Dundalk must act quickly to replace O’Donnell if they're to reach relegation play-off


The Commentary Box | The Gerry Malone Column
Dundalk have only scored three goals all season in the league and that has been away from home. They have drawn 4 games, 3 at home and one away. They have lost 5 games. They have also conceded a shocking 15 goals in 9 games.
Dundalk are getting many applications by the day for the vacant managerial job. They must move on this sooner rather than later. But they must take their time too. But things might change so quickly that by the time you read this they have a new man in charge at Oriel.
One thing is for sure, it will not be Brian Gartland who will be the next manager. I asked him after the game if he was interested in it and he emphatically said no. Until I heard him saying that I wondered if he did have an interest.
People can change their minds when they get a taste of being a boss. But Gartland was adamant the Dundalk job was not for him or the job of a football manager elsewhere. Personally, I feel there is only one man who can sort out Dundalk's problems. That is Stephen Kenny. He lives locally and knows every nook and cranny at Oriel. He may cost 300,000 to 500,000 euro. But he would be worth every penny.
Things are so bad at Oriel at the moment that he might not be able to keep Dundalk in the Premier Division this season. But he would bring them back up the following season. Dundalk would be league champions within two years and who knows what would happen with a good European run. I said this last week. There is no need to look elsewhere. Stephen lives four miles from Oriel. He is the only solution. But who knows, the former Dundalk supremo may not want an Oriel return.
Kenny has been linked for a move to Scottish Premier Division side Aberdeen. There is another job he may be able to go for soon. That is the Derry City job. They have underperformed this season and last Friday could only manage a two all draw against second from bottom Drogheda United away from home. Ruaidhri Higgins could well be on the way out of the Brandywell, if the poor results continue for Derry.
Stephen Kenny is a former manager of Derry City and no doubt he would be welcomed with open arms up there too. Derry could meet whatever fee Kenny looked for. They are the second richest club in the country. The Derry owner has plunged so much of his own money into the club already.
I have no doubt he would move for Kenny were they continue to underperform. Two weeks ago, some supporters called for Higgins to go. Last week he was a hero again when they beat Dundalk 4-1. The draw with Drogheda has put the Derry supremo under pressure once more.
Dundalk have had applications from managers who have won everything to nothing. One manager who is interested in the job has some managerial experience on the international front with a country a good distance from here. Another is from one who has tasted domestic success here. Dundalk have had applications from ex-League of Ireland players and former Irish League players.
John Gill has been named on public forums as a man who could turn things around. They have linked him to the Dundalk job as well. Vinny Perth surprisingly has not been named among the contenders as being linked to the job. But it appears unlikely now that he has applied. He would be an excellent candidate for the job. Another man who has not applied but who could possibly get Dundalk out of trouble is ex-Linfield and Ballymena boss David Jeffrey. He was appointed as Linfield manager on 4th January 1987 after ex-Dundalk boss Trevor Anderson resigned.
In 2005-06, Jeffrey guided Linfield to a clean sweep of domestic trophies. On 8th January Jeffrey signed a new 4-year contract with Linfield, the longest one in clubs' history. He won the manager of the month award 32 times by 2014. He was the most successful manager for Linfield along with Roy Coyle. He won 32 trophies in his 17-year reign as manager. David left Linfield at the end of the 2014 season.
In total David won 9 league titles with Linfield and seven Irish Cups. He won 6 League Cups with Linfield. He also won the Setanta Cup with the Windsor Park club. David departed Linfield in 2014. He won the League Cup with Ballymena in 2017 and a fourth-place finish in the league. He won a number of other honours with the club.
They had depleted resources. His main achievement was keeping Ballymena in the Premier Division. He is only out of football for a season. I think he would be a good man for the remainder of the season. He has great experience at battling relegation and would be a good asset for Dundalk for just the one year. He is available. I am sure it might be worth Dundalk giving him a call.
Brian Gartland named four changes from the Dundalk side that played in Derry. Out went Ross Munro in goals for George Shelvey. Shelvey let four goals in against Sligo weeks ago in Oriel. He did okay on Friday night but was shaky at times. Mayowa was left out along with Koen Oostenbrink and Ryan O'Kane.
Andy Boyle returned after being out with a long-term injury. Jamie Gullan also returned. Archie Davies returned from suspension. Davies played as a winger. The move did not work. He is very good at getting down the flanks. But he needs someone in front of him. #
Zak Johnson was forced off through injury early on. Mayowa was top class replacing him. Andy Boyle was also good in the central defender's role. He tightened up the defence considerably. John Mountney and Zak Bradshaw did well as full backs. Jamie Gullan failed to impress.
He appears to be carrying an injury. He was replaced by Ryan O'Kane in the final twenty minutes. I have no idea why Ryan was dropped from the Derry game. He is one of the few players who can create goals. He even scored in Derry last week. Brian Gartland dropping him would not have done the Dundalk youngster's confidence much good.
George Shelvey made a bad mistake early on as he tried to clear it. The ball went straight to Mason Melia. The 16-year-old just failed to turn the ball into the net. Forrester came close again for Pat’s on 28 minutes. His shot was saved well by Shelvey. Pat’s should have been in front on 37 minutes.
A great cross from Brandon Kavanagh found Conor Keeley 10 yards out from goal. He shot wide with an empty goal beckoning. Dundalk did start the second half in a flurry. Daryl Horgan and Jamie Gullan went close. Mayowa also headed narrowly wide. Robbie Benson was immense in midfield.
He shot over from 20 yards coming very close. Mason Melia went close for Pat's again while Ardee man Kian Leavy was taken down in the box. It should have been a penalty for the Pat's. It was not given and resulted in the Inchicore side's manager being booked for dissent. Pat's could have won it in injury time when Jake Mulraney’s effort came off the outside of the Dundalk cross bar.
Yes, Dundalk seemed to have more zip in their step. However, it was still the same old story. They cannot score. And they were very lucky not to concede at least twice. The defence was solid. But we have seen this before at Oriel and when they go away, they let in too many goals.
I can see this Dundalk team go through the full 36 games in the league and not win a game. Maybe that sounds silly, but they are just that poor, I cannot see where the goals are going to come from. Dara Keane made his Oriel debut coming on as a sub for Daryl Horgan in the final quarter of the game. Brian Gartland also used Sam Durrant to replace John Mountney late in the game. Cameron Elliott replaced Jamie Gullan while Ryan O'Kane was eventually used to replace Robbie Mahon.
Cameron Elliott once again failed to have any impact up front. He was signed by Brian Gartland at the beginning of last season and has yet only scored a single goal this season. He has only scored one goal since joining Dundalk. This is simply just not good enough. His play on Friday was very poor.
Striker Ciaran McGuckin was injured two weeks ago playing for the north in an under 20 internationals. It's not known how long the young striker will be out for. There has been nothing from the club as to how much it will be. Hopefully, he will be back sooner rather than later. But when there is silence from the club on an injured player, I always fear he could be out longer than was at first thought. We shall see.
I congratulated Brian Gartland on getting a point from the Pat’s and the way his side fought for the result. I asked him if he was happy. “No, I do not see where the congratulations are coming from. We had hoped to win the game. We were happy with a lot of attributes we have seen in the team.
But you cannot reinvent the wheel in a couple of games. There was a head coach and deputy head coach here until Monday who were tactically very good. We are not going to reinvent the wheel. We are here to instill a bit of positivity in the side. It was an emotional flat side to the start of the week. But myself and Liam have liked what we have seen so far.”
The caretaker manager said himself and Liam Burns tried to instill greater intent and positivity from his team. “I was delighted with one of the saves George Shelvey made.” Gartland said the save on the counter Shelvey made kept Dundalk in the game. He said his side did manage to get into some great positions.
He told me that it was just the composure in the final third that got his men. He said that Dundalk played the game in Pat’s half for most of the second period and that his players managed to get in behind the Pat’s defence. He said it was important that the side continues to work on their creativity to get the all-important goal. Gartland was happy that his side had laid down a good foundation for themselves going forward.
Brian told me it was not easy for either himself or Liam to step in as caretaker managers. He says he asked Stephen O'Donnell how he has been in management over the past few years as he was waking up at night at time and having it going over in his mind constantly who will he play on the right or left and then change his mind again.
Brian says it's not easy being a manager. He told me it was a high-pressure job. Brian says it has been really tough for him and for Liam Burns stepping in for Stepen O'Donnell. He says people just think looking from the outside that it's just football. He says there is a lot of work that goes into managing a team that people do not realise.
Asked what was his assessment of his squad Brian Gartland said he felt it was a matter of them needing just more confidence. Brian Gartland wisely thought through his answer before giving it, as it was him who brought in the players who make up the new squad. Gartland said that this was nobody's fault that they need more confidence.
Brian said against Pat's away they gave away one silly goal and that cost them the three points. He claimed the home games against Drogheda and Waterford recently never saw Dundalk bang the door down. But he claimed that if anyone else looked like winning those games, it looked like Dundalk.
He says all it will take is for Dundalk getting the bounce of a ball correctly and they will be back in the mix. He says they have brought in a young squad. All he was looking at from them was reaction. Brian says that all that matters in football from players in a team is how they respond no matter what age they are. He says everybody will make mistakes. It just depends on how they are going to react. He said they encouraged the players to build forward and think forward and not get hung up on looking back at any mistakes that have been made.
Brian says he does not know how long he will be caretaker head coach. There have been a lot of applications since Stephen O'Donnell stood down. But he says it may take time as there is no point in rushing the process. I asked Brian did he see himself staying in the job of manager. He said no as he had made the decision a number of years ago that he would never be a manager.
He said he even referred to the possibility of him ever becoming a manager. He said in his book last year that he would never be a manager. Brian says that he does not think that people realise the pressure managers are under, especially if they are living in Dundalk.
He says that he has to think of the pressure his family would be under if he was manager of Dundalk and living in the town. He says he would be able to take the pressure. But coaching and living in Dundalk would put his family under a lot of pressure. He says it's a twenty-four seven job and people just do not realise that.
As the dust settles on the Stephen O'Donnell departure from Dundalk it is so easy now to see why it just did not work out for Stephen. The ex-manager did so well to get Dundalk into Europe in his first season. Particularly as he had to build a new squad from afresh.
That was for season 2022. Nobody would ever have imagined that Stephen would have to do it again in 2023. In that season he could only start signing players late when all of the League of Ireland players had been signed. Dundalk were forced into a situation where they had to go to the UK and bring in on loan players on occasions.
No manager would have normally put up with that. Then at the end of the season came the dispute with Pat Hoban and his departure to Derry for 2024. Stephen kept his dignity intact when he refused to comment on the situation. I was critical at the time as to why the manager was letting him go.
Stephen has never gone public to give his story of what happened. Pat has and said that the manager had met him three days before the second last game of the season and told him to find another club. Sadly, the club lost Pat in a transfer to Derry City at the end of January 2024.
Stephen told me around August last season that he was hopeful he would have his complete squad signed by mid-December for season 2024. But that was not to be as unknown to him at that time the then owners wanted out. There was a report in one newspaper that the owners had tried to sell the club as far back as the World Cup in 2022.
The manager at that time was just trying to get the 2023 squad signed. The team he did sign was much weaker than the one the year before. As for season 2024 it must have been a bombshell to the then manager when he found out that the owners were off, and a new owner was coming in.
Stephen came to Dundalk I imagine, thinking it had a united fan base, ownership and playing base. He thought he was coming to the same club that he played for under Stephen Kenny. That was clear to me when he was being asked about the departure of Pat Hoban.
Stephen said he wanted to see supporters, owners, players and management be united together in the battle with other clubs. He said that he wanted a siege mentality such that everybody else was against the club apart from those who were behind it. That's what Stephen saw in the Kenny years. But they were long gone when he came as manager in December 2021.
Stephen came to Dundalk having just won the FAI Cup in 2021 with Pat’s. He just never imagined he was walking into such a changed club and atmosphere. Had he known I doubt very much that he would have left Pat’s after just winning the cup. Jump ahead three years later he would never have imagined that he would have had to build a new team for the third year in a row as well as losing his best players. No manager could have dealt with that. How must he have felt also when he saw the owners that brought him back to Oriel. He never criticised the previous owners once. And when he was leaving last Monday he did say the club was under good hands in the ownership of Brian Ainscough.
One of the saddest things that came out of this mess was that Stephen never fulfilled his hopes of having his 2024 squad fully signed up by the previous mid-December. To Stephen O'Donnell I wish to say thank you for the last three years. He was a man who never held grudges.
He could have been against me with all the tough questions I had to ask him when others asked nothing. Stephen loved the town of Dundalk, its people, the club, and its supporters. He was possibly the most straight talking and co-operative manager I have ever worked with at Dundalk.
I wish him the very best for the future and his assistant Padge Cregg. Stephen is a talented young coach. He will be back with another club sooner rather than later. As John Murphy said in an interview with me. “Even Pep Guardiola could do a lot with the current squad that were recruited for this season”.
The UEFA documentary on Dundalk's late one-armed striker has been nominated for a sports EMMY. This is the equivalent of the American BAFTAS. The awards ceremony takes place this coming 21st May. Jimmy scored many goals for Dundalk. On 11th October 1974 Jimmy was murdered by the UVF on his way to work for a Belfast bookies.
Jimmy was gunned down by loyalist thugs who murdered a completely defenseless man and left him to die on a cold Belfast street. Of course, republican terrorists also murdered many innocent protestants as well. The 50th anniversary of Jimmy's murder takes place next October. He was a teammate of the great John Murphy who is still thankfully with us along with Francie Callan and Tootsie McKeown. The documentary can still be seen on the UEFA website.
Dundalk played Bohemians at Dalymount Park in Dublin last night. I really hope they did well. May I wish all of you a safe week. Have a good one as well and please everybody look after each other.