Alleged road rage case dismissed by Dundalk judge


Court
A 48-year-old man accused of assaulting another motorist in an alleged road rage incident, has had the case against him dismissed at Dundalk District Court after Judge John Coughlan heard conflicting accounts of events.
Arthur Mullen with an address at Ballymakellet, Ravensdale contested the charge of assault causing harm on Barrack Street, Dundalk on the grounds that he was acting in self-defence.
The court heard last Wednesday that the defendant was travelling immediately behind the complainant in the case on January 22nd last year and that neither of the men knew the other beforehand.
The alleged victim told the court he had four young children in the car and had done nothing to provoke the accused adding "I did not raise a finger. I got hit by this man twice".
Statements from both men were subsequently handed into the court and the complainant got into the witness box.
He said he noticed a grey jeep behind him and the defendant was flashing the lights and ranting.
The Defence barrister said her client accepted there had been an altercation, but what was in dispute is who started it.
The complainant said the accused had blocked in his car and as his children were screaming, he got out to speak to him as the witness he didn't want the defendant to approach the car as he claimed "I knew he was looking for a fight".
He said the accused hit him twice and claimed he'd said "Big man, Hard man. I'll show you now".
The witness said he had contacted a Garda he knows through the golf club, who had advised him to make a statement.
He denied a Defence suggestion that he had “instigated the words”. The barrister told the court her client says the complainant had stopped in the middle of the road, he went around him and claims that as he got out, the complainant struck him on the ear.
Although there are CCTV cameras in the area, the investigating garda said none of them captured the incident.
A man who was at the bottle bank, a farrier who had shod the defendant's daughter's pony, told the court he heard banging on a window and cursing and saw the complainant hit the defendant, as the accused was getting out of the car and Mr. Mullen lost his balance.
Judge John Coughlan dismissed the charge due to a conflict in the evidence.
