Fault for Dundalk's limp Cup exit lies both on and off the pitch

Cameron Elliott of Dundalk after the Sports Direct Men’s FAI Cup quarter-final match between Galway United and Dundalk at Eamonn Deacy Park in Galway. Photo by John Sheridan/Sportsfileplaceholder image
Cameron Elliott of Dundalk after the Sports Direct Men’s FAI Cup quarter-final match between Galway United and Dundalk at Eamonn Deacy Park in Galway. Photo by John Sheridan/Sportsfile

The Commentary Box: The Gerry Malone Column

The nightmare scenario I feared would happen materialisted at Eamonn Deacy Park last Friday in the FAI Cup semi final when Dundalk were hammered 4-0 by First Division champions Galway United.

It was Dundalk's worst display since 2012 when Shamrock Rovers beat Dundalk by 7-0. That was the year Dundalk avoided the drop back into the First Division when they won the relegation/playoff decider.

This cup quarter final was shocking.I knew Dundalk were going to be in for a very hard night when manager Stephen O'Donnell played the same team in exactly the same positions that Derry City had ripped asunder at Oriel Park two weeks previously with a 3-1 win.

O'Donnell that night said it was the best performance he had seen from a Dundalk side since he came to Oriel.

In his post match press conference in Galway,the Dundalk boss told reporters it was the worst night of his entire career.

I could not understand why he had left Darragh Leahy at centre half when that is not his normal position.

He also once again played Hayden Muller at left back when his natural position was playing as a centre half.

Dundalk looked woefully ill-prepared for this game. I know this is not the case. But on the pitch it looked like that in all positions.

Dundalk could not cope with Galway's physicality,speed or skill.

They were first to every ball. Three of their goals were from set pieces.

They had their homework done on Dundalk as well.

They knew Dundalk could be caught on the wings, the centre of midfield and the high ball. Dundalk's heads were down from the first goal. When Galway went four up they were dead and buried.

One reporter joked when he said that even a half time team talk from God would not bring Dundalk back.

They were 3-0 down within 31 minutes. We then saw the ignominy of the Dundalk boss making three substitutions 11 minutes from the break.

Off came Johannes Yli-Kokko, Darragh Leahy and Connor Malley. They were replaced by Robbie Benson, Greg Sloggett and Robbie McCourt.

The manager might as well have not made the substitutions as Galway  got a fourth  goal six minutes from the break when Robbie McCourt took Aodh Dervin down in the box. There was no need to give the penalty away. Man of the match David Hurley slotted it home with ease.

Galway started the game at a frantic pace. Stephen Walsh scored on eight minutes when Wassim Aouachria put in a great cross from the right.

Walsh was given so much space that he had no problem scoring.

The second goal happened on 20 minutes when David Hurley's corner was headed home by Ed McCarthy.

Then 11 minutes later it was three when again Hurley got a cross that Aodh Dervin scored from. The fourth came of course from a David Hurley penalty  on 38 minutes. 

Darren Brownlie, Sam Durrant were  replaced at different stages in the second half by Ryan O'Kane and  Cameron Elliott .

Nathan Shepherd, a top class keeper has seen his confidence drop in recent weeks  with all the terrible goals that Dundalk have conceded.

It was a forgetful night for full backs Archie Davies and Hayden Muller.

The two centre halves Connor Leahy and Darren Brownlie were poor.

The midfield just never got going.

Sam Durrant and Daniel Kelly were totally ineffective on the wings.

The other three in  midfield  were also totally ineffective.  The striker Pat Hoban also never got going as the whole team were so bad.

Galway  should have won by more. The referee  ruled out a definite penalty and a definite goal. 

I was amazed that neither Greg Sloggett nor Ryan O'Kane started.

John Martin was never brought on nor was Paul Doyle.

It raised my suspicions that these players were either not fully fit or indeed some were injured. I had heard 48 hours before the game that Dundalk had a big injury list.

Looking at the subs list they were all players who were either coming back from an injury or who I suspected might not be 100 percent fit after recovering from injury.

The first eleven looked jaded throughout until O'Donnell made the three straight subs on 34 minutes. The replacements had little or no impact on the game.

O'Donnell could not have put it any better when he said his side were absolutely woeful. He said the team did not know what to expect when they turned out to play Galway.

He said his side failed to show any resilience or physicality.

He summed it up well that Galway did what they wanted with Dundalk.

The manager also has to take responsibility for his team's result. He got his team selection very badly wrong.

Having said after the Derry game that his team must stop giving away sloppy goals, he plays the same defence. There can be no excuses for this.

O'Donnell says his team played like a team not knowing what to expect, I do not think he himself expected what Galway could do.

He seemed to totally underestimate them .

This was a team who had won all 14 games at home this season.

Dundalk played like a bottom of the table First Division team. Galway played like a good mid table Premier Division team. 

The manager in saying his team were totally woeful says it all.

Friday night was not the first time Dundalk were woeful.

The repercussions are enormous. Not only will they not be playing in Europe,it has huge financial implications.

The club will  lose out on a possible €300,000 for Friday's defeat and no Europe next season.

They have nothing left  to play for in the last six games.

They can't be dragged into the relegation zone. Nor can they go any further up the  table.

I could see this result coming from the moment I heard the draw three weeks ago.

Dundalk supporters brushed me off as did the media. But the nightmare did happen.

And it has happened in such a profound way one can not guess what's next for Dundalk FC.

Dundalk fans rightly vented their anger as the team came over to acknowledge the fans. The Dundalk boss  said he hoped that all of his players realise that the performance was not acceptable. I agree.

O'Donnell said it was important the Dundalk supporters were acknowledged by the entire team.

He says the fans had every right to vent their anger on the team as well.

O'Donnell said that his side knew Galway's strengths, but yet they did what they wanted to Dundalk ultimately.

The Dundalk team I saw on Friday were clueless and were nowhere near tuned into the strengths of the Galway opposition.

They had no answer to a Galway side who could have won by six or more.

The owners have to take a major responsibility over what happened.

Players were signed very late pre -season and none of them were from the League of Ireland.

Two of the three on loan signings did not work out either.

The recruitment policy was wrong from the start. The loss of Emmanuel Adegboyega to Drogheda and how it happened  was very unfortunate. He is now with Norwich.

Failure to give Nathan Shepherd a new contract at the start of the season  is all but certain to see him leaving in a few weeks time barring a major miracle.

Why did Dundalk have such a long injury list on a weekly basis. Everybody has their own opinion on that.

The owners won't talk to the local media. One wonders why.

Fans want  to hear from them now about where they see the future of the club going both on and off the field.

Now is the time to talk to the fans who have followed them loyally over the entire season and before.

It's not easy being the owner of a football club. It costs a lot of money. It's easy to criticise .

But the owners must make a much better connection with fans than they have done since they took over from Peak 6.

O'Donnell said that when his team went over to the away fans after the game,that  they were very angry.

He said it was understandable as it's the team and club they love.

He says every bit of flack they got was deserved.

He accepted they go behind too easily in games  and that they they gave away conceded goals far too easily.

He said that he does not know what this is down to adding that they will have to try and find out why they concede so easily but that's what it is.

I found this answer remarkable.

O'Donnell picked  the same  team that were torn apart by Derry two weeks before.

He has a serious problem in midfield and one in defence.

Galway were much more physically stronger than Dundalk up front.

The defence could not cope with it. Nor could the midfield.

The team simply did not have the hunger or the will to win.

Some reporters have asked if Daryl Horgan's effort of four minutes gone in, would it have been a different story? The answer is no.

Galway had their homework done on Dundalk. They wanted to win. Dundalk did not show the will to win.

Greenore man Conor McCormack contributed very well to the Galway win.

Conor, although from the  area, has never played for Dundalk.

His previous team Cork City  had  many clashes with Dundalk for the League and the Cup over many seasons.

He followed former Cork City manager John Caulfield to Galway a number of years ago. After the game a very happy Conor told me that they knew they would win the game.

He said that they had the self belief to do so.

He said that the team knew that Dundalk had a lot of strengths but that they also had a lot of weaknesses.

He said Galway's game plan worked perfectly. He says Galway knew exactly what Dundalk were going to do.

The Louth man continued that his side were just too good for Dundalk on the night.

Conor said that Dundalk have a problem at the back, adding he is sure that the Dundalk manager will try and sort this out.

Conor said that Galway that the Galway players have been watching all of the Dundalk games recently and knew exactly what to expect.

Conor said rightly they dominated Dundalk all over the park which ensured the Oriel Park side could just never get going.

He continued that Galway play to their strengths, adding that they do not have to dress things up, as they do not need to.

At the  end of the day Conor says it's all about results.

Again he says they knew all about Dundalk's weaknesses and that they just simply could not deal with Galway.

He said he was very surprised at the way Dundalk played.

I suggested there was no fight in the County Louth side. Conor agreed and said every other time he had played against previous Dundalk sides he had never seen them play the way they did on Friday night.

But the Greenore man was quick to emphasise that O'Donnell was a good manager.

He said that Dundalk had obviously just underestimated Galway. I have to agree with Conor on that.

Otherwise the Dundalk boss would never have started with the same team that played against Derry.

Conor said it looked like half of the Dundalk players did not want to be at Eamonn Deacy Park on Friday night such was the way they had played.

He continued that Galway were much more up for the game and they were really looking forward to it.

Conor said very few people gave them a chance. He said Dundalk are the Premier Division team who had internationals in their team and had won many honours.

He continued that a lot of his team had not even played in front of even 2,000 people up to Friday's game. Well they played in front of 4,300 against Dundalk.

I asked Conor at the end of the interview why he had never played for Dundalk.

He said Stephen Kenny did try to sign him, but he decided to go elsewhere.

When asked why,Conor said it was because Kenny was his manager before at Shamrock Rovers and Kenny decided to go with other players in his side.

Ultimately the Greenore man said it did not work out well for Kenny at Rovers.

He said he met with Kenny and they shook hands on Conor's decision not to sign for him at Dundalk.

The Galway player said he has nothing but the height of respect for the current Republic of Ireland manager.

I think Conor summed it all up as far as Friday is concerned on Dundalk's performance.

The end of the season can not come quickly enough for Dundalk.

The fault with Dundalk being beaten in the Cup by Galway lies with many at Oriel both on and off the pitch. The manager must take some of the responsibility.

But the defeat was by no means solely his.

There are others who must also share in the responsibility. Most importantly now the owners must decide what they want to do.

The malaise at Oriel can not be allowed to continue.

Next season the Premier Division will be much stronger than the current one.

Dundalk must start to strengthen on the pitch now.

They must never again leave it until weeks before the start of a season to sign players. And they must sign the right players.

They must also  sign the good prospects on a professional basis at the academy now on a professional contract  and thus ensure that no other player of elite talent is allowed to leave the club for another one with all the losses that this entails from this.

Have a good week.

Dundalk play St Pats in Inchicore on Friday. Next Monday they are at home to Cork.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice