Dundalk is simply not good enough to grapple with the top teams


The Commentary Box | The Gerry Malone Column
The automatic relegation Grim Reaper was hovering over Oriel Park on Friday night after Galway United's 2-0 win over Dundalk. The home side turned in another dismal display which now sees them just two points clear of bottom side Drogheda United who have shown a good revival of late.
Dundalk were terrible, particularly in a second half which saw Galway totally dominate. They got two goals in that period when it could have been more. They were denied a stone wall penalty late in the game also.
A third goal would have been a deserved one for the Westerners as they tore holes in a very poor Dundalk defence. Once again goalkeeper Felix Goddard turned in a poor performance.
He was responsible for the first goal. He also failed to take any real command of his penalty area throughout the game. But the blame for the defeat does not lie with Goddard. Dan Pike once again was poor at left full. To be fair to the youngster he is a right-footed player.
Mayowa was solid enough in defence. But he too must take responsibility for the first goal. Andy Boyle returned for his first game in six weeks. He only began to train again after his long period of absence last Monday, I was surprised to see him back so soon.
Jamie Gullan once again disappointed up front. He showed little or no flair. John Mountney had a quiet game at right full. Aodh Dervin failed to have any real impact in central midfield. Robbie Benson ran his socks off as usual.
But with most of the side playing below-par football it was always going to be difficult for him to shine. Ryan O'Kane was about Dundalk's best player on the night. He gave Galway much difficulty down the left with his darting runs down the flanks.
This was particularly so in the first half. Daryl Horgan also caused problems down the right. But he was snuffed out by a well-organised Galway defence when he did threaten. Jad Hakiki once again failed to put in the performance that he is capable of.
He was playing behind Jamie Gullan. It was hard for him to link up with a player who just showed none of the acumen and skill needed for a striker. It brought home to me again the huge mistake Dundalk made in letting Pat Hoban go last January when he had another season left.
The loss of Archie Davies at right full was also clearly there to be seen. How could Dundalk have let him go in the window when he was contracted to the club for the rest of the season? Yes, the player may have wanted to go. But Dundalk needed him.
His loss as well as Hoban's has left Dundalk wide open now for the drop. The recruitment policy of past people in the club has also played its part in Dundalk now staring relegation in the face.
The loss of centre-half Zak Bradshaw and Zak Johnson has been a huge hammer blow to the defence. They were on loan players who had to return to clubs in the UK at the end of June. Along with Archie Davies and Andy Boyle, they were the spine of the team. No team could recover from the loss of Bradshaw, Johnson and Davies and hope to put up a solid battle to try and stay up.
Dundalk are now into their fourth keeper. Felix Goddard was brought to Oriel in the window. His signing is just not working out. Again I ask why Nathan Shepherd was not signed at the start of the season by Brian Gartland and Stephen O'Donnell.
He should have been number one on their shopping basket. Two years ago, Nathan single-handedly with his terrific saves and domination of his area helped Dundalk qualify for Europe.
There were many games that season Dundalk would have lost but for Nathan. Those games were turned into wins because Dundalk had a solid keeper at the back.
Dundalk's signings in the window also look to be poor enough. Drogheda have signed well and are hot on the trail of neighbours Dundalk in the relegation battle. Players such as Bobby Faulkner, Scott McGill, Daniel Pike and Felix Goddard are just not good enough.
The jury is out on new signing Josh O'Connor who only came on late in the game on Friday. It was impossible to assess his abilities in such a short time. Overall Dundalk were terrible at the back, shoddy at midfield and very poor up front.
Last Friday to the day 8 years ago Dundalk were THE team in Ireland when they knocked Belarusian Champions Bate Borisov out of the preliminary stages of the Champions League on a score line by three goals to nil.
Last Friday Dundalk were left with the real threat of being relegated for the third time in just over 20 years. How have Dundalk come to be the top team in Ireland to a team being threatened by the very dark chambers of the First Division?
The fault lies with so many people down through the past number of years. I will come back to that as the season comes to an end. One factor has been the many changes of owners to the many managers who have been at the club since Stephen Kenny left in 2018.
It's hard to watch Kenny win in Europe while Dundalk's future looks so grim. When I walked into Oriel last Friday it was as if I could feel the ghosts of the past hovering around the old stadium.
They were the good ghosts who made me remember all the successes from Jim McLaughlin to Turlough O'Oconnor to Stephen Kenny and Vinny Perth.
But then reality struck me at how bad things were. The shoddiness and dilapidation of the stadium soon brought me back to the fact that Dundalk faced relegation. And the current form of the team does little to dispel all of this.
A face from the past Pop Flanagan was introduced to the crowd before the start of the game. Pop was a butcher from Clones in Monaghan. He joined Dundalk from Pats along with Dermot Keely in the summer of 1978.
Dundalk won their first Double in 1978-79. Pop was a midfielder. He went on to win a cup in 1981 and the league in 1982. He played for Dundalk in the 1982-83 season. Dundalk failed to qualify for Europe when Pop missed a penalty in the final game of the season against Sligo.
