Man who failed to give sample to Dundalk gardai claimed he had a head cold


Court
A 57-year-old man who denied that he had failed to give a drink driving breath specimen at Dundalk Garda Station, and claimed he was unable to, because he had a head cold, was convicted at the local district court last week and banned from driving for four years.
Oliver Bradley who gave an address at Daragh Park, Newry was prosecuted for failing to comply with a requirement to provide two breath specimens for a roadside breath test on the Inner Relief Road, Dundalk on December 30th last, with driving under the influence of an intoxicant, and refusing to comply with a requirement to give a specimen at Dundalk Garda Station.
The court heard that the defendant had made several attempts to provide a specimen for a roadside breath test and was arrested.
He subsequently failed to provide sufficient breath for a reading at Dundalk Garda Station and a doctor was called to take a blood sample, which was above the legal limit.
The Defence solicitor told the court her client was suffering from a bad cold at the time and argued that he had made four attempts to provide breath.
She added that the reading of the blood test was so low her client ought to have been given the opportunity to be dealt with by way of a fine and three penalty points.
Insp. Martin Beggy agreed with the submission.
In respect of the remaining charges, the solicitor argued that there was no evidence of her client refusing to give the breath specimen in the Garda Station, where he had made two attempts and subsequently gave a blood sample.
Mr. Bradley told the court "I did my best to give a sample" and said he was caught up in the chest and nose due to a head cold.
He claimed that when he was asked if there was any medical reason that he could not give the breath specimen, he thought the garda meant the likes of a heart condition.
However, Judge John Coughlan convicted him of refusing to give a breath specimen. He imposed a four year disqualification and €75 fine. After he was told the accused is a carer for an elderly relative and the loss of his licence would be significant, the Judge said Mr Bradley could appeal by entering a bond of €300 in cash.