Transfer merry-go-round continues as Dundalk say goodbye to legend Hoban


The Commentary Box: The Gerry Malone Column
It was the most significant week of the pre-season at Oriel Park this week when it became clear that Dundalk waved goodbye to one if not two of the most significant players who would have had a massive influence on the outcome of next year's season for the club.
Pat Hoban's speculated move to Derry City happened on Wednesday. Then on Friday morning came the news that Nathan Shepperd, one of the most exciting prospects in a goalie's shirt to play for Dundalk may not be returning.
News also filtered through on the same day that Peter Cherrie would not be the club's goalkeeping coach. The veteran keeper was widely seen as Dermot O'Neill's successor to the position. But the club amazingly overlooked him for the position. It's thought unlikely that Peter will be returning as the number two keeper as well.
Dundalk did announce two new signings on the positive side and a contract renewal. Dundalk born Mayowa Animashaun will feature a lot in the Dundalk first team next season. He had been away on loan with Dungannon Swifts last season.
Then due to problems with his club registration, he could not take part in any of the remaining games of the season from last June. The tall centre half would have been a real asset to Stephen O'Donnell in that crucial part of the season. However it was not to be.
But there is no doubt Mayowa will play a key role in Stephen O'Donnell's plans next season. Mayowa made his first full debut for Dundalk in the 2021 FAI cup quarter final win over Finn Harps at Oriel Park.
Dundalk also announced the signing of 21 year old Robbie Mahon from Scottish club Motherwell. Mahon came through the academy system at Bohemians. He then spent almost two years in Scotland, where he won the League One title at Dunfermline during a loan spell.
Dundalk had already brought in Dutch midfielder Koen Oostenbrink two weeks ago.
Dundalk played a behind closed doors game against Shelbourne at the AUL grounds in north County Dublin last Friday.
The game finished 1-1. Keith Ward put Shelbourne ahead only for Scott Brady to level things up for Dundalk with a terrific goal. Dundalk had a number of trialists in the team.
One of these trialists was an international goalkeeper from Togo. Malcolm Barcola has picked up 21 caps for his country. He is over six foot. Malcolm played for part of the game. He was born in Lyon France and was on the bench for his local side a number of times. He moved on to the Bosnia and Herzegovina League and played 11 times for Tuzla City. He departed from there last May.
Last Wednesday came the news that Pat Hoban had departed for Derry City. It was inevitable after Hoban revealed he had been told by Stephen O'Donnell that he could find another club two days before the final home game of the season against Bohemians. Derry are paying an initial fee of €30,000 for Hoban.
The deal also includes add-ons that will increase the money Derry give for Hoban. This depends on success in the league and success in Europe next season by Derry. There was no financial reason why Hoban should have been let go. New owner Brian Ainscough confirmed this at his December press conference. He made it clear from the off that it was a matter between the manager and Hoban.
It came to a head midweek after it was revealed by chief soccer correspondent with Independent Newspapers Daniel McDonnell that Hoban was on his way to the north west. Books I am sure will be written as to why Dundalk decided to dispense with the club leading record goal scorer of all time at such a crucial period in the club's history.
He would have been an invaluable asset this coming season in what already looks to be a weakened squad in comparison to last season.
Darragh Leahy, Daniel Kelly, John Martin, Greg Sloggett, Keith Ward and Connor Malley are among some of the players already gone. Now the club has no Hoban or possibly Nathan Shepperd it surely puts Brian Gartland and Stephen O'Donnell under even greater pressure to get their recruitment right considering the calibre of players that have departed.
Whatever caused the split between Stephen O'Donnell and Pat Hoban in the end is a real shame. They were teammates for years. I am sure they were great friends as well. Stephen would not make any comment in November at the infamous post match press conference that saw him continuously saying no comment as to what had happened or indeed if anything had happened in his talk with Pat Hoban.
He never even confirmed the talk had happened until after the transfer with Derry took place last week. Instead he made an extraordinary outburst at the time on what he saw was the negativity around Oriel. He spoke about how it affected his young team. But now quite a number of that team have departed.
Pat Hoban told me in an interview at the end of last season that he had been given a reason by Stephen O'Donnell as to why he should look for another club. But he said he was not going to say what it was at that point. Pat said it would all come out at some stage. When asked by me if the manager was carrying out instructions from somebody else, he said he had no idea. But the Galway man said he would continue in the game and at 32 he felt he had another three good years in him. Pat said he would not stay anywhere he was not wanted.
And so 10 weeks later as expected Derry came in and signed him. It brings to nine the number of players Ruaidhrí Higgins has signed from Dundalk. It's incredible that the Derry manager has swooped like a vulture and signed whatever Dundalk player he felt was an asset to him. There is nothing wrong with that. But it shows how far down the ratings Dundalk have fallen where one club can just come in and sign the best players at Oriel. Higgins will be under a lot of pressure to deliver at Derry this season. If he does not win the league, it would be no surprise if he is asked to step down by the Derry owner.
Stephen O'Donnell told the Dundalk website that Hoban's departure from the club was in the best interest of both parties. The Dundalk boss said that a parting of the waves became apparent following a meeting between him and Pat Hoban at the end of October. This was the first time O'Donnell acknowledged publicly that such a meeting had taken place. O'Donnell said that they both sat down in person and had a chat about different things.
O'Donnell continued that there was a lot of uncertainty at the time and they talked about where the club was at and where they both felt about where the club was going. The Dundalk manager says he felt the meeting was amicable and constructive. But he said Pat came out in the media a couple of days later and said he felt it was the end of the line for him at Dundalk.
O'Donnell said that once a player has that in his head, it was best for both parties to start afresh and find an agreement that was fair for both. The O'Donnell statement leaves some confusion.
He says he felt the meeting was amicable and that Hoban two days later said it was the end of the line for him at Dundalk. Stephen does not refer to Pat Hoban's interpretation of the meeting where he claims he was told by the manager to find another club. This is all academic now. Hoban is a Derry player.
Stephen O'Donnell paid a great tribute to Hoban on the day the transfer deal had gone through. He described Pat as being an unbelievable servant to Dundalk. He said he was the club's record goal scorer. O'Donnell said that the numbers are there to show the contribution Pat has made to the club and that nobody will ever take that away from him. O'Donnell said that he and everybody at the club wished him well.
In a statement on social media Pat said a new era in his life and career was beginning for him at Derry. But he said that he wished to thank each and every Dundalk fan and team mate who made his eight seasons at Oriel so special. Pat added that Dundalk became more than just a football club to him. It became his home and a place where he is thankful to have met so many wonderful people, many which he now called friends.
Players move on in every club. Pat Hoban has had a long and successful career at Oriel. It's going to be hard to see a Dundalk team without their captain and all time leading goal scorer. But I am sure every Dundalk fan will wish Pat well at a club that is really the Dundalk team of the north west as a result of taking so many players from Oriel.
Dundalk has to stop the fact over the next year or two that they have seen their best players over the past few years going to other clubs when they can still offer so much to Dundalk. The fact that Dundalk have lost a lot of League of Ireland players since November 2023 is a huge worry. The other worry is that they have yet to sign one League of Ireland player for next season. I find this really troubling. None of this is the fault of the new owner.
But he needs to get his own CEO into the club immediately to do a big analysis on the workings of the club. He also needs to be on the ground on a very frequent basis. The idea of an absentee owner will just not work. I am sure Brian Ainscough knows this.
On Friday it emerged that talks between Nathan Shepperd's reps and Dundalk FC in the previous day or so had broken down. The news was not good. The reports were that Nathan Shepperd would not be returning to Oriel. The breakdown in the talks are reported to have centred around a clause in the contract Nathan's reps wanted to have inserted into it. It was unacceptable to Dundalk.
As a result talks broke down. Dundalk were right to stand their ground. Unless there was a movement at attempting to solve the problems between both sides over the weekend, then sadly the career of one of the best keepers in the league at Oriel is at an end. Nathan had a great first year with Dundalk in 2022.
It was the terrific saves he made that season that ensured Dundalk would get a place in the Europa Conference League in season 2023. At the beginning of that season Dundalk exercised their option to keep Nathan for another season. He looked for a relatively small increase in his wages. The idea by Nathan's reps also was that he would sign a new two year contract with Dundalk. But Dundalk showed little interest and the second year of his original contract continued.
The form of the Dundalk team of 2023 took a step backwards as far as progress was concerned from 2022 as they conceded a lot more goals. This was not Nathan's fault as he continued to take off some considerable saves.
The news as it stands on Nathan is that he will not be back at Oriel. Had Dundalk given him the two year contract in 2023, we would not be talking about this now.Dundalk were at fault in 2023. But now it is right to say Dundalk were 100 per cent correct to not concede to what Nathan's reps were looking for in January 2024..
On Friday it also emerged that the reserve keeper Peter Cherrie had been overlooked for the goalkeeping coach job at the club. The job became vacant when Dermot O'Neill retired last November. Peter has been a great servant to the club. He won a league medal in 2014 with Dundalk under Stephen Kenny. He had been with the club since 2008. Peter's career at Dundalk was cut short just as the success began under Stephen Kenny.
He did play with Derry City at one stage before coming back to Dundalk in 2021. Peter saved Dundalk from getting dragged into the relegation quagmire, when he played for the last nine games of the season. The stability of having Peter in goals ensured Dundalk started to win games and finish clear of the relegation quagmire.
2021 was a crazy season. It was the year of the three managers. Shane Keegan started as manager. He was gone within a short time. Director of Football Jim Magilton took over as caretaker manager. He had initial success. But Dundalk slid down the table again as the poor form re-appeared. Towards the latter end of the season Vinny Perth was brought back . It took Vinny a while before he put Peter back in.
When he did, Dundalk's season stabilised as they edged to safety. Peter stayed on at Oriel for seasons 2022 and 2023 as the number two keeper to Nathan Shepherd. He looked to be a shoe-in for the goalkeeping coach vacancy when Dermot O'Neill left the club. But it was not to be for Peter as the powers that be opted for another candidate.
Dundalk begin their series of pre-season games at Oriel on Thursday, when they play first Division Longford Town at Oriel. Next Sunday they are in North County Dublin to take on Malahide United at Gannon Park.That's in the Leinster Senior Cup.
On Friday February 2nd Dundalk take on Drogheda United in the second game of the Leinster Senior Cup.
The annual Jim Malone cup will also be played on that night. Dundalk will take on Bohemians the following Monday 5th February at Oriel.
Have a safe week. Be careful out there and please look out for each other.