That result had profound implications. Jim McLaughlin moved to Shamrock Rovers while the double team broke up. Pop left also and has spent many years in America coaching.
Galway never let Dundalk out of their own half for the first 15 minutes of the first half. Galway could have been in front in under a minute when a mistake by Daniel Pike put the home defence under pressure. Pike eventually got back to clear the ball to safety.
Conor McCormack then saw his 20-yard shot taking a deflection. The ball fell to Jimmy Keohane who shot wide from close range. Galway came close just two minutes later when Vincent Borden's lob from 30 yards was narrowly over.
The Galway siege of Dundalk was finally lifted 14 minutes into the half when Ryan O'Kane had a good run down the left. For the first time, Galway were vulnerable. O'Kane shot narrowly wide. Ryan went close again nine minutes later with a superb effort.
O'Kane then set up Robbie Banson who went close with a 20-yard stinger. Galway's hero on the night Stephen Walsh had a great chance to open the scoring when he shot wide from seven yards. It would have been easier to score.
Dundalk should have been in front on the half-hour when Jamie Gullan shot over from 13 yards. It was a terrible miss. Ryan O'Kane then had the ball in the net when Ryan O'Kane's cross found Gullan in the box.
He shot home but was rightfully denied the goal for offside. A minute from the break Gullan missed another chance, shooting wide from close range.
Galway led on 53 minutes when Stephen Walsh headed home at the far post. Mayowa had failed to clear when he should have. Goddard also made a mistake for the goal. Dundalk survived what should have been a second goal soon after when.
Stephen Walsh got a cross into the box. Jimmy Keohane struck his effort off the crossbar six yards out. Dundalk keeper Goddard also clearly fouled Keohane. It should have been a penalty. The referee waved away few if any appeals.
Hakiki was replaced by Eoin Kenny on 63 minutes. Dundalk rarely if ever threatened. Keohane missed another great chance when he was clear on goal. All he had to do was round Goddard.
Instead, he fluffed his lines and shot straight at the Dundalk keeper. Dundalk made a triple substitution with 14 minutes remaining. Mahon replaced O'Kane. Josh O'Connor replaced Gullan. McGill replaced Benson.
Galway got a deserved second goal three minutes from time. Karl O'Sullivan's cross was headed home at the far post by Stephen Walshe. The Dundalk defence was all at sea.
Pike was replaced by Sean Keogh a minute later. The referee played five minutes of injury time. He blew directly at the end of this time to put Dundalk out of their misery.
The result was not a surprise to me at all. This Dundalk team is simply not good enough to grapple with the top teams. The loss of the three key defenders in the window has been a crushing blow.
The new goalkeeper is also making too many mistakes and is failing to command his penalty area. As far as the goalkeeping problem is concerned, the manager must move now.
He can either bring academy keeper Sean Molloy in or turn to his goalkeeping coach Peter Cherrie. Molloy did very well when he minded the net for two games a few weeks ago. He did not concede a goal. But one has to remember he had a well-organised defence in front of him.
Sean is a fine keeper. I would not be against the move of at least trying him. However, Jon Daly has Cherrie signed as a player apart from being the goalkeeping coach.
Daly said at the time he brought Cherrie in that he signed him to be only used in times of an emergency. Well, this is an emergency as Dundalk are disimproving week by week while Drogheda are improving.
I asked the manager if he would think now of replacing Felix Goddard with Peter Cherrie. I said I do not like singling players but the question had to be asked. "Well, you do not like to single players out but you just have.
"Felix did have a couple of moments in the game when he happened to miskick the ball. I have just been asked did I think Felix could have done better for the first goal. I think a lot of players could have done better. We gave a lot of space for the first goal.
"Then came the cross which gave Stephen Walsh a free header, That type of opportunity is very difficult for any keeper to deal with. Do I think he could have had a better performance. I think a lot of players could have had a better performance.
"In terms of putting Peter Cherrie in, I think that Peter is obviously the goalkeeping coach. That is what he is here for. Peter will go into goals if we have an emergency in terms of keepers. That's the situation we are in."
I asked the manager if he did not think there was an emergency now. "We have 30 points to play for. I think that as a group and as a club we have to have a bit more of a positive outlook on things.
"There is too much negativity about the place. It's really important that we have a positive outlook. We are obviously extremely disappointed with the result. But I feel we can beat teams in the league on our day if we turn up and play.
"If we show the levels of how we played in the second part of the first half tonight, we will get results against teams. That is where I am at." I said to the manager that the defence was very vulnerable in the second half.
And I stressed that he was now without three key defenders lost in the window or whose loan terms were up. He said that the fact the players were now gone was not seen when Dundalk beat Drogheda in the league weeks before.
"It's very easy to look at players who have gone when you have a negative result to put the blame on the players who have gone." I said I was not blaming any of the players who have gone.
"The manager said he still had players who were gelling and who are working hard to where they want to be. This process takes time. You have to remember when those lads left we were bottom of the league. We are two points clear of the bottom of the league.
"So maybe looking at that point of view that change was needed and now we have to work on that to get us out of the place we are in now." I said to the manager that I thought he had a goalkeeping crisis on his hands.
"He said in reply that he appreciated my opinion. He said that he was more than happy to listen to my opinion. He said he did not necessarily have to agree with me. Jon said that he would move on from there.
I found the manager to be polite and to be prepared to listen. Many other managers in the past would have roared at me. I am used to that when dealing with Dundalk bosses down through the decades. Jon is a decent man and is a good manager.
He has been given an impossible task at Oriel. I just can not see how Dundalk are going to get out of trouble. The new signings are just not good enough as are some of the existing players. Putting Cherrie in goals is not the solution that will cure all ills.
But maybe it would stabilise the defence. Next Friday night Dundalk travel to the northwest to take on title chasers Derry City. I can not see Dundalk getting anything from this game. In fact, I fear for them given how badly the defence and midfield are playing.
I suggested to skipper Andy Boyle that his team were now in serious relegation difficulty. He said that the table never lies. "We are where we are as we have just not been good enough over the season. We are trying as hard as we can to rectify the situation.
"I have not seen the game back yet and its aftermath is still pretty raw. We need to watch it back to see what happened and learn from it." Andy is one of the players left on the side that hails from the Kenny era.
He is a terrific defender and will help steady things at the back again. Friday night was his first game back in six weeks. I am confident that he will form a good partnership with Mayowa between now and the end of the season.
It's not all negative news around Oriel. News has emerged that the club has received a grant of 250,000 euros which will cover the laying of a brand new state-of-the-art astro turf pitch at Oriel.
The news emerged just a week after the club failed to successfully apply for a Government infrastructural sports capital grant scheme worth thousands if not more. But the news that the club is to get a grant that will see the old pitch being replaced by a new state-of-the-art modern one is fantastic.
The old pitch was installed in January/February 2017. It has come in for much criticism. Many are of the opinion that it has been responsible for Dundalk's high injury list over the season.
Credit must go to club owner Brian Aainscough and CEO Peter Halpin and his officials. To say the new pitch will be a great asset is an understatement. To have the expense covered fully by a grant is great work by the club.
Dundalk have had some difficulty using their existing grass training pitch beside Oriel over the past few weeks. It will be sorted. It has nothing to do with the pitch owners, the local Grammar School. The school and Dundalk have worked closely together for decades.
When the existing pitch is back in a condition that it can be used, I have no doubt that it will be. Meanwhile, Dundalk have been in contact with local junior club Quay Celtic for the use of their facilities to train on.
Clubs do have to look after their own facilities very carefully as they are regularly used. I hope Dundalk do get to use Quay's facilities. They need to train on a grass pitch, the week they are playing away from home to a side that has one.
The death occurred of two people last week who had great connections with the club. There was great shock at the news of the death of former club director Paddy Williams. Paddy was a director at the club from the early 1980s up to 1994. Paddy was a very hard club worker.
He contributed so much. I knew him well. He was the type of man who was never afraid to speak his mind. He was a decent honest down to earth man. Paddy loved the club. He was a great friend of my late da Jim Malone who was also on the board at the time.
Paddy also did an awful lot of work for young people behind the scenes. He was a hard-working member of the Rotary Club in Dundalk. He worked on the Rotary Club's youth leadership programme. This involved working with young people in all of the local secondary schools.
It was a competition to find a leading winner for the region. I remember when my old school Colaiste Ris won it. My student met up with key members of the Rotary who helped prepare the student for the grand final.
The student won the entire competition. Paddy played his own part in this and he drove the student to the Grand final in Belfast along with other members of the local Rotary.
My student won a prize of representing the region and the country in the European Parliament. The student worked with students from all over the EU and debated key issues in the EU Parliament as if they were MEP's.
The death also occurred of Peter Quinn, former owner of the Imperial Hotel in Dundalk. Peter's former employees speak so well of him. One told me how he left school at 15. He got a job in the Imperial as an operative.
Peter was so happy with the young man that he offered him an apprenticeship as a chef in the hotel. It involved going to Galway to train. The young man was not allowed to go to Galway by his mother.
He went on to train as a butcher instead and was a neighbour of Peter's on the Point Road for years. Peter's brother Oliver was Chairman of Dundalk in the Jim McLaughlin era from 1974 to 1993. Peter was an investor in the club as well when money was needed.
He was a good card player. My dad was in a poker school along with the late Doctors Frank and Jim Reilly. They all said my dad was a card shark. Peter and Frank O'Reilly used to joke with me that they paid for my college fees because my dad won so much from them.
The last time I saw Peter was at the end of September 1996. I had to call for my da to take him home from the night's poker. Peter was in great form that night and gave me a good slagging.
Strangely it was my da's last night at the poker school. He developed pneumonia and died two weeks later. Peter Quinn was a great help to Dundalk FC. Have a safe week. Please look after each other and of course, remember to be careful out there.