Dundalk will come away with nothing from Dalymount unless they can start to produce

Dundalk midfielder Paul Doyle. Photo by Seb Daly/Sportsfileplaceholder image
Dundalk midfielder Paul Doyle. Photo by Seb Daly/Sportsfile

The Commentary Box | The Gerry Malone Column

I have seen many FAI Cup games involving Dundalk in the past few decades. Last Friday's Cup performance against Drogheda United would rank among the worst I have witnessed. I remember when non-League Cobh Ramblers dumped Dundalk out of the Cup in 1983.

I remember when another non-league side Portmarnock beat Dundalk in the Cup on 1st April 2001. I remember another non-League side Ashtown Villa beat Dundalk in the Cup on 20 March 1991 in their first home defeat to a non-League side at Oriel Park.

Dundalk amazingly went on to win the league that year. The worst performance I ever saw from a Dundalk team in the Cup was on 16th January 1975. Dundalk were being managed by a man named Jim McLaughlin who had taken over the job the previous November.

The Tolka Park side was a senior team in the League of Ireland at that time. But they had a totally amateur set-up. That side went on to win the cup for the one and only time in their history. Dundalk were flying in Willie Penman every Sunday for an exorbitant cost.

Here were amateurs who ripped the much more fancied Dundalk apart. That Home Farm side had many players who went on to be icons in the League of Ireland. Noel King, 16-year-old Martin Murray and Dermot Keely.

These three all went on to have highly successful careers. Martin Murray and Dermot Keely won League medals with Dundalk. Keely won the league with Dundalk as a manager also while Martin Murray won the Cup as manager also with Dundalk in 2002.

That Home Farm game always stuck in my mind as a game Dundalk should have won. But they did not as the Farm were hungry to win, Dundalk were not. Last Friday night had many similarities with that Home Farm game so long ago.

Dundalk put in a nightmare performance, having beaten their neighbours just a week earlier by four goals to two. Quite simply Dundalk were simply shocking all over the park.

I asked Dundalk boss Jon Daly after the game what had happened. He accepted it was a poor performance. "The 2 goals we conceded were extremely poor from our point of view. We need to try and get over this as quickly as possible.

We have an opportunity to bounce back against Bohemians next week. If we turn up and play like that next week we may possibly be coming away with nothing." Jon was spot on.

Dundalk will come away with nothing from Dalymount unless they can start to produce reasonable performances away from home. They are still not doing that.

The Dundalk manager made two changes from the team that beat Drogheda so comprehensively the previous week at Oriel. Jamie Gullan returned to his striker's role in place of Eoin Kenny.

Scott McGill came into the centre of midfield in place of the injured Paul Doyle. McGill had a poor game and was totally ineffective. Jamie Gullan was played as the sole striker.

This was a mistake by Jon Daly. Gullan needs someone to play-off alongside him. In other words, the Dundalk boss should have gone with two strikers.

The Dundalk boss explained after the game that Jad Hakiki had been given a forward role to link up with Gullan. But that just never materialised. So bad were Dundalk in this game that their first real attempt on goal did not come until the 79th minute.

The performance was that bad. Too many players were just not prepared to stand up and fight for a win. Some players just seem to stand away from the challenge.

Dundalk lacked any intensity. Drogheda in comparison created Weaver's Park into a stadium of intensity. They also had new signing James Bolger playing at centre half.

He scored the Drogs first goal. He was outstanding. He is a great find. His signing from Swedish side Boden BK only came through on Wednesday. He was very quick to settle into the Drogs defence.

Douglas James Taylor also caused many problems for the Dundalk defence as he did last week. He is a fine striker. Drogheda are a big strong physical team.

Their new signings including the two mentioned could easily help lift Drogheda off the bottom of the league table and condemn Dundalk to the bottom again were they to take advantage of Weavers Park.

It's a cramped small pitch where the crowd can get in on the opposition, creating a hostile atmosphere. My fear is that Drogheda will start to pick up a lot more points at home now with their strengthened team. If Dundalk's away form continues as it is they will be in real trouble.

Mayowa stood out for Dundalk at the centre of the defence while new signing Aodh Dervan was excellent when he came on as a sub late in the game. But Dundalk still have a problem with their keepers.

New signing Felix Goddard had a nightmare of a game. He was at fault for Drogheda's first goal. He was also not good for the second goal scored by Warren Davis on 74 minutes.

