Justice minister will ‘appraise’ legal aid reform data


Jim O’Callaghan said he will make changes if they are needed, but said he will not give in to ‘what solicitors want’.
The justice minister said he will “appraise” the data around the criminal legal aid reforms and will make changes if he thinks they are needed, but said he will not give in to “what solicitors want”.
Jim O’Callaghan claimed that the “vast majority” of solicitors who provide legal aid services are doing so within the courts, and made an appeal to all solicitors to “come along” with their colleagues.
The Fianna Fáil minister said that following the start of the legal term on Monday, criminal cases are ongoing around the country.


He again pointed to weekly data received by his department, which shows the number of legal aid certificates that have been issued.
By October 2, some 2,400 certificates were issued.
However, data obtained by the Law Society shows that in August, the number of certificates issued fell by 86% from 2,868 in August 2025 to just 394 in 2026 for the same month.
The new 520-euro flat fee is supposed to represent five appearances – the average for criminal legal aid cases – plus an 8% increase in fees given to all criminal lawyers.
Under the old system, solicitors were given 240 euro for a first appearance with a legal aid client and 60 euro thereafter.
“I would appeal to solicitors to come along with the majority of our colleagues who are providing the service under the criminal legal aid scheme,” Mr O’Callaghan said on Thursday.
“It’s going to improve efficiencies within the court system, and that’s my primary focus: is to ensure that court users find themselves in a situation where the district court is efficiently used, rather than cases going on endlessly through adjournments, rather than through multiple certificates being issued.
“The legal term started on Monday. Criminal cases are ongoing throughout the country. You can see that in the reportage.”
Earlier this week, Chief Justice Donal O’Donnell expressed “concern” over the ongoing dispute, calling for it to be resolved.
Mr O’Callaghan said he agrees with the Chief Justice, but added: “I think it is important that the row is resolved, but unfortunately the Law Society believes that calling for the row to be resolved means I give in to what the solicitors want.”
Mr O’Callaghan said he has made a series of concessions to the Law Society through their engagements.
He said he will look at the weekly data and make any changes if necessary.
“I have no problem once I get the data… I have no problem appraising it, and if I think that changes need to be made, I will,” he added.
“But in terms of the Microsoft Excel sheet that I get to look at every Friday when it’s updated, my recollection from having looked at it the last time is they all have solicitors on it.
“I’m looking down to see where the solicitors are based, is their geographic spread, and the district courts are working in many parts of the country.
“I accept there is an issue in Dublin with solicitors withdrawing their services, but I also have to say, and I urge the Law Society to represent these people, there are solicitors who want to work and who think the scheme that I’ve put in place is a generous scheme, and their interests should also be represented.”