His Donegal side beat Mayo in the final, having earlier got the better of Kerry and Cork.

It hadn’t worked for McGuinness the previous year, but maybe because he was still trying to perfect it. Neutrals were nearly in tears as they watched the Ulster champions mesmerise – yes, mesmerise – Dublin, who, at the time, were attempting to get back on the All-Ireland ladder.

Boos from the crowd were more prominent than scores. The semi-final ended with just 14 points on the board, eight of them going to Dublin, with Pat Gilroy’s team just about finding a way to cure their first half frustration.

Three weeks later, Dublin were crowned champions, beating Kerry by a point, 1-12 to 1-11. Before the decade would end they’d have six more titles to their credit, followed by another two in the ‘Twenties.

Donegal didn’t change tack, however. They got their reward, but not universal acclaim, with their 2012 success.

The new rules don’t allow for a team to have all of their players in one half of the field, and that’s a change to be welcomed.

At least three must be in the opposing half, and while there were fears this might have the trio standing just a foot or two beyond the demarcation line in the middle of the field, making little difference to what we saw several times in last year’s All-Ireland final, one half of the field empty, save for a goalkeeper, on several occasions, it hasn’t happened.

You see at least one of them lurking around the square, and, of course, he has to be marked like his two colleagues. That’s not so much a change, but a blessing.

What the new rules have emphasised is the need to have six-footers at midfield, or someone smaller who’s great in their air.

If a goalkeeper or his defenders are not working as a team with the short kick-out, the way Stephen Cluxton and his Dublin colleagues did, there is no alternative but to go long.

As for swarming around a player in possession, it can still be done, but there’s now an escape route for a player who wins a free.

Rather than having to place the ball or kick from his hands – which can still be done – he can now immediately take off on a solo knowing he can’t be touched until he puts in four toe-taps.

Niall McDonnell aimed most of these kicks at midfield, or beyond, in the game with Roscommon and it didn’t pay dividends, mainly because the Rossies were much better in the air. And then when running at defence they had lots of avenues to explore, especially down the middle.

Louth have a lot of things to get right for Sunday’s away match with Cavan. There has to be a good catcher alongside Tommy Durnin, especially if the short kick-out is not working – and employing Sam Mulroy as one of the three permanently up front, a target for a long ball coming from the back, could pay dividends. There’ll also be a need to tighten up in defence.

It’s a must-win game for Louth if they are not to be looking over their shoulder on the turn-in to the second half of the competition.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice