Use of handcuffs on Dundalk man was justified, says judge


Court
A man who contested a drink driving prosecution on the grounds that he was handcuffed, has been convicted at Dundalk District Court after Judge John Coughlan ruled that the use of the restraints was justified.
The court heard how 48-year-old John Conlan of Burns Lane, Newry Road, Dundalk had kicked out at gardaí after he refused to get into the patrol car after his arrest.
A Garda told the court last Wednesday that he was on mobile patrol on the Dublin Road in Dundalk on June 14th 2016 at 4.40am when he observed the defendant driving at speed.
He said Mr. Conlan broke a red traffic light and failed to indicate as he pulled onto the Inner Relief Road.
The Garda said the accused was driving erratically and turned onto Hoey's Lane, where he was stopped. He added the defendant's speech was slurred, his eyes glazed and there was a smell of alcohol off him.
The court also heard he was unsteady on his feet as he got out of the car.
After being told he was being arrested on suspicion of drink driving, the accused became rigid and kicked out at gardaí when he was being placed in the patrol car.
The Defence solicitor said the case was being contested on the use of the handcuffs which Judge Coughlan noted there had been a High Court ruling on.
However, Insp. Martin Beggy pointed out that the use of the handcuffs had to be justified.
The Defence solicitor argued that his client had pulled over and exited his car without any issue.
However the investigating garda said after he had informed him of his arrest and asked him to sit in the patrol car, John Conlan had refused and then became aggressive and the handcuffs were used for the defendant's safety and the garda's safety.
When the solicitor asked if there was a discussion about his client retrieving his mobile phone from the car, the Garda said he couldn't recall but he would not have had an issue with that.
Judge Coughlan ruled the use of the handcuffs was justified. He imposed a two year driving ban and a €75 fine.
