Over €1.975 million in Louth District Court fines issued over last five years remain unpaid


546 Louth District Court fines worth a staggering €276k went unpaid last year
A total of €471k in district court fines were issued by Dundalk Court Office last year, according to figures released to the Dundalk Democrat under Freedom of Information (FOI).
Of the 1,358 fines issued 794 were recovered in part or in full representing €192k.
A total of €2,790 (18 fines) were deemed “uncollectable” leaving an outstanding amount of €276k (546 fines) still to be paid.
Over €1.975 million in District Court fines issued in Louth between 2019 and 2023 remain unpaid according to figures released to the Dundalk Democrat under Freedom of Information (FOI).
Figures show that over the last five years 6,730 fines totalling just over €2.65 million were issued through Dundalk Court Office which includes the District Court Areas of Dundalk, Drogheda and Ardee.
However, just 2,695 fines have been paid in full or in part, meaning almost 75% of the money due is still outstanding. Fines are issued by the courts as a punishment for an offence and are often an alternative to community service or imprisonment.
Under the Fines Act 2014, those sanctioned can now pay in instalments in a move that was brought in to stop the imprisonment of people who are unable to pay a fine in one go.
The year 2019 saw the most money left unpaid with 1,560 fines imposed at Dundalk Court Office adding to a total value of just over €1.386 million.
€165k (701 fines) of this has been recovered in full or in part, with €4678 (35 fines) deemed “uncollectable” leaving an outstanding amount of €1.216 million (824 fines) still to be paid.
Fines can be deemed uncollectable for a number of reasons including if the person is deceased or if an enforcement sanction has been imposed.
The reason for the particularly high amount of fines in 2019 was due to one fine where the person was convicted of €500 per day from the date of offence which was the 6th of March 2014 to the date of conviction in court in 2019 plus costs and legal expenses.
The offence in question was contrary To The Provisions Of Section 156 (2) Of The Planning And Development Act 2000.
2022 had the second most money left outstanding, with a total of 1,235 fines imposed at district court level in the county with a value of €330k.
€117k (447 fines) of this has been recovered in part or in full, leaving an outstanding amount of just over €205k (788 fines) still to be paid.
Meanwhile, in 2021, 954 fines were imposed at Dundalk Court Office adding up to a value of €238k. €93k (370 fines) of this has been recovered, with €600 (3 fines) deemed “uncollectable” leaving an outstanding amount of just under €145k (581 fines) still to be paid.
Finally, 798 fines were imposed at Dundalk Court Office in 2020 with a value of just under €224k.
The figures show that €90k (370 fines) of this has been recovered in part or in full, with €1,150 (5 fines) deemed “uncollectable” leaving an outstanding amount of just over €132k (423 fines) still to be paid.
Additionally, over the last five years just over €450,000 was paid into the poor box at Dundalk Court Offices.
A little more than 62k was donated to the poor box in Louth last year with The Red Door Project receiving the largest share of €22,100. Turas Fundraising A/C received €21,575 and Mid Louth Strengthening Families Programme received €3,600. Last year €62,670 was paid into the Louth poor box.
Poor box figures for 2022 showed €42,150.00 was paid to The Red Door Project, 37,420 to Turas Fundraising A/C and €4,600.00 to the Mid-Louth Strengthening Families Programme. A total of €109,809.33 was paid into the Dundalk poor box in 2022.
2021 again saw Turas Counselling (€35,664) and The Red Door Project (€38,653) receive the most poor box donations, with The Mid-Louth Strengthening Families Programme (€2500) receiving the third most. Just over €80k was donated to the poor box in Louth that year.
Turas Counselling (€39,300) and The Red Door Project (€33,800) received the most from the poor box in 2019 with Women’s Aid Dundalk receiving €3930 and a total of €91,580 ordered to be paid into the poor box that year.
Over 108k was donated to the poor box in 2019 with Turas Counselling (€10,160), The Red Door Project (€7600) and Family Addiction Support Network (€6,700) the biggest beneficiaries.
A spokesman for the Courts Service described the Poor Box as being “predominantly used by the District Courts who deal with criminal offences of a less serious nature.
“The individual amounts can vary substantially depending on ability to pay, other penalties imposed, and the nature of the offences.
“The option of paying into the Court Poor Box usually arises where the offence is minor in nature and would not attract a custodial sentence.
“Public order offences can be the most common offences for which the Poor Box option is given to defendants.
“These include breaches of the peace, intoxication, or disorderly conduct in a public place, threatening, abusive or insulting behaviour in a public place, or failing to comply with a direction from An Garda Síochána. It is at other times used for first time, minor drug offences, and offences against property.
“There are many reasons and instances why the Court Poor Box is used by judges of offences on the more minor side of the scale.
“The accused may never previously have been before the courts, the accused may have pleaded guilty, a conviction might be inappropriate, or might adversely affect employment, career or working abroad prospects, and / or the offence may be of a minor or less serious nature.
“When combined with the Probation of Offenders Act it provides an option where the person is held accountable in public court, some financial penalty is considered merited, but a conviction and fine are not.
"It can sometimes be a more meaningful punishment than the maximum fine where the value of a maximum fine may have been eroded by inflation”.
