Commentary Box: Dundalk went down to a shock defeat to bottom side Waterford

placeholder image
SPORTSFILE

The Commentary Box | The Gerry Malone Column

Dundalk went down to a shock 3-2 defeat to bottom side Waterford, after leading two nil in Oriel last Friday. A goal from John Mahon five minutes from time gave the Blues a deserved win.

And they left Dundalk with nothing to complain about, with the victory. Two goals from Tommy Lonergan before their winner came made it a nightmare Ciaran Kilduff will want to forget quickly.

Dundalk are facing a serious injury crisis. News has emerged that Danny Mullen could be out for the rest of the season. The striker injured against Bohemians last Friday week tore ligaments in his ankle.

He faces a lengthy spell out of the side. Gemi Arubi started his first game since the break. He was injured with the Ireand under 21's three weeks ago. He still has that injury.

It was clear to home supporters that Gbemi was still injured when he came on as a sub against Bohs last week. He started on Friday and failed to make any impression in the game. Mayowa has missed the last four games with a hamstring injury.

He is still clearly suffering from that, as he had no impact on the game in the last 15 minutes when he was brought on as a sub. Harvey Warren is also another long term injury. He is most likely out for the rest of the season, too.

JR Wilson missed Friday's game. He was out due to illness. Declan McDaid also missed the game due to suspension. He was badly missed. Harry Groome started his first game for a long time and played well.

Tyreke Wilson also returned to the team. He came on as a sub last week in Dalymount. He started on Friday. Ciaran Kilduff had a threadbare subs bench made up mostly of underage players. With the injury crisis, Ciaran Kilduff needs to sign well in the window.

Will he be able to do that? That's a big question. Reports that Gbemi Arubi is heading across the channel have been denied by the manager. He denied one report that there is a price of half a million euro valuation on his head.

Gbemi has been strongly linked to Huddersfield and Burton Albion. The manager says I am wrong about the half-a-million figure and also that he has not been approached about a move for Gbemi.

Well, I have had that figure mentioned by a good source. I beg to differ with the Dundalk boss when he says that my source is wrong. I believe it's right.

If Dundalk get any kind of decent offer, they should let Gbemi go now, as he can leave as a free agent at the end of the season. But I am worried about Gemi's injury.

If I were a manager looking at the way he is playing at the moment, I would be only making a small offer. I would only do this based on his performance on Friday and the performance against Bohemians.

But this is not the true Gbemi. He will recover from the injury. But the manager has no option but to play him now as his squad is now so threadbare.

Eoin Kenny has also been linked to clubs in the UK. I am not surprised. But again, the manager says he knows nothing of this interest. If I were Eoin, I would play out the rest of the season with Dundalk.

They badly need him. He had another great game on Friday. He faded near the end. But for Dundalk, it would be best if Eoin did go now. They would get some much-needed money for him.

Eoin can leave Dundalk at the end of the season in October when he is no longer contracted with Dundalk. He is only 20.

He should not be in any rush to go to the UK or abroad. But if he gets a good offer, he should go. I am confident he is going nowhere until the end of October, if indeed he does go anywhere.

Dundalk lined out as follows on Friday. Enda Minogue was in goals. Enda could not deal with the high balls Waterford pumped into the Dundalk box.

He failed to dominate his penalty area. I give him 4. Keith Buckley was once again asked to play out of position. He had a good game at full back. He cleared a Lonergan shot off the line with Minogue beaten.

He battled bravely in his out of position place. I give him 7. Tyreke Wilson had a quiet game. He gets 6. Bobby Burns gets 7. Again, he put everything on the line. He was good. He did give away the penalty. He says the ball hit his hand.

I do not think it was intentional. Rob Cornwall was outstanding for Dundalk at centre half. I give him 7. Aodh Dervin was outstanding in the first half. He faded totally in the second half. I give him 7.

He was replaced by Mayowa in 74 minutes. I gave Mayowa 5. He was only on for 17 minutes. Harry Groome had a great game. He gets 7. His replacement, Shane Tracey, gets 5.

Ronan Teahan was superb in midfield and got 7. Eoin Kenny was superb once again. He got 8. He was top class. His headed goal was awesome.

Gbemi Arubi was not his usual self. But he is still injured. He gets 5. Daryl Horgan once again was superb. He gets 7. But Daryl did fade in the second half. So did most of the other Dundalk players.

Evan McMullan was top drawer for Waterford. He is a marvellous keeper and kept Dundalk at bay when they were really on fire. Evan is from the Dundalk area. I remember seeing him playing quite frequently with Irish league side Warrenpoint.

I was amazed Dundalk never made a move for him. He went to Fleetwood and then went to Waterford. He had a difficult start with them. Now he is showing his true class under new manager Graham Coughlin.

Waterford won this game with the high balls into the Dundalk penalty area, the way Dundalk just faded and crowding the Dundalk penalty area to hinder Enda Minogue. The tactic worked.

Once again, the Dundalk defence was smaller in height, as is their keeper. This lack of height gave Waterford a distinct advantage as they fought their way to come from 2-0 down to win the game.

It's a long time since I have seen Dundalk throw away a two nil lead and lose three two. But this team have been hit so much by injuries, unlike so many other teams in this league.

They are a credit to everybody, considering how they have taken the league by storm. Many forget that they were just promoted this season.

The games between Dundalk and Waterford have produced a dramatic 16 goals between them so far this season. Nobody could have seen Waterford winning this game, with halftime nearing and the Blues being two nil down.

Dundalk had collected 13 points from the last 15 available. Dundalk started the game with a great confidence. They dominated the early exchanges. Dundalk went 1-0 up after 10 minutes. Daryl Horgan sent in a corner from the left.

Eoin Kenny rose high above everybody in the box to head home. It was a magnificent goal. The ball hit the post on its way in. It gave Kenny his fifth goal of the season.

Dundalk doubled their score on the half hour. Daryl Horgan set up Harry Groome on the edge of the box. He hammered the ball to the roof of the net.

Dundalk keeper Enda Minogue had nothing to do up to the 40th minute. This was apart from punching away a Waterford corner. But Waterford shook Dundalk when Lonergan struck a sweet shot off the Dundalk crossbar from just four yards out.

The last time Dundalk and Waterford met here, Dundalk were 2-0 up at the break. They went on to win 5-0. This did not happen on Friday as the game suddenly took a blue turn for Waterford.

Referee Mark Lynch ruled a Lonergan header had crossed the line in first-half injury time as Keith Buckley tried to clear the ball. The sides were level 15 minutes into the second half.

On the hour mark. Bobby Burnes handled the ball in the box. Lonergan fired home the penalty. There were no protests from the Dundalk team. Bobby Burns was booked for handling the ball. Lonerrgan fired home the goal to the top left corner of the net.

Waterford got the winner four minutes from time when John Mahon shot home from just inside the box. It was an unbelievable recovery by Waterford. Dundalk were left stunned.

I sensed right through the game that there was something not right with the Dundalk team. They were never firing on all cylinders, and with all of the injured on and off the pitch, Something was going to crack at some stage.

It finally happened on Friday night. Waterford got their goals all from set pieces. Dundalk just cannot cope with these. Manager Ciaran  Kilduff must solve this problem soon. But it is a very difficult one to do.

After the game, Ciaran Kilduff told me in an exclusive interview that having led two nil, he felt his side would have gone on to win. But that was not to be. The manager agreed that there was always the feeling that Waterford were in the game.

"When it was 2-2, it was clear he said that whoever got the next goal would win. They got it; we did not. Keith Buckley cleared a great effort from Lonergan off the line. He was played in the wrong position tonight.

We were forced to do that late not long before the start of the game. Keith Buckley had to clear three efforts off the line. Danny Mullen may have to see a surgeon. He has sustained ligament damage following an injury against Bohemians. We have to deal with that now.

"Gbemi's leg was strapped tonight. He has a knee injury; it's a matter of pain management for Gbemi. Mayowa was probably rushed back too soon tonight. We had no option. We needed to do it. I have a great group in there. .

They do everything. I will wait for the surgeon to assess whether Darragh Mullen is out for the rest of the season. Yes, Harvey Warren is out for the rest of the season. Conor O'Keefe is weeks away from returning.

But he is also dealing with a double calf injury. He has to be assessed as quickly as possible. He also is dealing with the concussion issue.

Vinnie Leonard is also departing the team now, as we approach the opening of the window. But it's not just about having missed Vinny since the start of the season. We have lost a lot of players through injury.

We were lucky to have had other players stepping up to replace them. It's important we now assess where we are. We did not fill the bench tonight.

But we had enough players there to help us win that game. I would not take away from the fact that there were some very young players on the bench tonight. They are an important part of our team. They will be well able to help us over the line when called upon.

''I do not know anything about the departure of Gbemi. I have not read what you have read in the papers. As far as I know, there have been no offers for Gbemi.

It's news to me that there could be a price of up to half a million euro on his head. Your source is probably incorrect. I have no offer to report. I would tell you if I had. There is nothing about news on an offer for Gbemi.

''I have heard nothing on any offer for Eoin Kenny either. I am sure there is a lot of interest in our players. But listen, there is no news on anything. I have not been speaking to Archie Davies in terms of bringing him in. I have spoken to other players.

We are looking for reinforcements. But it's not as easy as it was. This is because we are now seen as a threat by the top clubs in the league. Previously, it was easier to recruit.

I am asked if this defeat was a setback for us in our quest. There seem to be many quests for us out there. Some weeks our quest is seen the title, other times it's to secure a place in Europe. Other weeks, our quest is seen in terms of survival.

"The season has not been completed. Then we will see what we have done.

"We will just take one game at a time. That's what we have been doing all season. We won three out of three of our last games, against Derry, Bohs and Galway. We did not want to lose that game tonight."

I asked the Dundalk boss would he have any interest in the vacancy at Tolka Park. He gave me an emphatic no. I said there was speculation linking him to the job a few months ago.

Ciaran said he is the Dundalk manager, and that was that. He said that he has never been approached by Shelbourne about taking charge at Tolka. He said he had nothing to report on this topic.

I asked Ciaran if he was approached by Shelbourne, would he be interested? "No, I would not be interested. I am Dundalk manager. I have a contract here. And I love it here. So I have nothing to report."

This is good news. But I am aware of reports that Shelbourne were ready to make a move for Kilduff earlier in the season, and they then decided to shelve a move at least temporarily.

Ciaran had great success at Shelbourne as a player, as he had at Dundalk. Shelbourne would be in a better financial state than Dundalk. They are also in Europe in July.

Bobby Burns has been a revelation for Dundalk this season. He has been playing in a back three role ub defence in recent games. He has also been on the scoresheet. He was a great signing by Ciaran Kilduff.

On Friday, he was adjudged to have handled the ball in the penalty area. This allowed Waterford to score from the penalty. But it seems it came of Bobby's hand by mistake. This may never have been given by many referees.

Mark Lynch had a poor game as a referee. "I am gutted by the result. Obviously, we got ourselves into a good lead. It was very disappointing to lose it. We have to pick ourselves back up now, as we have a huge game next Friday against Shelbourne.

I was trying to get ourselves to step out, and I had my arm out when the ball hit me. I will have to watch this penalty incident again. When it struck me, I was trying to get my arm out of the way.

I just thought there were a lot of soft free kicks given by the referee throughout the game. That's why I was annoyed with the referee when he gave the penalty against me. They are a huge team.

We knew they were going to have an advantage from throw-ins and free kicks. Their goalkeeper put a lot of balls in on top of us.

We have had a lot of injuries, and there were probably a lot of players playing for us that had a lot of injuries. We really do not have the same options to freshen up the squad. That is the challenge facing us.

"We will rest and recuperate for next Friday. It's a huge game for us at Tolka. We did get off to a great start. But conceding goals from set pieces is something we have struggled against all season.

We have got to try and tidy this up. It's so disappointing to be losing a game after we were 2-0 up. I thought myself, when we went to try and win it, when it was 2-2, that we may have lost it then.

We had a couple of great efforts. We had a couple of great shots that were deflected. Their keeper had a couple of great saves. But we will stick together. We will go back to our game.

