Can the new playing rules see beyond the year-long trial period?


Inside Track | Joe Carroll
When the GAA’s new playing rules were sanctioned – for a year’s trial period – the one that most pleased me decreed that at all times both teams should have at least three players, aside from the goalkeeper, in each half of the field.
This would remove the possibility of one half being depopulated. To me, this was one of the reasons why the game had become so boringly unattractive, 29 players, sometimes the whole 30, crowding beyond the mid-point, all those on attack making themselves available for a pass, maybe even one of a few yards, and the defenders closing off the route to goals, and at the same time positioned themselves for a block.
It would make some sense if this happened late on, a team chasing an equaliser or a winner, the other calling all hands to the pumps. But it was a regular feature at all times, even in the most important of games. This year’s All-Ireland final didn’t escape.
On at least a half-dozen times, most players were bunged together, making the short of sight in the Davin Stand, or on Hill 16, left to wonder what was going on at the other end of the field. At the same time, the crowd was silent. Not a tweet from of anyone in the crowd of 83,000, this on football’s biggest day of the year.
So, it’s going to be different in this regard once the National League kicks in at the end of next January? Only slightly. There’ll be a dashed line in the middle of the field, and all the three from each team will have to do is stand behind it. Maybe only six inches back.
It may, however, encourage teams to put in a long punt, aiming to get one of their frontmen into the clear. Anything to consign ‘parking the bus’ to the scrapyard, or stop us from thinking it’s an under-10 contest we’re watching, everyone chasing after the ball, is to be welcomed. But I have my doubts.
The throw-in, to get the game underway, will have just two lined up. The other midfielders will be on the sideline, only entering the fray when the ref blows the whistle.
This should eliminate the jostling that’s been going on since the very old rule was scrapped, the one that had eight from either side, the six forwards and two midfielders in place, though it’s for sure there were shenanigans even then.
A story. There was a time, even further back, when the eight players from each side lined up for the throw-in and had to hold hands. Louth were playing Kerry in a junior match one day, and before the ball had even been thrown in, a Louth player was calling for treatment, his hand almost crushed to pieces by an opponent who could safely be described as ‘mountainy’, fists like shovels.
From the past to the future, and what else to look out for at Ardee, or wherever Louth are playing in the league.
All kick-outs are to go beyond the newly-introduced 40-metre arc. This will eliminate the short kick-out, and should encourage high fielding. But if he’s still manning the Dublin goals, don’t think Stephen Cluxton won’t be able to find his man.
Cluxton never went far enough out the field, leaving his manager with no need to worry if there was someone minding the shop; but others did. They can still do it, but can only take a pass if inside the opposition half.
That arc, mentioned earlier, will extend back to the 20-metre line on each end of the field. A shot from outside of it that goes over the bar will be worth two points. It’s meant to encourage kicks from long range.
The new advanced mark is good news for forwards. Any of them who makes a clean catch inside the 20-metre line from a kicked pass from beyond the 45-metre line, can continue playing; but if no advantage accrues – a score, presumably – the referee will give a free from where the mark had been made.
A tough one that on defenders. Say the forward who made the catch is then disposed by a clean tackle, is it fair on the tackler that the forward should then get another chance?
Patsy Connolly, who refereed Louth club matches long after retirement age, once told this paper that a referee will ‘need a computer’. That was only after it was decided to introduce the black card.
Patsy would probably agree that legislating for the use of a pal of the red and yellows was pie compared to what’s in front of today’s middle men.
It might be easy enough for inter-county refs, assisted by neutral officials, but problems could arise at club league matches, the ref having to call on one from either team to carry a flag.
“Hey, ref, your man (from the other side) was over the half-way line.” And just to even things up, there’ll be the same call from the opposite side later on.
Which brings to mind another story. Before sending their man out to do linesman, a club, which shall remain nameless, would tell their flag-waver before the game: “You’re doing the line for us, so do it for us.” In other words, wave it one way and one way only.
A winter programme of mostly weightlifting is the usual for county teams ahead of a new season. There’ll probably be more to it this time. After websites have been dissected, there’ll be trial games, with the teams that adapt best to the new rules having an advantage, at least in early league ties.