Former Dundalk FC executive awarded almost €17,000 due to unfair dismissal


Former Chief Operations Officer Martin Connolly wins case after the WRC ruled he had been unfairly dismissed
Dundalk Football Club has been ordered to pay €16,667 in compensation to their former Chief Operations Officer, Martin Connolly, after the Workplace Relations Commission (WRC) ruled he had been unfairly dismissed from his role.
The decision follows a detailed two-day hearing held in November 2024, and March 2025 in which WRC adjudication officer Kara Turner found that the club had failed to provide any substantial reason for Connolly’s sudden removal from his position.
Connolly was told by the club’s then-new owner, Brian Ainscough, on 26th February, 2024, that he was being let go. He received no prior warning or explanation.
The adjudicator’s report noted: “There were no communications between the parties in the February to May 2024 period. It was not suggested to the complainant that he was being made redundant.”
Connolly remained on the club’s payroll until 22nd May, 2024, but testified that he received no formal correspondence from the club and had not been told that he would be paid beyond February.
The WRC heard that he only received a single text message after the dismissal, which asked him to process payroll. Otherwise, there was no further contact from the club’s owner or any other representative.
Connolly said the dismissal took a toll on his career, forcing him to take up work in a pharmaceutical factory from September 2024, earning a lower salary and facing a long commute and 12-hour shifts.
Counsel for Connolly, Aaron Shearer BL, pointed to the public nature of the dismissal and the reputational damage caused.
The WRC accepted that Connolly made some efforts to find work in the months following his dismissal but noted the evidence did not fully support consistent efforts during the summer of 2024.
Despite this, Kara Turner concluded the dismissal was unjust. “The respondent has not established substantial grounds for the termination of the complainant’s employment.
“There was no conduct on the complainant’s part or any other issue put before me that warranted termination of the complainant’s employment in the manner it occurred.”
She added that a compensation award of €16,667 was “just and equitable” considering the financial loss Connolly experienced.
Legal representation for the club argued Connolly had not done enough to find alternative employment and challenged the claim of reputational harm, but this argument was not enough to sway the decision.
This is not the first time the Lilywhites have faced consequences over its handling of dismissals.
In January, the WRC also ruled in favour of former player and head of football operations, Brian Gartland, awarding him nearly €53,000 after he was dismissed following a protected disclosure about player safety concerns.