Does Dublin stars’ retirement open the door to Leinster hopefuls?


Inside Track | Joe Carroll
It wasn’t such a surprise when James McCarthy announced his retirement from inter-county football a few weeks ago. One of the mainstays in Dublin’s glorious era, the Ballymun Kickham is 34, and given the high-powered game he played – his athleticism one of his greatest assets – to have continued, would have required an effort he maybe felt he couldn’t maintain.
He leaves with a record he shares with a couple of his former colleagues. It wouldn’t have been thought possible a couple of decades ago, someone winning nine All-Irelands. And Leinster and league titles and All-Stars to go with it? Himself, Stephen Cluxton and Mick Fitzsimons have a place in the annals of the GAA that can never be erased.
That McCarthy has since been joined on the sidelines by long-time Dublin colleague, Brian Fenton, isn’t so much a surprise as a shock. At 31, it seemed the Raheny clubman had more years to give to county football. Had he continued, it would have spelt continued bother for, in particular, the Leinster counties who’ve been in the Dubs’ shadow for over a decade.
Fenton’s record: Seven All-Irelands, 10 Leinsters, four National Leagues, six All-Stars, and twice named Footballer of the Year. He was never on a losing Dublin side in the Leinster Championship. Not bad for someone who wasn’t considered good enough for the county minors.
Fenton and McCarthy often formed a midfield partnership, providing the perfect link between defence and attack, and getting among the scorers. Even when Louth were on the receiving end, we still had to give recognition to how the 8 and 9, and the others, carried out their demolition job.
Does their, and perhaps others’, absence – Cluxton, much older than McCarthy, could also hand in his badge – open the door to Leinster hopefuls? Louth, you would have to think, are well enough placed to give it a go.
The Reds were the Dubs’ opponents in the last two provincial finals, going down heavily last year, but giving the champions more than they had bargained for during this summer. Four points was the dividing margin, and to prove that that wasn’t a fluke, Ger Brennan’s team then made it to the All-Ireland quarter-finals.
Going one better is on Louth players’ minds, if one is to judge by the reaction of a panellist your writer was in conversation with a few weeks ago.
“You’ll be aiming to stay in Division Two (of the league)”, he was asked.
“Of course. But the big one is the Leinster Championship, and that’s what we’re aiming for.”
This was before McCarthy and Fenton had declared their intentions. It’s an ambition that’s no doubt shared by the others, and that should leave Ger Brennan with no need to search for an incentive when he gathers his charges together ahead of the new season. Craig Lennon winning an All-Star, and three others getting a nomination, was an off-season boost.
The new rules will be in play for next year’s competitions, and with no county proficient in their application in the heat of battle, you would have to think there’s a chance there’ll be some fluctuation in the pecking order.