Brave Louth effort, but no denying Donegal their win


Inside Track | Joe Carroll
Louth can have complaints over not getting a fair crack of the whip in last Sunday’s All-Ireland quarter-final with Donegal at Croke Park.
Two questions: How was Ciarán Keenan not awarded a penalty in the opening half, and should the Donegal goal have been allowed to stand?
Add to that, Conall McKeever and Sam Mulroy’s unfortunate clash of the heads in the first half, which resulted in McKeever having to go off and Mulroy being less active in open play than normal, but still with an eye in for a score. Underdogs need most things to go right.
One thing, however, that can’t be complained about is the result. Donegal, the fresher of the two teams, won by eight points, 1-23 to 0-18, and deserved the laurels.
They now advance to a semi-final meeting with Galway, whose shock defeat of Dublin came after Armagh had put two goals between themselves and Roscommon.
There’ll be a reminder of two previous All-Ireland finals, the 1953 renewal and the one of 2002, when Armagh take on Kerry in the other semi-final.
Donegal’s major asset was their ability to prise open the Louth defence, and more important, finish moves with scores. They had marksmen all over the place, in defence as well as in attack, a point emphasised by No 7, Peadar Mogan, finishing they day with 0-5. They attacked with speed, and rarely was a chance wasted.
Louth couldn’t match this, though 18 scores is a tally that would win lots of matches. It’s not that there wasn’t much play in the Donegal half of the field.
There was, but all too often moves broke down with a turn-over, or a shot wide of the mark. The missed chances amounted to nine.
Conor Grimes, so often the one to send for when a score is needed, had a complete off-day, missing the target on a number of occasions. And while as industrious as ever, Ciaran Keenan showed again that finding the sweet spot is not his strongest lieu.
Because of this, there was more emphasis than ever on Sam Mulroy’s free-taking, and he delivered. Just once out of five attempts did the team captain fail to hit the target – the one that didn’t go over came back off the post. Added to that were his two from play, one coming when he was heavily bandaged.
Mulroy didn’t deserve to be on the losing side, and neither did the one we often referred to as the warhorse, Tommy Durnin. When others were finding the target elusive, the big midfielder chipped in with four wonderful points from play, and was always driving forward. Also, If there had been an award for catch of the day, he’d surely have won it for that first half effort of his.
It was caught beautifully on camera, and showed that in a game where fisted passing, oftentimes crossfield and backwards, is de rigueur, there’s still room for that thing of beauty, the high catch.
Durnin and Bevan Duffy are the team elders, both in their 30s. If neither is back for next season, finding replacements will be a problem for Ger Brennan. Durnin was Louth’s outstanding player on Sunday.
Louth were always on the back foot, but it wasn’t until well into the second half that Donegal finally put the game to bed. That was after an Eoghan Bán Gallagher goal was allowed to stand.
As seen on television, the Killybegs clubman was clearly in the square when he fired to the net after the ball had come back off the post.
But, says a local referee, it’s only when the scorer is in the square before his colleague passes it his way that the goal is disallowed.
Put that one down to the umpires, if we will – that Ciarán Keenan wasn’t awarded a penalty when grounded can be laid at the door of referee Joe McQuillan.
Though the incident took place beyond the 20 metre line, a penalty would have had to be awarded because Keenan was clear on goal when fouled.
It looked grim for Louth when McKeever and Mulroy clashed in the 20th minute. Donegal led by three points at the time. No questioning the Louth response, however. Niall McDonnell brought off a great save, and Ryan Byrne popped one over.
Conor Early signalled his entry as a replacement for McKeever with a fine score, and then twice before the change-over Louth got to within a point.
But before the change of sides, Donegal had stretched their lead to 0-11 to 0-8. Louth were in touch until the Gallagher goal. After that, it felt it would take a three-pointer at the other end to get Louth back into it.
It didn’t come, just a number of points, two coming from Ciarán Byrne, whose injury in the previous week’s match with Cork wasn’t as serious as first thought.
And nearly every time Louth scored, Donegal were in immediately with a reply. With the pressure off, Jim McGuinness’ side could take aim from even the most acute of angles, and it worked for them.
A slightly disappointing end to the campaign, but aside from everything said above, is it fair to ask a team to go out and play just a week after another must-win match? And against a team that had a fortnight off?
There were negatives over the past couple of months, but these were more than outweighed by the positives. Two teams can be pleased with their efforts – the one on the field, and the other on the sideline. Still to reach the top table; but, let’s hope, waiting for the waiter to show the Reds to their seats