But we did have a lot of lads playing out of position tonight. This was as a result of the injuries. Sometimes, this will hit a team. We need to get our injured lads back. We must also rest and recuperate.

"The Waterford keeper did very well. From our perspective, we could have scored. Right throughout the game, we had a couple of great chances at 2-0 and 2-1. But look, our forwards have been doing great all season.

Some of them have even been playing through injury. It was just disappointing we did not get the other goal. Then, at the other end, they manage to get a scrappy goal. In fairness, their keeper took off some great saves.

And some of his kicking of the ball put us under a lot of pressure. He had such a long kick that even if we won our headers, they were going out for throw-ins. They were then able to put us under pressure from these. His kicks were nearly creating throw-ins and corners.

"Lonergan had a great game for them and got two for them tonight. Amond is also a marvellous player. He has been top goal scorer for them over the past two years.

Waterford's achilles heel has probably been that they have been conceding too many goals this season. We knew their threats.

But us conceding from set pieces tonight was just so disappointing. The Shelbourne game is a massive one. We have beaten them in Tolka before. So we can beat them there again.

"Our ambition is just to win the next game in front of us. You have to remember we are such a young squad. We have a lot of lads that have also just come from the First Division. We have taken too many injuries this season.

There is Danny Mullins just walking past there. We lost Vinny, Conor Kearns, Conor O'Keeffe and the list goes on for most of the season. We have had some really important players missing.

But we have a good squad. We are confident that we can get back and go on a good run. When we are at our best, and we have everybody back, we are as good a team as everybody.

"We will have to look at the reason why we are conceding so many goals from set pieces. We are not one of the tallest teams in the league. It is a problem. It is definitely something that we will have to look at.''

I would agree with Bobby. Dundalk will have to look at the reason why they are conceding so many goals from set pieces. With Danny Mullen out for the rest of the season and with Gbemi carrying an injury, the side needs another striker.

At the back,  I feel the side needs a new keeper. Enda Minogue is not dominating his area. This is keeping pressure on the defence. Enda is not the reason why Dundalk are conceding all of the goals.

No, not at all. But Dundalk need a keeper who will come out for crosses and secure them. They also need a keeper who will catch the ball when it comes in for a cross. Very often, Enda will just punch the ball away. When the penalty area is crowded, that can be a problem for any keeper. I just felt Enda had difficulty in these situations.

But the defence has problems because of the their height. Players are also playing out of position because of the injuries. Players are also being asked to play with injuries. This puts pressure on the entire team.

Dundalk need a midfielder, a centre half, goalkeeper and a new striker. It will be almost impossible for Dundalk to get players in these positions.

If Gbemi Arubi does go now in the transfer window, they might as well wave the white flag as far as any hopes of getting into Europe are concerned. But if Dundalk turn down good money for him now, they will get nothing for him in October.

I was very sorry to hear the news that Gerry Goodman had passed away recently. Gerry was a former Director of the club during the Gerry Mathews era.

He was a gentle man. He lost his wife a number of years ago. I remember meeting him shortly after that. Gerry always had a smile on his face. If you met him in the shop or on the street, he would always want to stop and talk about the club.

I wish to extend my deepest sympathies to Gerry's family and friends. There was a minutes applause in Gerry's memory at Oriel before the Waterford game on Friday.

In women's soccer, it was great to see Dundalk advance to the second round of the Women's Under-23 FAI Cup. On Sunday, they beat Pats at Inchicore by two goals to one. Pats took the lead.

But Siun Kirby levelled things up to 1-1 at half time. A goal from Emesta Marut in the second half won it for the Dundalk women.

Next Friday's away game against Shelbourne will be very difficult. They should have a new manager at Tolka Park by then.

On Saturday night, they scored two goals in the dying minutes to draw 2-2 with Sligo Rovers. The last time the sides met was in Oriel. Shelbourne had a decisive win.

I want to congratulate Louth on beating Monaghan in the All-Ireland quarter final at Croke Park on Sunday. It's the first time Louth have got to the semi final since 1957.

Louth went on to win the All-Ireland that season. The bookies are giving Louth no chance to win it. Anything can happen now.

Have a great week. Look after yourselves and each other. And please remember to be careful out there.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice