High Court orders release of Louth man charged with Coca Cola theft

The case was heard at the High Court in Dublinplaceholder image
The case was heard at the High Court in Dublin | gg

Sean O’Hanlon had been before Dundalk District Court on 22 July

A man has been released from prison after the High Court found the Dundalk District Court proceedings which resulted in his detention did not amount to a fair hearing.

Mr Justice Garrett Simons directed the immediate release of Sean O’Hanlon from Cloverhill Prison.

Mr O’Hanlon had been before the District Court on 22 July in connection with an allegation involving the theft of two cans of Coca-Cola valued at €3.60. His existing bail was also revoked in relation to other charges.

In a judgment delivered yesterday (Tuesday, 18 August), Mr Justice Simons said he was “quite satisfied that Mr O’Hanlon’s detention is not in accordance with law”.

The judge said he had reviewed the transcript of the Dundalk proceedings and concluded that Mr O’Hanlon “was not given a hearing.”

During the Dundalk hearing, Mr O’Hanlon was asked whether he was applying for bail. He said that he was and referred to the allegation concerning the two cans of Coca-Cola, apologising and saying it would not happen again.

However, Mr Justice Simons said that response “could not reasonably be understood as an informed answer to the Garda objection as a whole.”

The judge found that Mr O’Hanlon had not been given an opportunity to question the Garda witness or to properly respond to the matters raised in the Garda objection to his release.

Those matters included 46 outstanding warrants, an alleged failure to comply with existing bail conditions and the possible implementation of conditions capable of addressing the asserted risks.

The judge said the court refused bail without inviting Mr O’Hanlon to make any further response.

In his judegement, Mr Justice Simons said: “It was only after bail had been refused that Mr O’Hanlon was able to say that he had recently obtained an address.

“That was clearly a matter which was relevant, or at least potentially relevant, both to the risk of non-attendance and to the possibility of using bail conditions to address that risk. An effective opportunity to be heard must, by definition, precede the decision.”

Additionally, Mr Justice Simons said bail was revoked in relation to other charges without Mr O’Hanlon being heard. He had not been given notice that the revocation would be sought and had not been given an opportunity to answer the application before it was determined.

The judge said the case fell within the exceptional category of cases where the High Court can intervene under Article 40.4.2° of the Constitution.

The article gives the High Court the power to test if a person’s detention is lawful.

Ordering that Mr O’Hanlon should be released from prison, he said: "Regrettably, I have to say that the events before the District Court in relation to Mr O’Hanlon did not constitute a hearing.”

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice