Dundalk game postponed due to a disgraceful decision by the FAI

St Patrick's Athletic manager Stephen Kenny, left, shakes hands with Dundalk manager Jon Daly. Photo by Ramsey Cardy/Sportsfileplaceholder image
St Patrick's Athletic manager Stephen Kenny, left, shakes hands with Dundalk manager Jon Daly. Photo by Ramsey Cardy/Sportsfile

The Commentary Box | The Gerry Malone Column

Dundalk are rooted to the bottom of the league table thanks to a disgraceful decision by the FAI to postpone their rescheduled game against Stephen Kenny's Pats last Sunday. Drogheda took advantage by hammering Sligo Rovers by seven goals to nil.

Dundalk are in deep trouble. They needed the Pats game to be played, in the hope that they could stay off the bottom of the table. But at 4.45 pm, on Friday an email was sent to Oriel Park to say that the Dundalk v Pats game had been called off.

The FAI said that such action was being taken as a result of what it called the unique opportunity that now exists for two League of Ireland clubs to participate in the group stages of the Europa Conference League.

Shamrock Rovers are the other team who qualify automatically as a result of winning their first qualifying round of the Champions League. The interesting factor in all of this is that it's believed the decision was not made by the man who had the power to change the decision.

FAI League Director Mark Scanlon had rejected Pats pleas for the Dundalk game to be postponed. It's believed that the decision was finally made higher up the chain of authority in the FAI.

Stephen Kenny had been making the point all the time that the League were ranked 33rd by UEFA in their order of success. A Pat's win would push the League to within a top thirty place at the end of the year.

This is the FAI's aim as well. But it's interesting that the man who had the authority to cancel the Pats game with Dundalk persistently refused to cancel last Sunday's game.

Once again the FAI higher echelons made the change less than 48 hours before kick-off at Oriel. The game has been re-fixed for Thursday 5th September at 7.45.

Pats have done very well to remain in the competition. They played top Turkish side Basaksehir last Thursday and held them to a scoreless draw, at the Tallaght Stadium.

All last week Stephen Kenny called for the Dundalk game to be postponed, as Pats would have three games in six days. This would be the two Europa League games home and away and a visit to Oriel in between on the Sunday.

But the FAI and Dundalk turned down Pats requests to have their game called off. None of the Irish sides in Europe were given the luxury of having games postponed.

The FAI seemed to be acting consistently for once on such an important issue and were backing Dundalk last week until something happened to cause a change of mind. Stephen Kenny was outspoken in his call to have the Dundalk game called off.

In truth, I would normally be sympathetic to Pat's call. But not now where Dundalk were being denied a game they were told was going ahead right up until the last minute.

Jon Daly spent the week preparing his side for the game that was seen as a relegation six-pointer. For the FAI to pull the rug right from under him less than 48 hours before the game was an absolute disgrace.

The FAI and the League showed gross disrespect for Dundalk and cared little to nothing that this game had huge ramifications for Dundalk's Premier League status.

Instead, they saw the postponement as valid given what they called the unique opportunity to have two League of Ireland clubs in the Group stages of the Europa Conference League. All last week I was being told by sources close to the FAI that the Dundalk v Pats game was in doubt.

I was told there was a good chance that it would be called off. I doubted what I was being told, as I could see no way the FAI would call the game off at such a late stage.

They had also insisted that Pats play Galway and Derry games where they called for them to be postponed. The FAI and the League would not hear of a postponement of those games. They were insistent on the games going ahead and they did.

The decision to cancel the game was made under the infamous Participation agreement between clubs and the FAI and the League. This agreement was brought in in 2005-06.

It was used to deny Dundalk a place in the Premier Division of the League of Ireland after they finished second in the First Division in 2006. At that time any club who finished second played off against the second-from-bottom team in the Premier Division.

But the FAI decided to restructure the league. Places in the premier division were allocated on the basis of results over a specified number of years in the past. Dundalk's record in those years were abysmal as they were obtained when Trevor Anderson was manager.

He turned out to be the worst ever manager record-wise on the field Dundalk ever had. It was his record the FAI used to keep Dundalk in the First Division. John Gill's achievement of finishing second was ignored.

That was a very strange time. Dundalk were down to play Finn Harps in the last game of the season of the First Division. The game was postponed for 24 hours in Ballybofey due to bad weather.

It was practically insisted the game be played the following day, as the Oriel Par side looked set to be involved in a promotion-relegation play-off with Waterford. Dundalk beat Finn Harps and went on to beat Waterford in a relegation promotion play-off arranged by the FAI.

When the FAI met to announce who was going to be in the Premier Division, there was consternation that Dundalk were being excluded and condemned back to the First Division.

The FAI justified their ruling by saying that Dundalk had signed up to the participation deal which effectively allowed the FAI to do as they wanted. The FAI claimed at the time that Dundalk had not got enough wins over the years they were considering for the restructuring.

Why then were Dundalk assigned to a playoff against Waterford over two legs? it made no sense. The participation agreement came back to haunt Dundalk again last week. It was under this deal that the FAI were able to call the Pats game off.

Having been insistent they were not budging on the issue they suddenly wilted to Pats demands. The decision as I feared was that Dundalk were left on the bottom of the table once again.

Former Dundalk boss Vinny Perth told Virgin Media that the decision to cancel the game set a poor precedent Vinny said that nobody more than him wants to see Pats advance to the group stages.

"I am not sure about the decision postponing the Dundalk game on Sunday was a good one. Dundalk received an email today at 4:45. That's the 48-hour requirement to call off a game. This will not sit well with people at Dundalk.

"Drogheda got a point off Shamrock Rovers in the middle of their European campaign a week or so ago. Yes, it was not as hectic for Rovers at that stage.

"But this decision does not sit well. It does not reflect well on the integrity of the league. These clubs know if you are going to be successful in Europe, you are going to be playing every two or three days.

"I think it's the correct decision in many ways. It's not the correct decision from Dundalk's Point of view. Ultimately I hope this does not affect the relegation issue at the end of the season".

Vinny's reaction was the most sensible one I heard from so-called experts on Friday who gave their views on the postponement. The Dublin media were of course delighted.

Philip Quinn of the Irish Daily Mail said on social media that common sense had prevailed. Quinn said that at last the League of Ireland had finally postponed the Dundalk V Pats game. They took their time he said. Owen Cowzer of the Sun said that the Dundalk Pats game was off.

There was an easy case to make for it being called off, he said. You had the shorter turnaround and the FAI's 2025 strategic aim for the League of Ireland and the FAI's strategic aim for the League to be a top 30 one within UEFA.

One member of the public said that the League had refused to call the Shamrock Rovers V Drogheda game off. Drogheda got a point. Next Sunday they will not call the Pats game with Drogheda off at Weaver Park. Pat's he said will only field half a team.

The Irish Sun said on Friday morning that Stephen Kenny wondered whether the FAI was too chicken to do what the Turkish FA do for their European teams.

Kenny was pointing out that the FA in Turkey postponed their opponent's game domestically at the weekend to help them prepare for the game against Pats on Wednesday. Kenny told reporters if a Football association is serious and ambitious then they should do what the Turkish FA do.

Kenny said Dundalk would not have qualified for the group stages of the Europa League in 2016 only for the FAI cancelling a number of Dundalk's domestic games.

I disagree with the Pats manager. That Dundalk team was perhaps the best footballing side Dundalk ever had. They would have got to the group stages with or without the help of the FAI.

But something changed in the corridors of power of the FAI now in Abbottstown. Somebody in power decided to go with Pats desire and cancelled the Dundalk game. The email with the news on the cancellation of the Dundalk v Pats game arrived at Oriel at 4.45.

I heard at 5.15. I have to say I did not expect this with the FAI being so resolute all week. Now they had cancelled the game and ruled in favour of Pats. Taking it in, I eventually accepted that it was a case of the non-Dublin teams being ignored again.

The FAI were also disregarding Dundalk's hopes of trying to avoid relegation. They did not care or take into account the damage their decision was doing to the club. It would mean that Dundalk would have no game for three weeks.

It also meant that Dundalk would go bottom of the table for the weekend with Drogheda winning. Is that in the best interest of Dundalk? Answer no. They would be bottom for at least a week. Jon Daly described the FAI's decision as farcical.

The Dundalk manager says the club were caught totally blindsided by the decision. Daly says he hopes Pats advance to the group stages. But he said he also wanted what was best for Dundalk. He said that Dundalk would have had an edge on Pats

playing them last Sunday after their European game last Thursday. Daly says it was farcical to call off the game 46 hours before the kick-off at Oriel Park. He said the decision makes the league look amateurish.

The Dundalk boss added that the reasons the FAI had outlined for postponing the game were as relevant a week ago as they were on Friday. The Dundalk boss added that a decision could easily have been made at that point to postpone the game.

Jon Daly said that the issue of sporting integrity also has to be called into question. Daly said that clubs in and around Dundalk have already and will have played clubs on the back of European fixtures. He said that there was zero consistency.

On Saturday evening the FAI announced the re-fixture of the game for Thursday, September 5th at 7.45 pm. There are no games scheduled for that week as it is the international break.

I can not understand why it was not rescheduled for the next day on Friday as there are no international games that day involving the Republic. It's no big deal really.

It was just good to see the game being re-fixed and to have a certain date so soon after the FAI threw Dundalk's plans into chaos. But playing the game during the international break means that many of the Dundalk players who had booked to go away on a holiday for a few days can no longer do so.

The players have had their travel plans thrown into chaos. The game could and should have been rescheduled for the week the next round of the cup is on. Pats are also out of the cup. Thus the game could have been played on the cup weekend.

John Murphy of Dundalk FM says it breaks his heart to see Dundalk back at the bottom of the table. That club he says did so much for him. He says he got so much joy out of football.

He says seeing the position where Dundalk are now really affects him. "Letting Pat Hoban go before the start of the season was scandalous. To allow Pat to go to Derry was unbelievable.

"Despite the dispute there was at the time between Stephen O'Donnell and Pat Hoban, the club should have gone out of its way to keep Hoban. He was a goal-scoring machine. He also had a year left of his contract to go".

"The foundation of your club is built around your senior players. By letting Hoban go Dundalk had allowed success to be taken away from them. It certainly did not add to it. Dundalk also lost John Martin and Darragh Leahy at the end of last season.

"John Martin has got some very important goals for Shelbourne this season. John Martin even scored for Shelbourne against Dundalk. The loss of talent from Oriel Park with players going to Derry, Shelbourne, Waterford and other clubs has been so disappointing.

"This has happened over the past few seasons and has contributed to where Dundalk now find themselves. That is the bottom of the table and looking straight at relegation".

"For a club to add to success, you must add strength to your squad. You do not allow it to be weakened. It was no surprise that some players did not return to the squad at the start of the season. Players must look after themselves. They have wives and families too.

"Players have to live outside of Oriel Park or whatever team they are playing for. But if these players have performed well the year before, they should have no problems talking terms with their clubs the following season.

"I had my doubts about how Dundalk would do this season even before a ball was kicked. This was when it became clear that Nathan Shepperd and Pat Hoban were not returning. These two were the key players. A team could have been built around them.

"It was great to have Andy Boyle and Daryl Horgan still in the team. They play for the shirt and the team. But it has been very hard for all the Scottish signings to come in and play for Dundalk. I always ask if they are going to put their foot or their head in where it is sore.

"Then a lot of them disappear in mid-season and at the end of the year, they are gone. Zak Bradshaw and Zak Johnson were fantastic players. But they were not here to be building blocks for the club. They were here as building blocks for themselves.

"The same could be said about Archie Davies. He was a top-class player and was here for a season and a half. Archie was under contract until the end of the season. But he wanted to return to the UK when the right offer came. It would have been wrong of Dundalk to hold on to him".

John said Dundalk were at a huge loss when they lost the two Zak's and Archie. There was nobody to replace them. He went back to the letting go of Pat Hoban. Again he said Hoban should never have been allowed to go.

The former Dundalk's 1962-63 league winner said that Hoban should have been the stepping stone to build around.''Instead, we let him go for a mere 30 to 35,000 euros. I just can't get my head around it.

A club is not going to be successful every year. But we had made ourselves a name to be. But now we are deep in relegation trouble. Why? Because of poor decisions that have us here."

John said that when a person goes out to buy something they know how much it is going to cost. He criticised many of the signings that were made this year.

He says they were poor. "We have been signing players from the wrong end of the market. That will eventually catch up with you. I mean no disrespect to the players at all who have come over and signed. They are trying to make a living for themselves and make a name here.

"But what's the future for Dundalk when they go? We lost Archie and the two Zaks. I am referring to them as they were good players. They were the spine of the team.

"But all of a sudden, they were gone and we saw the collapse of our defence. We are only rearing the on-loan players for someone to take them away.

"Dundalk have used over forty different players in all competitions this season. In fact, I think it is as high as 52 players. You can't build anything around that. And when we did build the house just fell away. Now we are left with rebuilding again. Jon Daly is doing his best.

"I really like him as a manager. Tactically, he is very astute. But you can only do it with the right kind of player. He has had to take players in who may or may not be up to scratch. Jon Daly was handed a poisoned chalice when he came in.

"He lost 9 players in the window and had to bring in the same amount to replace them. There is no foundation there. You are just struggling to get things going again. We have nine games left to go. You could say the season is now over.

"We are praying for a relegation play-off place. Drogheda gets players that seem to want to play for the badge. If I said to you would you take many of them, you probably would only take a few. But they seem to want to play for the shirt.

"Does Dundalk have the players that want to win?Is the club going to be in the same place next season? We need players that want to win and can compete with Drogheda.

"We need a team and say they could get a result in Weaver Park when we need to. If it is neck and neck between the two teams for the last game in Drogheda, I know who I would be backing. It would be Drogheda."

Finally, the documentary on Jimmy Hasty which won an EMMY award earlier this year, will be screened at this year's Louth International Film Festival at the An Tain Arts Centre on Saturday, 28th September.

It will be followed by a question and answer session with the documentary director Richard Milway from Noah Media. Admission to the event is free. Have a great week and please look after each other.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice