Motorist fined and banned for dangerous driving in Louth


A 19 year old man who denied driving a car which took off at speed on the Dundalk/Greenore Road and claimed he was at work at the time and it was a case of mistaken identity, was convicted at Dundalk District Court
A 19 year old man who denied driving a car which took off at speed on the Dundalk/Greenore Road and claimed he was at work at the time and it was a case of mistaken identity, was convicted at Dundalk District Court last week.
Fionn Duffy formerly of Loughanmore House, Lordship, Co. Louth and now with an address at Crossan Road, Mayobridge, Co. Down was prosecuted for dangerous driving at Loughanmore, Rampark, Rockmarshall, Bellurgan and Ballymascanlon and driving without insurance or a driving licence at Loughanmore on October 15th 2022.
The investigating Garda gave evidence of seeing the defendant behind the wheel of a dark coloured Mercedes car shortly before 9.30am on the R173 at Mountbagnall where it was parked on the hard shoulder, facing in the wrong direction.
He explained he had looked directly at the driver, as a car with a similar description had been seen acting suspiciously in the area.
The garda told how he had turned the patrol vehicle and the defendant took off at speed and at various locations had overtaken other vehicles on a continuous white line including traffic that had slowed down for speed ramps outside the Pat's grounds, where he said there's a children's playground and coffee shop.
He added the Mercedes drove at speed past Bellurgan national school and failed to slow at the Ballymac roundabout and caused other motorists to brake to avoid it.
When he called the next night, the defendant's mother said he wasn't at home and he failed to attend the garda station or make any effort to contact the garda, as he had requested.
The witness said he's known Mr Duffy since the defendant was seven or eight years old.
The Defence barrister argued that the Mercedes driver was not his client, who was doing excavation work on the date in question and argued that he had previously been mistaken for a close relative by a different garda.
Mr. Duffy in the witness box produced a SnapChat memory time stamped 3.30pm, to prove this.
Although he stressed it had been recorded on his mobile phone, the defendant agreed under cross examination that he could not physically be seen in the clip.
Insp Ger Collins also pointed out the dangerous driving had occurred that morning and not in the afternoon although Mr. Duffy claimed he had been at work since 7.30am.
He claimed he had been unaware that the case was listed for a contested hearing that day and said he'd been unable to contact the man who had collected him until that morning, but he could not attend as a defence witness , as he was working.
An application to dismiss the no insurance summons was successful, as the lawful demand for the certificate to be produced was made a month and a half after the legal limit.
When Judge Eirinn McKiernan asked if his mum had told him the garda had called, Fionn Duffy said he was advised by his solicitor there was no need to contact him.
Judge McKiernan added "You're 18 years of age and a garda's looking for you. Why did you go (to the garda station) in January?".
The defendant replied "Because I had to go in for a release form" to which the judge remarked "So you ignored the garda's request".
Mr. Duffy confirmed the Mercedes was his and when Insp Ger Collins asked who he was suggesting was driving it at the time, he replied "I don't know" and when asked about the garda identifying him as the driver said "I accept that he thinks he knows me".
Judge McKiernan in convicting him, said ignoring the garda's request was "not the action of somebody saying 'It wasn't me. I didn't do it".
The judge imposed a €300 fine and a two year driving ban and at the request of the Defence fixed recognizance in the event of an appeal being lodged.