Jon Daly will hardly take my suggestion on board. I would put Academy keeper Sean Molloy back in goals. He played twice in goals a few weeks ago and did not concede a goal.

Should this not work out, then I would take the move many would see as extreme and put goalkeeping coach Peter Cherrie back between the posts. He is signed as a player apart from being a coach.

Four years ago Peter was brought back by then manager Vinny Perth as Dundalk were in freefall dropping down the table. After what seemed an age, Peter was back in goals. Dundalk's performances stabilised and they avoided the drop into the relegation zone.

Jon Daly must give this idea serious thought. A goalkeeper is the most important player in a team. The keepers Dundalk have brought in this season Ross Munro and George Shelvey failed to inspire. The Dundalk manager brought in neither. Now Felix Goddard is doing the same.

It's not just Friday night's game he looked very shaky at times. He was also equally uninspiring for some of the attempts he had to deal with in the league game against Drogheda the previous week at Oriel, even though Dundalk won 4-2.

The lead goal for Drogheda was a disaster on 16 minutes. Luke Heeney sent a cross in from deep. James Bolger cushioned a side foot shot that was really going nowhere as Goddard had the ball in his sight.

What seemed the simplest of tasks to deal with by Dundalk, turned into a horror show. The keeper fumbled the ball and carried the ball into his own net.

He totally misjudged Bolger's effort. Dundalk were a goal down when they should not have been. But you could see it coming a mile away. The cross came from John Mountney's side.

He did not have his usual good game at right full. But how Goddard did not deal with the ball properly and instead allowed himself to carry the ball over the line and into the net I will never know.

It looked like instead of tipping the easy shot over the crossbar he tried to catch it with one hand. It was one of the most bizarre goals I have ever seen. Bolger's shot looped high into the air. The result was that Goddard ended up in the net with the ball in his hand.

At first, I waited for the referee to disallow it. I had no reason to think why except for the way Goddard conceded it. I soon realised it was a perfectly legal goal. But it was the goal that knocked Dundalk out of the Cup.

Dundalk were denied a penalty in the first minute of the game which seemed a perfect one when Robbie Benson was taken down in the box. Referee Damian McGrath did not have a good game overall for either side Jamie Gullan was clearly held down on the edge of the box and appealed for a free on 73 minutes.

The referee waved play on. Luke Dennison pumped a free into the Dundalk box. It bounced in the Dundalk penalty area when it should have been cleared by the keeper or other defenders.

The ball came to Warren Davis. He curled the ball into the net. He had only been on as a substitute. It was a disaster. It was the goal that ended Dundalk's interest in the Cup for 2024.

Dundalk got a goal back in the second minute of injury time when Goddard kicked the ball out very strongly. For once it caught the Drogheda defence out. Dundalk centre-half Bobby Faulkner headed the ball over the outrushing Drogheda keeper Luke Dennison and into the back of the net.

It was too little too late. Dundalk were knocked out of the first round of the FAI Cup for the first time since 2010. The result also means that Dundalk have still never recorded a win over Drogheda in the FAI Cup in Drogheda.

The home side changed their formation from the previous week's league game. They played three at the back with five in midfield and two up front. Dundalk went with a 4-5-1 formation.

Felix Goddard was in goal. The two fullbacks were John Mountney and Sean Keogh. Two centre halves Mayowa and Bobby Faulkner. Two wingers Daryl Horgan and Ryan O'Kane.

Hakiki played behind striker Gullan. Subs 67 mins Aodh Dervin for Keogh. Norman Garbett for Hakiki. 76 Eoin Kenny on for Ryan O'Kane. 83. Dan Pike for Gullan. Cameron Elliott for Benson.

Dundalk's first real attempt on goals came on 79 minutes. Scott McGill fired a free into the Drogheda box that was cleared without a problem by Drogheda defenders.

Jon Daly said that the defeat was poor. "We just have to get over it as quickly as possible. We have an opportunity to bounce back against Bohemias next week if we can get the win.

"But if we turn up and play like the way we played tonight we certainly will not be coming away from Dalymount with anything. We were really poor in possession against Drogheda.

"That must improve vastly. Tonight we looked like a team that had not been together for a long time. Tonight was the first time since I became manager of Dundalk that I felt that. We must improve massively.

"I do not think either team were great tonight if I am being brutally honest. They took their opportunities from the mistakes we have made. The first goal was an error on our part.

"Obviously, Felix has made a mistake. Sadly when you are a keeper and make mistakes it generally leads to a goal. The second goal was a terrible one to give away.

"If you do not win the ball first in those situations. Warren Davis is excellent at capitalising in such situations. He scores plenty of goals by just putting people under pressure.

"He managed to just scoop it into the net. Outside of that, they did not do a whole lot more. but we did not either. The goalkeeper will hold his hands up with no problem and accept he has made a mistake.

"That's part of being a human being. But I do not think he could have done a lot for the second goal. It started with a mistake by the defender. We gave Warren Davis an excellent opportunity to score and he did.

"I think Felix made a few good saves. He is obviously still getting used to the players that are in front of him. We need the team to work on that and try to continue to get better.

"But tonight was disappointing. From my point of view, it was probably the worst we have been since I came here. This was an opportunity for us to progress in the Cup. But now we can put all of our focus on the league.

"I really would have loved to have gone through to the next round of the cup. I know what the Cup is like, having won it with Pat's last year. I know what it is about. I know the occasion. There are players in the dressing room who know what it's about. So they know what it means to win it.

"I am so disappointed for the players and the fans that we have gone out on a whimper. On Andy Boyle, the manager told me that he is just back doing a little bit of light training with the physio. Hopefully, he is not too far away."

Drogheda manager Kevin Doherty was a happy man after the game. "We did not make as many mistakes tonight as we did in Oriel. I thought our new debutants did so well.

"I was really delighted with them. I brought Luke Dennison in as keeper as I think it's good to have healthy competition. It was good to get the win. But we knew we had to work very hard for it right to the end.

"A few weeks ago we led 2-1 against Galway with a few minutes to go as we were against Dundalk tonight. In the Galway game, we conceded two late goals here and ended up with nothing.

"I am really hoping that this win will give us the momentum we need to start getting the points to get out of the position we are in now in the league.

"We were missing Darragh Markey, Gary Deegan and a couple of more players we hope to have back in soon. When told that Dundalk have never won an FAI Cup game in Drogheda, Kevin Doherty says that hopefully, that will continue for a very long time.

"I think we will be battling Dundalk in the relegation zone for the rest of the season. The last time we beat Dundalk here in the league we went six points clear of them.

"Now We are five points behind them. Results will really change things. Hopefully, we can add one or two more players to the squad before the window closes. With the players coming back from injury as well we really can strengthen the squad."

Last Friday week's league game against Drogheda failed to show up the loss of Archie Davies, Zak Bradshaw, Andy Boyle and Zak Johnson in defence. Last Friday's Cup game showed this loss considerably.

You just can not lose 4 top-class defenders like these and not leak goals. Andy Boyle is still some time away from returning. Mayowa has done very well at the heart of the defence.

But without the others mentioned Dundalk looked very unsteady at the back. Jon Daly will give his new keeper time to settle into the team. Felix Goddard has to take some responsibility for the loss.

But in truth, the fault lies with the entire team. The defence is very vulnerable now just as it was at the start of the season. On Friday Dundalk can drag Bohemians into the relegation quagmire were they to win at Dalymount.

I am afraid I just can not see that happening. Bohemians have signed well in the window. Last Friday they dumped Shamrock Rovers out of the cup by virtue of a late penalty. It was a fully deserved win.

It was only Stephen O'Donnell's second competitive win this season combining his tenure as manager of Dundalk and taking over as assistant manager at Bohemians. The two wins have come at Bohemians.

There was a large amount of security at Friday's Cup game. This followed the violent scenes between the two sets of supporters at Oriel the previous Friday in the League game. There were no incidents and the game passed off peacefully.

There have been reports that the trouble in Oriel emanated from links between some of the Drogheda supporters involved in the trouble and supporters of a Belgian team.

Other reports say the supporters were German. Drogheda imposed no lifetime bans on any of their supporters. But to be fair they imposed bans on 15 supporters of various lengths. It's not known if Dundalk imposed any bans on their supporters who were involved in the violence.

The Gardai and the FAI allowed the game to go ahead despite fears that it would be played behind closed doors. It was a good ruling. Both clubs are believed to have been fined 700 euros each as a result of the violence.

Again if true this was fair. Dundalk put in a huge amount of work last week along with Drogheda to prepare for the cup game and ensure it would all go along without incident.

Have a great week. Look after each other. And please be careful out there.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice