Disappointing result for Dundalk as they seek first win of the season

Ruairí Keating of St Patrick's Athletic shoots to score his side's first goal, past Dundalk goalkeeper Ross Munro. Photo by Piaras Ó Mídheach/Sportsfileplaceholder image
Ruairí Keating of St Patrick's Athletic shoots to score his side's first goal, past Dundalk goalkeeper Ross Munro. Photo by Piaras Ó Mídheach/Sportsfile

The Commentary Box | The Gerry Malone Column

The relegation trap door creaked open oh so slightly for Dundalk last Friday after they finished one of their most dreadful of weeks with another defeat, this time at Inchicore in Dublin against St Pats when they went down to a one nil defeat to the home side. Dundalk have now failed to win in Inchicore on their last seven visits. They have more worryingly failed to score in their last three games.

Dundalk went into the game on the back of their five nil hammering against Sligo Rovers at Oriel Park. It was a better performance than the Sligo game. But then, one could not expect anything worse. Pats played the worst football I have seen from them in a year since Dundalk beat them five nil at Oriel last season. Yet they were still the better side than Dundalk on Friday night.

The pressure has to be growing on Stephen O'Donnell now as there seems to be no way out of the trouble his side are in. More worryingly the confidence among the Dundalk players seems to be draining away gradually as each game is played.

It was a sad sight to see so many players drop to the ground in disappointment as the referee blew the final whistle after playing seven minutes of injury time. Some held their hands to the back of their head, others were just flat out on the inchicore turf as they saw another defeat notched on their record.The recruitment has just not worked out for Dundalk this season. Too many changes have had to be made and too many good players were lost in the close season.

To be fair to the manager he has been asked to put together a new side in the space of three weeks. He got away with it last season. This year it looks as though time may have beaten them. You may think what I am saying is an overreaction. It's not. I wish it was.

Quite a lot of the new signings just do not seem to have what it takes, to get Dundalk out of the hole they now find themselves in. To be fair they were not given enough time to even have the chance to gel. This was because Dundalk could only start to sign new players when the new owner came in.

To me some of the new players are just not up to the standard required for the League of Ireland Premier Division. Stephen O'Donnell of course has the final say who signs and who does not. But Brian Gartland also has a key role to play in recruitment. Indeed it is part of his job description.

So to me he is every bit as responsible about who comes in through the doors of Oriel in the pre-season. In fact Brian is the one who has to do the really hard work of speaking to agents and finding out what the player can offer. Some of the new players have been hugely disappointing. Even though there are only four games gone one can see the players who will be an asset and the ones who may not be.

Usually a player has time to settle in and establish themselves. The new players just have not had that time as they were signed so late. That is neither Stephen O'Donnell's fault or Brian Gartland. But football is a results game. And a manager is judged by his results. The person who has recruited the players must also be judged by the results. Thus if the rut continues, pressure will continue to grow on both Stephen O'Donnell and Brian Gartland.

Dundalk had chances to win or at least draw the game last Friday. But they just simply do not have anybody to put the ball in the back of the net. They should have got something from Inchicore on Friday against a Pat's side who had lost their last three games in a row. That they did not was because they continue to give away silly goals and can not score.

On a night when Dundalk could not score their former goal machine was getting three for Derry City maintaining the Brandywell team's position at the top with Shelbourne. It just really annoys me that Hoban was the one player that I felt Ruaidhri Higgins could not sign from Oriel this season as he had one year left on his contract.

Whatever happened before the end of last season between Hoban and O'Donnell resulted in the club's record goal scorer heading north west. It is sickening to think Hoban could still be scoring for Dundalk. Instead he is doing it for Derry.It was a serious mistake letting Hoban go. He could score the goals Dundalk cannot do so now.

He could win games when Dundalk looked destined to lose. Now he is the final piece in the Higgins jigsaw as he tries to win the league. He has signed 8 Dundalk players in the past 3 years. It's incredible how one manager has been able to sign so many players from an opposing club.

Stephen O'Donnell has allowed established Irish players to leave Dundalk. Himself and Brian Gartland have been forced in many ways to go with the policy of relying too heavily on loan players and shopping in the bargain basement of the lower Scottish Leagues for players . This has led to an attempt to defy all the known principles of team building by attempting the impossible of putting a new team together every season. There is no one among the new players individually at fault.

What's certain this season is that there is a distinct lack of quality in this Dundalk side.They are indecisive at the back. They lack guile and energy in midfield . As stated already they are totally impotent in attack. They have scored only once in four games. This was from a free kick . Thus it's very difficult to see where the goals are going to come from. On the evidence of three of their four games to date, Dundalk are without doubt relegation material.I find it impossible to make any further conclusion.

Why in God's name did Nathan Shepperd not get the two year contract when he looked for it at the beginning of season 2023, Instead the club used a clause in his contract to ensure he stayed another season. But he was able to go at the end of 2023. He wanted to stay with the two year contract he was looking for in 2023 and as a result was left in no man's land at the end of last season.

Why did the previous owners, Stats Sports and Andy Connolly not ensure that the manager had the team he wanted for 2024. Why was it left for new owner Brian Ainscough to pay out funds for a completely new team in such a limited timescele. No player was signed by Dundalk from the end of the season until Ainscough took over. This in itself ensured that putting together a new team would be a rushed job for any team building. It resulted in 11 players being signed by the new owner for season 2024, 4 of whom are on loan.

There has not been a real mention of the previous owners since the owner took over. Issues such as preparation for the 2024 season could have been dealt with much better than they were. As a result there was a lot for the new owner to do to get things ready for season 2024.

I have no doubt the previous owners did have a lot done for the new season. But they do not seem to have anything done for signing players. It;s ironic that on the morning of the announcement of the takeover Stephen O'Donnell was able to make his first signing. That was Sam Durrant, the young midfielder who was with the team last season on a short term contract.

Friday night's game was played in front of a crowd of 5,200. The manager made 5 changes from the side that were beaten by Sligo four days previously. Out went keeper George Shelvey with Ross Munro coming into the side. Ross did come on in the second half in place of Shelvey in the Sligo game.

Dundalk said that Shelvey had an injury and that was why he missed Friday's game. Louis Annesley came in at centre half in place of Mayowa. He had a concussion in the Sligo game and came off injured. Jamie Walker was dropped in favour of Hayden Muller. He was much more self-assured than the unreliable Walker. Cameron Elliottt was dropped for Jamie Gullen, Ciaran McGuckin came in for Paul Doyle.

Dundalk started the game on the front foot. Ciaran McGuckin had an effort that forced the Pat's keeper Daniel Rogers into a good save. Pats came roaring back. Anto Breslin got a great cross in front of the Dundalk goal. There was nobody there to finish the ball off. Pat's had a definite penalty waved away when Brandon Kavanagh was clearly fouled in the box by Hayden Muller. Pat's had a second clear penalty waved away by referee Ray Mathews. Ciaran McGuckan clearly fouled Jason McLelland in the box but again no penalty.

Pats got the golden winner after the half hour. Dundalk had a corner cleared away and were caught on the break. Chris Forester hooked a ball over the top which caught the Dundalk defence in no man's land. Brandon Kavanagh showed great control to hold off Hayden Muller.

He laid the ball off so well for the in rushing Ruairi Keating. His shot was parried away by Munro. Keating got a second chance and made no mistake in finishing the ball to the net. Dundalk nearly conceded again in the early stages of the second half when Louis Annesley's loose header in the box saw Ardee man Kian Leavy run on and force the save of the night from Munro with a stinging left footed drive.

Robbie Benson then shot over for close range. Dundalk were in for a goal on 76 minutes when James Gullan was in the clear in the box. Luke Turner's tackle was top class and cleared the ball to safety.

Sam Durrant then had a pile driver of a shot on the edge of the box go narrowly wide. Despite seven minutes of injury time Dundalk could just not get the equaliser. It was Dundalk's third defeat on the spin.

Before the start of the season I said Dundalk would struggle this and believe me they are. I just do not see that changing. Right now they look as if they have a one way ticket for the first Division. In a post match interview Stephen O'Donnell says that Dundalk are giving away what he called rubbish goals. I asked him if the Pats defeat just added to the pressure he must now be under.

The manager said it was not about him. He added that when results do not go your way they will be scrutinised. But he felt Dundalk must stop giving away silly goals. I asked the Dundalk manager if he thought he still had the confidence of club owner Brian Ainsciough, Stephen says he has a good relationship with the club owner.

But he added that whatever happens to him happens to him. The manager says he was more concerned about where the team goes from here. He says they have to stop giving soft goals away. Well to the manager and Brian Gartland I say that they would not be conceding silly goals had they kept Nathan Shepperd. And had Stephen O'Donnell not let Pat Hoban go they would have little difficulty scoring goals.

Stephen O'Donnell has been a great servant for Dundalk. There is no doubt that he is losing the supporters. But to be asked to assemble three new teams in a short space of time just weeks before the start of the past three seasons is just a bit too much to ask him to do. He will remain on as manager until after the Waterford game next Friday at Oriel at least. There will then be an international break of two weeks. Who knows what will happen after that?

There was great sadness in the area when the news came through that Sonia Hoey had passed away after a long battle with cancer. Sonia was a great sportsperson and was a leading soccer and Gaelic footballer. She played soccer for Castletown Celtic ,Dundalk City Ladies, Peamount Ladies and Rock Celtic.

When she played for Dundalk City Ladies, she scored the only goal of the game in the 2005 Women's FAI Cup final against Peamount Ladies at Lansdowne Road. Her goal brought the cup back to Oriel for the first and only time to date. I remember that game clearly. I was covering it for LMFM. There were great celebrations.

Sonia was a hero. She also played soccer for DKIT. She was also well known for her involvement in Gaelic Football. Sonia played for Dowdallshill GFC and the Louth Ladies. Sonia was first diagnosed with Stage 3 Cervical cancer in early 2019. A major fundraising effort was made on her behalf .

She travelled to Mexico and underwent specialised treatment. Sonia fought her illness so courageously for the next five years. Her passing leaves a great void in the lives of her family and many friends including those in the sporting world.

Have a safe week everybody and please remember to be careful out there.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice